Sunday, September 23, 2012

James Medoff, Stagflation, the Phillips Curve, and the Greenspan Boom


James Medoff, my thesis advisor in graduate school and later my collaborator and business associate, died on Saturday, September 15 after a long struggle with multiple sclerosis.  In the field, he was probably best known for his work on labor market institutions, and particularly for his work with Richard Freeman on the impact of unionization.  But by the time I started working with him, most of that was in the past.  I was a student of macroeconomics, not labor economics, but I was intrigued by a paper he had written with Katharine Abraham entitled “Unemployment, Unsatisfied Demand for Labor, and Compensation Growth, 1956-1980.” It seemed to provide a critical missing piece in the puzzle of macroeconomics.

Why was there stagflation (stagnation and inflation at the same time) in the 1970’s?  When I was in graduate school, there were two popular (complementary) explanations.  First, the Fed had been too easy because it didn’t adequately account for the way inflation expectations would become ingrained.  (In the cartoon version of this idea, the Fed goes from believing in a static downward-sloping Phillips curve to realizing – much too late in the game – that the long-run Phillips curve is vertical, but in reality there were certainly some steps inbetween.)  Second, there were oil shocks, shocks to aggregate supply which drove prices up and employment down.  A third explanation you might also hear was that the Fed had responded to political pressure from the Johnson and Nixon (and possibly Carter) administrations and loosened at the wrong times.

Doubtless there was something to all of these ideas, but the Medoff-Abraham paper suggested a completely different explanation.  Essentially what it said was that there was not nearly as much “stag” in the stagflation as we thought.  The labor market, it suggested, had been booming during much of the 1970’s despite the appearance of high unemployment.  The implication was that the unemployment of the 1970’s was largely “structural” (at least that’s the term used in debates about today’s unemployment), and once you realized that, the accompanying inflation shouldn’t surprise you.

When I took James’ graduate course in 1989, this idea was particularly important, because the situation was beginning to reverse itself.  The plateau in structural unemployment lasted from maybe 1975 to maybe 1987, and after that it began to decline.  By the time I graduated, in 1994, this decline was well underway, and our data were suggesting that the US economy could support considerably lower unemployment rates without sparking inflation.  James was invited to the Fed’s meeting of academic consultants that year to make the case for lower unemployment, and I went along to help and observe the discussion.  As I recall, there were about 10 people at the table, and James was the only one saying that it was OK to keep interest rates low and let the unemployment rate fall further.

Naturally, rather than listen to a single maverick, the Fed kept raising rates, and maybe that was for the best, since the recovery turned out to be stronger than most people (including us) had expected.  But over the next few years, something unusual happened.  The unemployment rate kept coming down, and the inflation kept not happening, and now it was Alan Greenspan himself, not some out-of-the-mainstream labor economist from Harvard, who was insisting (against some substantial resistance) that it was OK to keep interest rates low and let the unemployment rate continue falling.

Did James Medoff ultimately influence monetary policy, and was he therefore partly responsible for the boom of the late 1990’s?  Who knows?  If I had Alan Greenspan’s ear, I might ask him.  At his funeral, James’ daughter Susanna said that, in fifth grade, she had wanted to dress up as her father for “Dress as Your Hero Day,” but the teacher wouldn’t let her, so she dressed as Alan Greenspan instead.  In those days, a lot of adults may have considered Greenspan a hero, but I doubt many other fifth graders did.  For the record, I still think Greenspan did a remarkable job with the macroeconomic aspects of monetary policy, and his hero status (since rescinded by most commentators) was not without justification.

In any case, I feel that the research I mentioned is relevant today in a couple of ways.  For one thing, the saga of structural-vs-cyclical unemployment goes on today.  Using techniques similar to those used by Abraham and Medoff, my best guess is that, after the long decline that began around 1988, structural unemployment reached a trough in 2005 and has been rising since then.  (However, I see no particular evidence of a discontinuous increase during the Great Recession, or immediately before or after, and the increase since 2005 has not been particularly rapid, so I don’t buy the view that “our problem is structural.”)

Another way the research is relevant is that it reframes the 1970’s.  By the end of the 1970’s, most economists were convinced that, as textbooks put it during my undergraduate years and maybe still do, “the long-run Phillips curve is vertical.”  In other words, there is no long-run tradeoff between unemployment and inflation.  In the minds of most economists this conclusion was necessitated by the experience of the 1970’s, during which it seemed to become obvious that higher inflation was not generally associated with lower unemployment.  But if much of the problem of the 1970’s was structural, then the conclusion is not so obvious.  Perhaps, conditioning on the structure of the labor market, a downward-sloping Phillips curve still exists, even in the long run.  Indeed, more recent evidence suggests that there is such a tradeoff after all, at least at low inflation rates.

