Friday, August 28, 2009

Job Losses Are Not the Problem

It is sometimes argued that recessions benefit the economy by allowing the destruction of old, inefficient economic structures so that newer, better ones can be created to replace them. On the surface, this story might seem to apply to the recent recession: ostensibly, a lot of useless jobs in finance, real estate, and construction were destroyed, as well as perhaps old manufacturing jobs that hadn’t caught up with the latest technology, and jobs in retail trade that needed to be replaced by the Internet, and so on. But there’s one problem with that point of view: overall (at least during the first four quarters of the recession, up through the end of 2008, for which we have the relevant data), there weren’t an unusually large number of total jobs being destroyed.

But...but...but...haven’t we been hearing about large numbers of job losses month after month since the recession began? Sort of. We’ve been hearing about large numbers of net job losses. That is, the number of jobs that have been lost has been a lot more than the number that have been created. And a lot of job losers have ended up collecting unemployment insurance for a long time, sending the figures for continuing claims up to records, instead of getting new jobs. But the gross number of jobs being destroyed has not been unusually large. In fact, relative to the overall level of employment, job destruction was happening at a faster rate during the boom of the late 1990s than it was during the last quarter of 2008.

How can that be? For one thing, when you take out the business cycle, there seems to have been a general downward trend in the rate of job destruction over the past 10 years. More important, the rate of job creation also had a downward trend, and it dropped to new lows during the recession of 2008. If you lost a job in 1999, you weren’t actually all that atypical, but it wasn’t a big problem, because typically, you could find a new job fairly easily. If you lost a job in 2008, you were (typically) out of luck.




source: Business Employment Dynamics data from the Bureau of Labor Statistics



The fact is, job creation and job destruction take place during booms at rates that are not dramatically different from the rates during recessions. It’s just the difference between the two that changes. In a typical boom quarter, about 7 million jobs are destroyed, and about 8 million are created. In a typical recession quarter, about 8 million are destroyed and about 7 million are created. There just isn’t much support for the idea that recessions give us a special ability to reallocate resources more intensely than we do during a boom or a period of normal growth. “Creative destruction” is a dynamic process that continues all the time, not one that occurs in separate phases of creation and destruction.

And the most salient feature of the current episode is that there has been unusually little creation. From the 1990’s to the 2000’s, the quarterly job creation rate fell from about 8% to about 7%. Since 2006, it has fallen to about 6%.

Some might argue that this type of slowdown in job creation is inevitable during times of structural change and that it is useless to try to oppose it with monetary and fiscal policy. It takes a long time (Arnold Kling, for example, would argue) for the economy to come up with ideas for new, productive uses of resources when the old uses are no longer productive. Monetary and fiscal policies can’t do much to speed up this process. They can’t make entrepreneurs more creative.

I’m skeptical of that view: entrepreneurs were plenty creative during the 90’s, once the booming stock market gave them a reason to apply their creativity. Monetary policy really did help speed up the process of finding new uses for resources: low interest rates led to high equity prices, which made it easy to raise capital and thereby made it advantageous to find new ways of using capital. Some would say the process went too fast in the end, with a large fraction of the uses proving ultimately unproductive, but statistics show aggregate productivity rising rapidly and continuing to rise during the subsequent years, even (atypically) during the recession that immediately followed the boom. There may have been a lot of froth, but there was plenty of good beer underneath, and monetary policy is what opened the tap.

In any case, even if I were to concede that monetary and fiscal policies don’t help speed up the adjustment process, they do help us get the most out of the economy in the mean time. With nearly 10 percent of the labor force unemployed, there are a lot of resources being wasted – people spending their time looking for jobs that many of them just aren’t going to find until we get a lot more economic activity. There are plenty of useful things that those people could be doing in the mean time.

Perhaps more important, monetary and fiscal policies help us reduce the risk that a weak economy – too weak for too long – will fall into a deflationary spiral. As long as job creation remains weak, employers have little incentive to raise wages, and competition will tend to push down prices. Even an “artificial” stimulus, one that doesn’t accelerate the structural adjustment process, will create a demand for labor and force employers to compete somewhat for workers. That competition, in turn, will prevent them from competing too aggressively in product markets and keep prices reasonably stable.

