Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Inflation vs. Price Level Targeting


I don’t have time for a real blog post, but here’s a quickie in an attempt to keep this blog alive.

Dave Altig and Mike Bryan of the Atlanta Fed’s Macroblog argue here that it wouldn’t make much difference if the Fed were doing price level targeting (in which the future target path stays fixed even when you miss a target, so you need catch-up inflation or catch-up disinflation) rather than inflation targeting.  Their evidence is mostly from a chart like this (my replication using monthly data, which you can confirm looks fairly similar to theirs which appears to use annual data):



Quoting from their blog post:
Consider the first point on the graph, corresponding to the year 1993….This point on the graph answers the following question:

By what percent would the actual level of the personal consumption expenditure price index differ from a price-level target that grew by 2 percent per year beginning in 1993?
The succeeding points in the chart answer that same question for the years 1994 through 2009.

In my case, as I said, it’s monthly, and it goes all the way to 2012, but the idea is the same.

OK, fine.  So here it looks like a price level target would have produced roughly the same results as the Fed’s (unofficial until January 2012) inflation target, and whether it would have undershot or overshot depends on when you start the target path.  In particular, people who argue that we are undershooting right now don’t seem to have much of an argument unless they start the target path in 2008 or later.

BUT…

The problem with this chart is that it uses the headline PCE price index, whereas during most of this time (until January 2012 when the official inflation targeting policy was introduced), the Fed was perceived to be targeting core PCE inflation (excluding food and energy, that is), not headline inflation.  Price-setters were making their decisions largely under that assumption.  It makes no sense to go back to 1993 and set up a target path using the headline price index when that index was irrelevant to the policy that the Fed seemed to be following at the time.

Moreover, targeting the price level using the headline price index is a bad idea anyhow.   If you're going to use a price level target (and I do think it would be better than an inflation target), then you don't want to use a price index that will be subject to shocks that are volatile but persistent. A one-time increase in the price of oil should not require a subsequent compensating decline in other prices to offset it (nor should a one-time decrease in the price of oil require a subsequent burst of inflation to offset it). Theoretical arguments would suggest using an index of sticky prices, but the core is a reasonable approximation.

Here’s what my chart above looks like when you use the core PCE price index instead of the headline index.


Very different.  By this measure we are undershooting now no matter when you start the target path.  And unless you cherry-pick the starting point in 2003 or 2011, the size of the undershoot is not insignificant.  If you compare to the 1990’s, the Fed was already slightly behind when the Great Recession began, and they have fallen further and further behind since then.  Price level targeting, using the core price index, would require the Fed to promise a significant amount of catch-up inflation in the coming years.



DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

37 comments:

Anonymous said...

The premise that the Fed was targeting core prices since 1993 is incorrect. They moved to core PCE deflator around the turn of the century.

In its "Monetary Policy Report to the Congress" ("Humphrey-Hawkins Report") from February 17, 2000 the FOMC said it was changing its primary measure of inflation from the consumer price index to the "chain-type price index for personal consumption expenditures".[3]

Andy Harless said...

Well, they hadn't really started to settle on 2% either until around the turn of the century, so the whole idea of including the 1990's is questionable (and data on inflation expectations suggests that 2.5% would have been a more accurate estimate of their perceived CPI target). In any case the perception was always that the Fed would not be strongly influenced by one-time changes in food and energy prices. To some extent this was because they were perceived to focus on core prices, and to some extent it was because they were perceived to be targeting the inflation rate, rather than the price level, and were therefore not expected to compensate for changes that had already taken place. If they had been targeting the price level, it would not have made sense to use a headline index.

Perros y Gatos said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Perros y Gatos said...

A government, a country should work as a house. We can not spend more than we earn and thus avoid debt.

Razas de Perro y Gatos
Mis Videos Preferidos en Youtube

Christopher said...

I think that price level targeting by means of the core price index will cause the Fed to promise a significant amount of catch-up inflation in upcoming years.

Faraz Ali said...

Legitimate Typing Jobs Earn $250 Or More Daily Work At Home
With Hundreds Of Companies As A Home Typist. Never Pay Any Signup Fees To Work With These Companies. Work With As Many Companies As You Like For An Unlimited Income (Http://Tinyurl.Com/3gce3ot) Ids (11608)

yakenzu toby said...

I like your blog post. Keep on writing this type of great stuff. I'll make sure to follow up on your blog in the future.Very good, informative piece. Smartly done as all the time. agen bola, judi bola

cara baru said...

Howdy this is kind of of off topic but I was wondering if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding experience so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be enormously appreciated.. agen sbobet

ligaplayer.com said...

There is lot of information and they are very innovative and informative. I have read the article very well and it seems to me awesome. bola tangkas

acmbet.net said...

Hello I must say for this well prepared information.I am now bookmarking this website for future reference.Keep up the good work.

Alex Edward said...

Your post is quite informative for me
https://hedford.com

deposit ion casino said...