This is important because the US seems to be in the middle of that tradeoff right now.  If you believe there is no tradeoff, if you believe the long-run Phillips curve is vertical, then it's hard to explain how there's still any inflation at all after almost 5 years during which we had first an extremely deep recession and then a painfully slow recovery that has left output still well below any reasonable estimate of the economy's potential.  After 5 years, we should surely be making our way toward the long run, that vertical Phillips curve at full employment. If we're not, it must be because demand is astonishingly weak, and that astonishingly weak demand should be associated with an inflation rate that falls lower and lower until it becomes negative. (This is the flip side of an overheated economy that produces ever-accelerating inflation.) But that isn't happening. Instead we're seeing something that looks a little bit like the old-fashioned downward-sloping static Phillips curve, where low, but not necessarily falling, inflation rates are associated with persistent excess unemployment.

I admit this isn't what I expected. I wrote a blog post a couple of years ago predicting deflation. Even after having questioned the conventional wisdom, I had found it too strong to resist. The vertical long-run Phillips curve, I thought, might not be quite right, but it was "a close enough approximation," and if I denied this, I'd face excommunication from the Church of Macroeconomics. Deflation was coming, I thought.  I was wrong.

I never got a chance to discuss this question with James. During his last years he found it increasingly difficult to think and express himself clearly, so it's unlikely we could have had a productive discussion. But I can imagine what he would have said 20 years ago. He would have talked about his contacts in industry and how they weren't about to destroy morale by cutting wages, even if the economy stayed weak for several years. After some discussion I think we would have come to the conclusion that the vertical long-run Phillips curve was actually a pretty crummy approximation. That's certainly what I think now. I'm going to have to pay more attention in the future to what Hypothetical James Medoff has to say. He lives on.









DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

31 comments:

Will said...

Very interesting. What specific structural problems in the 70s did Medoff point to?

Andy Harless said...

Abraham (who is still very much alive AFAIK) and Medoff didn't point to specific structural problems; they just showed that the pattern of wage growth could be explained by changes in unsatisfied demand for labor. Since this high unsatisfied demand coexisted with high unemployment, the logical conclusion was that the unemployment was structural, but I don't recall if they specifically said that. In my thesis I tried to get a little more specific about what might have been going on, but I have to say I had only limited success. FWIW,

1. The shift from goods-producing to service-producing industries accelerated in the 1970's and then slowed down (perhaps because there was so little left of the goods-producing industries) in the late 1980's. Presumably people who lost jobs in goods-producing industries were not immediately a good fit in service-producing industries.

2. There was a shift in labor demand from east to west during the 70's and 80's (partly due to the oil boom, but it continued through the oil bust and included the West Coast). Presumably people who lost jobs in the East couldn't easily relocate to take jobs in the West.

3. This wasn't in my thesis, because I didn't have empirical data about it, but an obvious thing that was going on was the bulge in the young adult population due to the 1950's baby boom. Presumably there were a disproportionate number of people with little or no experience looking for jobs in the 70's and 80's, and they may not have been qualified for the jobs that were available.

Andrew Sacher said...

I am very sorry to hear of dr. Medoff's passing and illness. I took one of his classes in the spring of 2000 and I learned more from the experience than anything else I took that semester. The class was unfortunately not good, with a rigor below what i thought appropriate for a university course. But I wrote prof. Medoff an anonymous, nasty email about the content of the class and I will never forget how graceful and solicitous he was in reply. It was an example of being open and fair minded, even to critics, that I admire to this day, and I think speaks very highly to his character in handling a difficult illness. Thank you Dr. Medoff.

Listado de Razas de Perros y Gatos said...

Rest in peace.

Panda said...

I hope you had a good life.

Oso Panda said...

You must not feel sadness for his death. It must be remembered by tolo the good that has been given and left us.

Thylacinus cynocephalus said...

Rest in peace

auto accident attorneys said...

First of all thanks so much for creating this script. It is going to make the lives of so many teachers across our board so much easier.

Questions about Becoming a CNA said...

The unemployment rate kept coming down, and the inflation kept not happening, and now it was Alan Greenspan himself

traffic lawyer Florida said...