There is, of course (in theory, at least), the risk that policies will go too far and not just prevent deflation but produce excessive inflation. As I have argued before, we are nowhere near that point right now. I made the case against inflation using mostly the unemployment rate, but the case becomes even stronger when you consider the job creation statistics. This unemployment is specifically being induced by a slowdown in job creation. Job creation is specifically what leads to inflation: it’s when companies want to hire aggressively that they start raising wages excessively and competition becomes unable to keep prices in check. If unemployment – which arguably has a more tenuous relationship to inflation – is far, far away from the danger point, job creation – which has a direct relationship to inflation – is even further away.




DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management.

305 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 305 of 305
Cara Membantu Penyembuhan Demam Tifoid said...

penyajian website yang sungguh bagus dengan tampilan yang seperti ini, sungguh berkualitas,

Cara Mengurangi Rasa Sakit karena Encok said...

sebelumnya mohon izin dari kami untuk mengunjungi di website ini, terima kasih,

Cara untuk Sembuhkan Jantung Bocor said...

ulasan artikel yang disajikan di website ini sangat menarik untuk kami baca, terima kasih,

Mushtaq ahmed said...

bob net banking login

Cara Menyembuhkan Pendarahan Lambung said...

kembali izin untuk sejenak singgah di website yang menarik ini, sangat bagus websitenya,

Cara Mengobati Gejala Gagal Ginjal said...

kami ingin sekali berbagi informasi mengenai kesehatan dengan berkunjung ke website ini...

Cara Menyembuhkan Kaligata said...

senang berkunjung kembali untuk kesekian kalinya ke website ini, terima kasih sebelumnya,


Cara Menangani Penderita Stroke said...

salam semua, kami dari artikel kesehatan ingin mohon izin untuk berkunjung disini...

lady queen said...


Situs BandarQ Terpercaya
Situs Poker Uang Asli
Judi Domino 99

Gege Dai said...

uggs outlet
longchamp bags
michael kors handbags clearance
chrome hearts eyewear
polo ralph lauren
ugg outlet
longchamp handbags
cheap soccer jerseys
moncler outlet store
coach outlet store
michael kors outlet clearance
ugg outlet online
tory burch outlet
michael kors outlet online
oakley sunglasses
celine outlet online
polo ralph lauren
lululemon pants
beats by dr dre
ugg boots
nike outlet store online
ugg outlet
cheap uggs
michael kors outlet
adidas outlet
converse shoes
fitflops outlet sale
ugg boots
michael kors outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
louis vuitton handbags
ugg boots on sale
michael kors outlet
cheap uggs
nike free run
czq20160816

Cara Memulihkan Leher yang Bengkak said...

website ini salah satu website yang saya sukai yang pernah dikunjungi, tampilannya menarik,

Cara Meredakan Nyeri Ulu Hati said...

website yang benar-benar menarik untuk kami simak, terima kasih atas izin kunjungan kami ini,

Cara Meredakan Jari Tangan yang Kaku said...

sangat membantu sekali untuk kami karena dapat menambah pengetahuan dan wawasan,

Cara untuk Hilangkan Psoriasis said...

sungguh berkualitas informasi artikel dari websitenya ini, sukses terus untuk itu...

Cara Menyembuhkan Gagal Ginjal said...

penyajian informasi website pada kunjungan kali ini sangat bagus, sukses untuk semuanya,

Cara Memulihkan Pembuluh Darah Pecah said...

sebelumnya kami ingin ucapkan terima kasih untuk izin kunjungan kami disini, sukses selalu,

Cara Membantu Mengencerkan Darah Kental said...

kami minta izin untuk mengunjungi artikel di website ini, ingin menambah pengetahuan,

Cara Mengeringkan Luka Operasi Caesar said...

mohon izin untuk dapat berkunjung di website ini, sekedar untuk menyimak informasinya,

Cara Menangani Pendarahan Lambung said...

penyajian informasi yang mengagumkan, sukses untuk artikel informasi yang disajikan ini,

Cara Menangani Radang Sendi said...

sungguh benar-benar website yang berkualitas, sukses untuk website yang bagus ini...

