Friday, December 12, 2008

Deflation, Recession, and Aggregate Supply

There has been a lot of talk (some of it from me) about the possibility of deflation in the US. Deflation would be a problem for a couple of reasons: first, deflation would make it more difficult to engineer an economic recovery; second, deflation could result in a “death spiral” like what happened (according to one interpretation) during the early 1930’s. The latter problem is a lot scarier, if you think it’s a serious possibility. There is, in my opinion, a good chance of some deflation, but, as I will argue, I don’t think the death spiral scenario is something we need to worry about today.

The death spiral would occur because of a positive feedback loop (vicious circle) between deflation and economic weakness. Even mild deflation deters long-term capital expenditures by making them less profitable. (Why build a factory, for example, if you expect product prices to go down year after year?) Moderate deflation deters even short-term capital expenditures. (Why buy a computer if declining revenues will barely allow you to recoup the cost?) When deflation becomes severe, even expenditures for consumer durables are significantly reduced. (Why replace your refrigerator this year, when it’s going to be cheaper next year?) Because of these effects, deflation reduces aggregate demand, and does so more rapidly as the deflation rate increases. Weaker demand, as everyone knows, tends to lead to lower prices. Thus it’s possible to imagine an economic implosion where deflation and economic depression feed on each other and become ever more severe.

As I said, that is, according to one interpretation, what happened (or began to happen) during the early 1930s. President Roosevelt managed to put an end (at least temporarily) to the deflation, in part by devaluing the dollar. It’s not clear whether devaluing the dollar would be an option today, because other countries might counter with intervention designed to nullify any US attempt to intervene against the dollar. Fortunately, however, there are many other tools we can use to avoid the kind of severe deflation that faced Roosevelt when he took office. Working against the positive feedback loop of deflation and depression, there is a negative feedback process: the worse the deflation becomes (or is expected to become), the more authorities will be willing to use unconventional policies to stop it.

Stopping deflation should not be very hard at all, if you’re willing to accept the side effects of your deflation cure. Most discussions of this topic have focused on the demand side: the Fed could get people to start buying things by dropping money from a helicopter; or it could buy stock and increase demand by corporations and stockholders; etc. But when it comes to stopping deflation, demand policies are the hard way. To continue my side effects metaphor: if you insist on using the less powerful drug that has fewer side effects, you may have to give ridiculously high doses before the patient responds. The easy way to stop deflation – the drug to try once hair loss and vomiting become less of an issue than the disease itself – is to reduce supply rather than increase demand.

During normal times, economists and policymakers spend a lot of time trying to figure out ways to increase supply. It’s not an easy task. Cut taxes, to improve incentives for private investment? Raise taxes, to stop consumer spending from crowding out private investment? Invest more in public infrastructure to make the economy more efficient? Invest less in public infrastructure, to make the resources available to the private sector? It’s a tough game.

The game gets a lot easier when your objective is to let the other guy win. One obvious way to reduce supply, for example, is to encourage the formation of cartels. That’s something that Roosevelt tried, though some of his programs were struck down by the Supreme Court. Scholars can debate what the overall effect was on economic growth, or whether, after already devaluing the dollar, such additional measures against deflation did more harm than good, but it’s hardly open to question that encouraging cartels will tend to raise – and in the context of a deflation, stabilize – prices.

One particular form of cartel encouragement, which would certainly go over well with some of the current government’s constituents, would be to strengthen labor unions (one thing that Roosevelt did). Under normal conditions, some economists might argue that labor unions, despite their cartel aspect, often increase supply by such means as improving morale and decreasing unnecessary turnover. But it’s certainly true that unions are particularly loath to accept cuts in wages. In the context of a deflation, the stabilization of wages would tend to stabilize prices, since it would make it unprofitable for firms to cut prices. (Paul Krugman touches on this issue in some recent blog entries. He mentions a recent academic paper, but I like to give credit to Brad DeLong and Larry Summers – in a paper that I read nearly 20 years ago before it was published – for making intellectually respectable the idea that labor unions can help the economy by helping protect against deflation. I should also acknowledge James Tobin, who worked out the theory underlying the “death spiral” concept as discussed above.)

Another way to reduce aggregate supply is by inducing inflationary expectations to replace deflationary ones, so that producers are less willing to sell at low prices. This is largely a psychological issue, but if the Fed shows a willingness to take demand-side policies to extremes, even if the extremes are still not enough to solve the demand problem, they may affect supply. For example, when James Hamilton suggests (somewhat whimsically and just for the sake of argument) that the Fed could buy up the entire national debt, one might think of it as a demand-side policy, but I would suggest that its supply-side impact would be more important. With Treasury interest rates, even for long-term bonds, already quite low, it’s not clear that reducing them to zero would have much effect on demand. But when people observe the Fed buying up the entire national debt, the perception that “Helicopter Ben has gone wild” can’t help but make an impact.