The labor market, it suggested, had been booming during much of the 1970’s despite the appearance of high unemployment.

professional cv writing services said...

When virtue and modesty enlighten her charms, the lustre of a beautiful woman is brighter than the stars of heaven, and the influence of her power it is in vain to resist.

agen sbobet terpercaya said...

Truly a great work is here. This is the article to whom I was searching for a long time and now I found it here, I enjoy after finding this precious post and also would like to say thanks to you for such a informative post. You have done a very impressive work.
agen bola piala dunia

338a said...

Actually I am not habituate to reply a comment on blogs but this blog caught my attention and I am compelled to write a comment here to express my gratitude to you. I would like to appreciate for this awesome work. agen sbobet, tebak angka togel

muzammal khan said...

Truly a great work is here. This is the article to whom I was searching for a long. hop over to these guys

Yasir Khalid said...

She’s matured with every record she’s released, and her standing in the music community is still rising. If the world hasn’t noticed yet, it better get ready. brasil novinhas

Yasir Khalid said...

Certainly, he views the central bank as only having the power to alter the term structure of debt maturity -- something he believes has no real macroeconomic impact. www.1call.ms

salman khan said...

I’m telling not only won’t developing a lot of money generate rising costs in the US.it also won’t generate rising costs in Chinese suppliers. tickets

muzammal khan said...

In field tests of maize over the last three decades, powder therapies of the viruses have assisted boost. professional house cleaning

muzammal khan said...

For the maize that is already placed, 2% of the overall vegetation is increasing already, in evaluation. Floor tiling Marlborough

muzammal khan said...

Abraham (who is still very much alive AFAIK) and Medoff didn't point to specific structural problems; they just showed. online manifestation miracle

muzammal khan said...

Abraham (who is still very much alive AFAIK) and Medoff didn't point to specific structural problems; they just showed that the. straight from the source

Mirna R. Smith said...

my business is throughout this posting to help you out beside your short cheap needs. the particular Move forward mortgage might be a glorious product nonetheless as product or service that may permits numerous people, like everyone else, day-to-day! every time easy auto title loans emergencies happen, don’t anxiety! appear notice men and girls. we've got an inclination to all or any dwell at currently there on the marketplace for you in conjunction with the majority of us depend on promoting someone beside your cheap needs.

Mirna R. Smith said...

After {you can|you'll|you'll be prepared to} be purchased in to be able to North yank nation day cash advances to possess sort of our advance and besides Size Loan from the bank, apart from {is likely|is presumably going} to your initial compensation altogether likelihood be fascination free of charge, you may receive payday loan to satisfy sort of our folks, notice sort of our conveniences and spot the feeling associated with the strategy throughout that funding kind North yank nation day cash advances will amendment you to in conjunction beside your quick money wishes.

Mirna R. Smith said...

USA day money advances in Il possesses many various loan choices so on be wise that embody, day money advances, day and Fitting monetary loans, besides title loan to Automobile construct monetary loans. the bulk consider aiding you choose on for the proper loan product or service which could assist you to satisfy your own economic desires.

Yasir Khalid said...

In fact, it seems possible to me that the Taylor rule should include estimates of the impact of these imperfections (e.g. "binding credit constraints") rather than the output gap itself, which might be a very flawed proxy. office partitioning

Yasir Khalid said...

In the end, exchange via money only lubricates a system of exchange of some goods and services for other goods and services. how can i naturally get rid of cellulite

Tanveer Ali said...

Because you are the one who marketed your home, and not the lenders, you would be able to get the money after paying the residence broker for his or her services. Sell your home fast

Yasir Khalid said...

That's certainly what I think now. I'm going to have to pay more attention in the future to what Hypothetical James Medoff has to say. building a photography website

IndoWinPoker.net Judi Poker Domino 99 Online Indonesia dengan RakeBack 0.3% dan Referral 20% said...

Great blog you have here. Lots of blogs like yours cover subjects that can’t be found in magazines and newspapers. I don’t know how we got by 10 years ago with just magazines and newspapers.
INIPOKER.NET Judi Domino 99 Online Terpercaya Indonesia, Poker757.net Agen Judi Poker Domino 99 Online dengan Bonus CashBack 0,3% dan Bonus Referral 20%, Itupoker.net Agen Judi Domino 99 Online

Anonymous said...

'm going to have to pay more attention in the future to REBEL MOUSE

Alex Edward said...

I love the topic of these post, it is quite informative for me
Bane Cosplay