Cara Menyembuhkan Sakit Tenggorokan said...

tampilan warna yang cukup menarik untuk digunakan pada website ini, sangat bagus...

Cara Membantu Penyembuhan Patah Tulang said...

sebelumnya mohon izin dari kami untuk mengunjungi di website ini, terima kasih,

Cara Menghilangkan Keloid pada Kulit said...

kami ingin berbagi sedikit informasi di website ini khususnya informasi mengenai kesehatan,

Cara Memulihkan Penderita Rematik said...

kembali izin untuk sejenak singgah di website yang menarik ini, sangat bagus websitenya,

Cara Menangani Infeksi Telinga said...

kami ingin sekali berbagi informasi mengenai kesehatan dengan berkunjung ke website ini...

Kelly Anni said...

Sorry I helped to establish the link. Your website is very good and this article is very useful. Good luck and always success for your blogging. contact form | snapchat emoji

Cara Membantu Pengobatan Dispepsia said...

kami minta izin untuk berbagi info mengenai kesehatan disini, semoga bermanfaat infonya,

Cara Menangani Penderita Hepatitis said...

izin untuk berkunjung di website ini sekalian menyimak informasi terbarunya dari sini,

Cara Menyembuhkan Penyakit Melanoma said...

kunjungan kembali kesini untuk sekedar menambah wawasan dan pengetahuan,

Cara Mengurangi Resiko Hipertensi said...

sungguh menarik untuk disimak artikel serta tampilan warna yang di suguhkan disini,

Cara Menyembuhkan Tulang Keropos said...

sangat menarik untuk kami lihat tampilan warna yang digunakan pada website ini, bagus sekali..

Cara Menyembuhkan Endometriosis said...

website ini salah satu website yang saya sukai yang pernah dikunjungi, tampilannya menarik,

Cara untuk Meredakan Nyeri Otot said...

website yang benar-benar menarik untuk kami simak, terima kasih atas izin kunjungan kami ini,

Cara Memulihkan Tukak Lambung said...

sungguh berkualitas informasi artikel dari websitenya ini, sukses terus untuk itu...

Cara Mengatasi Saluran Pernafasan Terganggu said...

penyajian informasi website pada kunjungan kali ini sangat bagus, sukses untuk semuanya,

Cara Menangani Paru Paru Bocor said...

kami minta izin untuk mengunjungi artikel di website ini, ingin menambah pengetahuan,

Cara Menghilangkan Kaligata said...

mohon izin untuk dapat berkunjung di website ini, sekedar untuk menyimak informasinya,

Cara Mengatasi Nyeri Pergelangan Tangan said...

penyajian informasi yang mengagumkan, sukses untuk artikel informasi yang disajikan ini,

Cara Menangani Pneumonia (Radang Paru-Paru) said...

bagus sekali warna tampilan yang digunakan pada website ini, sangat cocok dan pas...

Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Bronkitis said...

sungguh benar-benar website yang berkualitas, sukses untuk website yang bagus ini...

Cara Mengecilkan Jerawat Batu said...

tampilan warna yang cukup menarik untuk digunakan pada website ini, sangat bagus...

Cara Membantu Penyembuhan Infeksi Telinga said...

sebelumnya mohon izin dari kami untuk mengunjungi di website ini, terima kasih,

Cara Menyembuhkan TBC Anak said...

kami ingin berbagi sedikit informasi di website ini khususnya informasi mengenai kesehatan,

Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Osteoporosis said...

kami minta izin untuk berkunjung ke website ini, sekedar untuk singgah menyimak informasinya,

Cara Mengurangi Rasa Gatal karena Psoriasis said...

kembali izin untuk sejenak singgah di website yang menarik ini, sangat bagus websitenya,

Cara untuk Hilangkan Luka Bakar said...

kami ingin sekali berbagi informasi mengenai kesehatan dengan berkunjung ke website ini...

