Wednesday, January 9, 2013

Inflation vs. Price Level Targeting


I don’t have time for a real blog post, but here’s a quickie in an attempt to keep this blog alive.

Dave Altig and Mike Bryan of the Atlanta Fed’s Macroblog argue here that it wouldn’t make much difference if the Fed were doing price level targeting (in which the future target path stays fixed even when you miss a target, so you need catch-up inflation or catch-up disinflation) rather than inflation targeting.  Their evidence is mostly from a chart like this (my replication using monthly data, which you can confirm looks fairly similar to theirs which appears to use annual data):



Quoting from their blog post:
Consider the first point on the graph, corresponding to the year 1993….This point on the graph answers the following question:

By what percent would the actual level of the personal consumption expenditure price index differ from a price-level target that grew by 2 percent per year beginning in 1993?
The succeeding points in the chart answer that same question for the years 1994 through 2009.

In my case, as I said, it’s monthly, and it goes all the way to 2012, but the idea is the same.

OK, fine.  So here it looks like a price level target would have produced roughly the same results as the Fed’s (unofficial until January 2012) inflation target, and whether it would have undershot or overshot depends on when you start the target path.  In particular, people who argue that we are undershooting right now don’t seem to have much of an argument unless they start the target path in 2008 or later.

BUT…

The problem with this chart is that it uses the headline PCE price index, whereas during most of this time (until January 2012 when the official inflation targeting policy was introduced), the Fed was perceived to be targeting core PCE inflation (excluding food and energy, that is), not headline inflation.  Price-setters were making their decisions largely under that assumption.  It makes no sense to go back to 1993 and set up a target path using the headline price index when that index was irrelevant to the policy that the Fed seemed to be following at the time.

Moreover, targeting the price level using the headline price index is a bad idea anyhow.   If you're going to use a price level target (and I do think it would be better than an inflation target), then you don't want to use a price index that will be subject to shocks that are volatile but persistent. A one-time increase in the price of oil should not require a subsequent compensating decline in other prices to offset it (nor should a one-time decrease in the price of oil require a subsequent burst of inflation to offset it). Theoretical arguments would suggest using an index of sticky prices, but the core is a reasonable approximation.

Here’s what my chart above looks like when you use the core PCE price index instead of the headline index.


Very different.  By this measure we are undershooting now no matter when you start the target path.  And unless you cherry-pick the starting point in 2003 or 2011, the size of the undershoot is not insignificant.  If you compare to the 1990’s, the Fed was already slightly behind when the Great Recession began, and they have fallen further and further behind since then.  Price level targeting, using the core price index, would require the Fed to promise a significant amount of catch-up inflation in the coming years.



DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

410 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 410 of 410
meldaresearch said...

Students should ensure that quality of essays offered match their prices. All quality custom essay should ensure that customers’ private details are kept in privacy. This also applies when one needs pre written research papers.

kawinha said...

สล็อตออนไลน์
โกลเด้นสล็อต
goldenslot
golden slot

Unknown said...

state bank of india balance check

hằng vũ said...

I like this post because it contains a lot of useful information to read, maybe everyone will like me. I hope this post of yours will be more appreciated by it really excellent, i enjoyed it, thanks for posting it.
cá koi mini, friv4 school 2020, friv Games for kids 2019, Jogo quente 2019

ayu manis said...

your article very good and also your information very helpful visitors, thanks
Thank you for sharing us education, please kindly visit mine :D
situs poker online
situs slot online
togel online
agen poker v
situs kasino

cửa cuốn khe thoáng said...

Thank you very much for the article information. I will share it with my friends.

Puremelda said...

No one would like to have a struggling future, and thus necessary to start early and set the path straight with the Essay Writing Help Service that we offer the best Custom Writing Company to the students around the globe.

Puremelda said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Unknown said...

By contracting with a transport company like Rokn Najd, we are the best transport company in Riyadh with experience that you can guarantee to reduce the burden at every step.If you have the idea of ​​saving and relying on yourself in moving furniture, the disadvantages of this idea may outweigh the budget considerations, here are four reasons why Choosing a furniture company in Mecca is a great idea:

شركة نقل عفش
شركة نقل اثاث من الرياض الى جدة

شركة نقل عفش من الرياض الى جدة
شركة نقل عفش بجازان

ahmerali said...

Great article and post, we will submit your article to our social network and our twitter, thanks and please post our comment, as we will put a link as well on our blog to your article.
Happy New Year Wishes

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 410 of 410   Newer› Newest»