And so on. Figuring out ways to produce less, rather than more, shouldn’t be very difficult. Naturally, reducing aggregate supply – trying to make the economy produce less at any given price – is not going to be directly conducive to economic recovery. But by reversing deflation and thereby making traditional demand-side tools more effective, it could be indirectly beneficial.

The death spiral should be pretty easy to avoid. The problem is that, once you get to the point where you have to make avoiding the death spiral a priority, you end up with this conflict between policies that reverse deflation and policies that increase production. It’s not the 1930’s, but it’s an experience I would hope to avoid.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management.

42 comments:

Billy the Kid said...

This was a great post. You´re a very pedagogical economist. Please, keep writing posts like this one.

Larry Byzantine's Blog said...

First of all deflation is good for the poor as their purchasing power increases.

Secondly, many economists think they can centrally plan the economy. Haven't we already seen throughout history that that doesn't work?

Why not let the bubble burst, the recession linger for a year or two and then let the market and entrepreneurs get us out of this hole? They always have in the past.

Stevie b. said...

Just discovered your blog. Very thought-provoking. Billy the Kid says keep writing posts like this one - I'd say keep writing posts like this one and the previous one as well!

Stevie b. said...

p.s. to clarify "previous post", I mean of course the Dec 8 post
on monetizing debt and inflation - not the blogkeeping stuff.

Ardent Economist said...

Interesting and thought provoking post, please keep more of this type stuff coming! The idea about labor cartels is certainly one I've never heard of and quite a unique approach.

I was hoping you could discuss the long-term t-bond and if you think this fall in the long-term interest rate is sustainable over the short to medium term? You also mentioned that its not clear that reducing it will spur long-term investment, but presumably at some level, investors that have liabilities in the very long-term (pensions? insurers?) would be much better off investing in the long-term in other forms as opposed to in 30 year bonds?

Anonymous said...

How about giving some real life examples of decreasing aggregate supply? Did it work? What little I know about FDR's attempts in this direction was to put a floor under prices in 1937 and the stock market crashed, again. Personally, I think that any kind of governmental intervention extends the problem. Japan is still in a Depression with all of their spending and our 1929-1942 Depression was never arrested by the most active (to date) of governments. Its hard enough to plan your own way when things are tough but with Congress writing bills the road out gets more complicated.

Billy the Kid said...

Dear Sir Harless:

Where are you? No recent posts...

Stevie b. said...

Like billy-the-kid, I'd like to follow your blog - but that means I need an actual blog to follow! So how about something new somewhat more frequently please, so we can have more food-for-thought - as I'm withering on this sparse diet you've got us on so far!

car accident attorney said...

I positively enjoying each little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you

Anonymous said...

I am really so glad to find this matter. I am actually looking for it. So grateful now, that there are lots of articles regarding this topic. coffee tables

http://bestukonlinecasinobonusuk.co.uk/ said...

Stopping deflation should not be very hard at all, if you’re willing to accept the side effects of your deflation cure

become certified nursing assistant said...

This is largely a psychological issue, but if the Fed shows a willingness to take demand-side policies

http://calosgrantt.angelfire.com/ said...

Scholars can debate what the overall effect was on economic growth, or whether, after already devaluing the dollar

论文网站 said...

With thanks in the care and attention in the rock, it's just what exactly I'd prefer. For the reason that carry out on the 14 already as well as I always do not own an opportunity to manner money that have been plans promptly, an important web page Instant messaging attractive hand. Needed claim out the style on the place for your wonderful convey for around commenting.

judi bola said...

Thank you for for sharing so great thing to us. I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post nice post, thanks for sharing. taruhan bola teraman

agen sbobet said...

this is true for a growing credit cycle, but if we are now in a deleveraging cycle, the optimists will be destroyed. the people will learn the opposite behavior, rushing for the exits instead of rushing to borrow, and the bottom will be hit when only 'fools' are optimistic. most people will count themselves winners if they didn't go bankrupt. bola tangkas

salman khan said...

For more compact nations, developing a lot of cash is risky, because rising costs can be a self-fulfilling prediction, both inwardly and outwardly.direct flights to las vegas

salman khan said...

Carter Brown, CEO of Boulder Electric Vehicle and a Precision customer, invented the electric service truck, and convinced Robichaud to test-drive the truck that he felt would be a perfect fit for the service industry because of the short routes service technicians drive daily. TUBE

salman khan said...

Carter Brown, CEO of Boulder Electric Vehicle and a Precision customer, invented the electric service truck, and convinced Robichaud to test-drive the truck that he felt would be a perfect fit for the service industry because of the short routes service technicians drive daily. TUBE

salman khan said...