Cara Menyembuhkan Cacar Air said...

pemilihan warna yang sangat bagus dan cocok sekali untuk digunakan oleh website ini,

Cara Menangani Penyakit Campak said...

kami minta izin untuk berbagi info mengenai kesehatan disini, semoga bermanfaat infonya,

Cara Menghilangkan Nyeri Punggung said...

izin untuk berkunjung di website ini sekalian menyimak informasi terbarunya dari sini,

Cara Mengatasi Kadar Kolesterol yang Tinggi said...

sungguh menarik untuk disimak artikel serta tampilan warna yang di suguhkan disini,

cara cepat menyembuhkan haid berlebih paling efektif said...


Thank you for the content that you provide. May be useful for everyone

Cara Mengatasi Penyakit Dispepsia said...

kunjungan kami ini untuk sekedar menambah info dan pengetahuan, terima kasih...

Cara Memulihkan Tulang yang Retak said...

sangat menarik untuk kami lihat tampilan warna yang digunakan pada website ini, bagus sekali..

lady queen said...



apartemen depok
apartemen harian depok
apartemen harian di depok
hotel depok
hotel murah depok
hotel murah di depok
penginapan depok
penginapan murah depok
penginapan murah di depok

Cara Meredakan Peradangan Ginjal said...

website ini salah satu website yang saya sukai yang pernah dikunjungi, tampilannya menarik,

Cara Menangani Osteoarthritis said...

website yang benar-benar menarik untuk kami simak, terima kasih atas izin kunjungan kami ini,

Cara Mengatasi Trigliserida Tinggi said...

sungguh berkualitas informasi pada artikel website ini, sukses terus untuk itu websitenya...

Cara Mengatasi Leher Bengkak said...

penyajian informasi website pada kunjungan kali ini sangat menarik, sukses untuk semuanya,

Cara Menangani Pengapuran Tulang said...

kami minta izin untuk mengunjungi artikel di website ini, ingin menambah pengetahuan,

Cara untuk Menangani Varises said...

kami ingin sekali punya website yang bagus seperti website ini, sangat berkualitas,

Cara Mengobati Penderita Thalasemia said...

mohon izin untuk dapat berkunjung di website ini, sekedar untuk menyimak informasinya,

Cara Mencegah Penyakit Kencing Batu said...

penyajian informasi yang mengagumkan, sukses untuk artikel informasi yang disajikan ini,

Cara Membantu Pengobatan Paru Paru Bocor said...

sungguh benar-benar website yang berkualitas, sukses untuk website yang bagus ini...

Cara Menyembuhkan Pembengkakan Lambung said...

tampilan warna yang cukup menarik untuk digunakan pada website ini, sangat bagus...

Cara Membantu Pengobatan Miom said...

sebelumnya mohon izin dari kami untuk mengunjungi di website ini, terima kasih,

Cara Mengobati Penderita Darah Tinggi said...

kami ingin berbagi sedikit informasi di website ini khususnya informasi mengenai kesehatan,

Cara Memulihkan Penderita Herpes said...

kami minta izin untuk berkunjung ke website ini, sekedar untuk singgah menyimak informasinya,

Cara Menangani Infeksi Hati said...

kembali izin untuk sejenak singgah di website yang menarik ini, sangat bagus websitenya,

Cara Menangani Penyumbatan di Jantung said...

kami ingin sekali berbagi informasi mengenai kesehatan dengan berkunjung ke website ini...

Cara Mengatasi Sakit Tenggorokan karena Radang said...

pemilihan warna yang sangat bagus dan cocok sekali untuk digunakan oleh website ini,

caiyan said...

lebron james shoes
the north face outlet
coach outlet
michael kors uk
nike huarache
nike air max outlet
ugg australia
canada goose outlet
uggs
converse shoes
20161103ciayan

Unknown said...


Pipeline leak detection is used to determine if and in some cases where a leak has occurred in systems which contain liquids and gases. Methods of detection include hydrostatic testing, infrared, and laser technology after pipeline erection and leak detection during service.
عزل اسطح بالمدينة المنورة
شركة عزل الاسطح بالرياض
تسليك مجاري بالدمام
تسليك مجاري بالرياض
جلى بلاط بالرياض

Unknown said...