This is certainly very nice. Solitary stare upon tips subject matter when we are bowled over. We are curious about this sort of products. Solitary appreciate your guidelines, and number the effort in this. Please keep editing. togel online. togel online

Wallet passbee Media said...

I’m planning to get my nose straightened… I find this is good info for people who would try to know something about Wallet passbee Media

Watersound real estate said...

I got it my elucidation from over here. I very much urge his/her workings with the constructive enlightening information. Thanks a lot…Watersound real estate

Apple Ibeacon said...

I do think in which price degree concentrating on through the central price list causes the Feasted for you to guarantee an important number of catch-up inflation with upcoming decades. Apple Ibeacon

muzammal khan said...

Always musicals and handled problems that impacted younger ladies of colour; this was an awesome interval of my lifestyle. Shauntay Allow, who is now a participant of. jual

Yasir Khalid said...

In particular, individuals who claim that we are undershooting right now don’t seem to have much of an discussion unless they begin the focus on direction in 2008 or later. Agen Judi

salman khan said...

The Buddhist way to all of this is quite authentic, really. Buddhism is aware of of that from the viewpoint of ego the possibilities of deficiency of way of lifestyle is generally difficult. ct bat removal

salman khan said...

Demonstrates address all sections of the market (like AHR Expo) or focus on particular sections (various organization events) seem to be the most effective. WII ISO

salman khan said...

Demonstrates address all sections of the market (like AHR Expo) or focus on particular sections (various organization events) seem to be the most effective. WII ISO

salman khan said...

I've already started using some of them. There wasnt a major growth but my boobs were a little more plump and full. Disappointed that it did not include a miter guide. carpet cleaners rowlett tx

salman khan said...

Richards worked as a Master Plumber before working at Viega, and has positive things to say about a career in plumbing. Richards became a product trainer at Viega after he was laid off from his job in 2010. “I saw the opening for the trainer position with Viega and after using their products. link m88

Yasir Khalid said...

Surely the Fed could alter expectations of future monetary policy in such a way that the resulting increase in private spending would be enough to offset the decreased spending due to fiscal tightening. Just think, for example, if the Fed were to increase its long-run inflation target. additional info read

Davids Flys said...

I am very much confident that this is very nice Posting done by you. I always find you your blog interesting. keep on posting such nice updates as become very important to impact your thoughts and content, the Facebook will give you this platform to show your statistic. http://janganmo.blogspot.com/2014/07/vizzyus-safety-url-monetize.html

salman khan said...

There is a saying in the Zen personalized, “Birth and deficiency of way of lifestyle are the excellent problem.” That is where actual Buddhist perform out needs primary. more information to follow

Yasir Khalid said...

Often it is the amazing deficiency of way of lifestyle of someone near that provides this home; and then the regularity of medical center trips and memorials gradually begins to select up amount, like a drumbeat in the forests. make sure you follow them

invitations click here said...

hanks, I've been searching for facts about this subject matter for years and yours is the best I have found so far.Bank Jobs.hanks,invitations click here

yogesh kumawat said...

Heya, I stumbled onto your website when using the yahoo and google though trying to find this type of fairly very helpful write-up plus your write-up is apparently instead fulfilling to be able to my opinion. Printed Circuit Board Supplier

JUDI BOLA ituBola.net said...

Thank you for this conversation and I saw lately your description about Eurozone which is apparent we keep more cash but too much is too much we were incorrect about the BOLA PELANGI AGEN BOLA SBOBET IBCBET CASINO 338A TANGKAS TOGEL ONLINE INDONESIA TERPERCAYA, DOMINO 99 ituDomino, Poker757.net Agen Judi Poker Domino 99 Online dengan Bonus CashBack 0,3% dan Bonus Referral 20%

INIPOKER.NET said...

Thanks for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more information? It is extremely helpful for me. agen sbobet terbaik

mical clark said...

It took us three years to build the NeXT computer. If we'd given customers what they said they wanted, we'd have built a computer they'd have been happy with a year after we spoke to them - not something they'd want now.
Sleeping Tablets Online

Yasir Khalid said...

The Fed has been missing its targets for inflation and unemployment for some time now; it's not clear why giving it another target to miss is supposed to be a panacea. truth about cellulite symulast

Tanveer Ali said...

This is particularly essential since you would always have to take into account that the purpose you can industry your home is to pay off your excellent economical debt to avoid a residence foreclosure. Fast Property Sale

mical clark said...

Diligence is the mother of good fortune.
Valium Online

salman khan said...

I didn't do that, I'm still just beginning but I can see how valuable having more stitch options is going to be and I've already started using some of them. There wasnt a major growth but my boobs were a little more plump and full. fifacoins goedkoop

Tanveer Ali said...

Selecting the right toy can seem frustrating, but it doesn't have to be. Here are some guidelines for getting the right toy. Look at brands. next page

Robert Glenn said...

This post is quite fantastic, i am completely agree with your statement
Leon Kennedy Costume