Carter Brown, CEO of Boulder Electric Vehicle and a Precision customer, invented the electric service truck, and convinced Robichaud to test-drive the truck that he felt would be a perfect fit for the service industry because of the short routes service technicians drive daily. TUBE

Yasir Khalid said...

In Apr, Wayne Bruggers of The Courier-Journal had written a popular article on the effect of non-renewable fuel ash on Stick Rune Road citizens and their fight with LG&E. Click here to enjoy live webcam with shemales

Yasir Khalid said...

ok, I just read Mr. Mankiws blog which sent me here and the first entry I read wasn't all that comforting. The last thing the world needs is another Keynesian. So I have some things I'd like to point out. venus factor weight loss

dawnc said...

Are you presently long lasting having getting some type of expenditures which will will’t hold on tight until eventually your individual resultant pay day progress will happen? unit of activity you presently hooked having Associate in Nursing quick automotive cash advances montgomery resolve? meant for the tiniest amount bit quick sharp emergency you’re under-going, any bucks pay day loan can assist you get the resources you will would really like quickly! usually, the whole teach generally demands simply fifteen units or maybe technique less.

salman khan said...

But there is another aspect of interest that not only can understand it, but already knows about it. There is a saying in the Zen customized, “Birth and lack of way of life are the outstanding problem.” That is where actual Buddhist work out needs primary. Igor Cornelsen

Yasir Khalid said...

BeerTap reviews Green Lakes Organic Ale from the Deschutes Brewery, the first beer sourced from Salmon-Safe hops grown in Oregon's Willamette Valley. Here at Salmon-Safe, our mantra is "Drink like a fish. Salmon need clean water and so do you." Mike Livak

Yasir Khalid said...

Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have. Susan McGall

Yasir Khalid said...

I am always searching online for articles that can help me. There is obviously a lot to know about this. I think you made some good points in Features also. EV or if there are any design changes we would like to have included with future vans,” said Robichaud. Sultan Alhokai

Yasir Khalid said...

First, arbitrage type yield adjustments in response to the actual announcement would be nearly instantaneous, and therefore the flow of funds reflecting the initial portfolio adjustment in the banking system would be relatively small. office partitioning

Yasir Khalid said...

The life of a person is priceless and should not have any kind of set price. When it comes to adopting or "buying" a child, this is a great thing and can bring great joy. check my source

Tanveer Ali said...

Exciting and believed invoking publish, please keep more of this kind things coming! The concept about work cartels is certainly one I've never observed of and quite a exclusive approach. best site

salman khan said...

We are existing because we are not dead; though our daily way of life is packed with the emotional jumble of concepts, feelings, and applications, at another stage we have a low-level careful system that is always looking out for existential threats. old school new body complaints

Robert Kickinger said...

I say let the economy crash. All this socialist bs is ruining what America was founded upon.

My site

Yasir Khalid said...

I always want and love reading quality contents. Keep sharing. Best wishes for your further efforts. Well done. check my source

Tanveer Ali said...

Clinton was a Democratic average who led the nation at time that the community feeling was highly to the Right. click to read

Tanveer Ali said...

I like "lowness," the more proper nouns would be "low" or "lowliness" but "lowness" certainly drives it home. I might have used "lowsomeness" because it's more of a mouthful, more fun to pronounce. click here

Tanveer Ali said...

Below is my history of the top ten factors you should create material and allow them to be launched for online. click here

Tanveer Ali said...

He was disliked by individuals for being out of phase with this community feeling. the venus factor reviews

Tanveer Ali said...

Discovered a duplicate of it) published for the youngsters in my system to execute at the Children’s Medical center. We created our own outfits and the youngsters who conducted were between the age groups of 8 and 11. Sell My Home

Tanveer Ali said...

There is a deficiency of interest in the demonstration and the addition of the distribute gambling was just place in to extensive the image. Taruhan Bola

salman khan said...

It turned out much more practical than I thought! Aside from just letting him chew on the links, I also used a chain of them to hook up toys to the stroller bars, so he could freely play with them but they won't drop to the floor. Just remember to buy spare filters, light bulbs and the powercable. Sell my property fast

Jagadpoker.com Agen Texas Poker dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya said...

In the end, exchange via money only lubricates a system of exchange of some goods and services for other goods and services. Senangpoker.com Agen Judi Poker dan Domino Online Terpercaya Indonesia, Daunpkr.com Agen Poker Domino Online Indonesia Terbaik Terbesar dan Terpercaya, ituCasino.net AGEN JUDI TOGEL DAN CASINO ONLINE INDONESIA

Tanveer Ali said...

Youngsters often put things in their mouth. Toys that contain little areas are a serious chocking threat and should not be chosen. Our site