شركة تركيب باركيه بالرياض
افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالاحساء
افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالدمام
افضل شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالجبيل
شركة جلى بلاط شمال الرياض
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

hoa pikey said...

The share your really gives us excitement. Thanks for your sharing. If you feel tired at work or study try to participate in our games to bring the most exciting feeling. Thank you!
hotmail login | red ball

Candy Sim said...

The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.
animal jam | five nights at freddy's | hotmail login

holi images said...

Holi Images
holi images
holi images

Meiqing Xu said...

pandora jewelry
ralph lauren
gucci outlet
polo ralph lauren outlet
beats earbuds
jordan shoes
michael kors outlet clearance
oakley sunglasses outlet
michael kors outlet clearance
denver broncos jerseys
20170320caian

Anonymous said...

the sychy behind the man is just blender. none of us is a perfect but the reality is different.no one want to demolish your self.
zee digitizing

24 hour check cashing Dayton said...

United Check Cashing providing you the exceptional services with a hundred% pleasure within very short duration.

check casher Claymont said...

We will be inclined to location unit the agency providing you the most effective services regarding inside a short amount. In USA you will realize U.S. Everyplace, every city and 24/7.

evelyndana09@gmail.com said...

We will be inclined to location unit the agency providing you the most effective services regarding inside a short amount. In USA you will realize U.S. Everyplace, every city and 24/7.
check casher Claymont

24 hour check cashing said...

Are you trying to money right into a financial institution account, the whole quantity commonly cannot be immediately accessed; there could also be a waiting amount for the check to clean?

Agen Judi Online said...

www.taruhan188.com
www.maincapsa.com
www.bandarjudisbobet.com
www.mendaftarsbobet.com
www.caramendaftarsbobetcasino.com

adham washim said...

pusat penjualan furniture di bandung Rumah dengan desain minimalis yaitu rumah pilihan masa kini, rumah minimalis toko furniture di sukajadi bandung konsep minimalisnya. Maka, jual furniture minimalis murah minimalis, wajib kita ketahui kiranya tutorial toko furniture minimalis bandung ini supaya ruangan kita kelihatan nyaman dan luas sofa minimalis murah di bandung sebagai tempat tinggal dan hunian kita.

berapa biaya bikin kitchen set Keluarkan semua imajinasi kita dalam menata ruangan minimalis, kitchen set murah dan minimalis dan membuat penguninya nyaman dan bahagia. Hal pertama yang wajib kitchen set minimalis apartemen semua tatanan rumah kita serta furniturnya sesuai dengan dinding rumah, serta buat seminimal mungkin.

Skin care flek hitam setelah itu dalam menata ruangan minimalis yang nyaman, gendongan bayi hanaroo di bandung, gunakan peralatan seperlunya aja, jangan biarkan perabot menumpuk sehingga kelihatan jorok dan tak rapi. jasa pembuatan furniture unik minimalis namun bagus dan indah.

Anonymous said...

Obat Ejakulasi Dini

astrianiy73@gmail.com

http://www.obatejakulasidinipria.com

great article, how can you find out? you are great! read also: Obat ejakulasi dini

Anonymous said...

Obat Ejakulasi Dini

astrianiy73@gmail.com

http://www.obatejakulasidinipria.com

great article, how can you find out? you are great! read also: Obat ejakulasi dini

Obat Ejakulasi Dini Permanen said...

its so helpful, anyway thank you. u can read also: Obat Ejakulasi Dini Permanen

cara membersihkan rahim said...

this article is very helpful

Obat Ejakulasi Dini Permanen said...

content you serve a very useful and needed a lot of people . thank you... read also: Obat Ejakulasi Dini Permanen

Obat Ejakulasi Dini Permanen said...

its so helpful, anyway thank you.

ahmad farokhi said...

That's very helpful. Thank you for the response
Inspirasi Desain Rumah Klasik Terbaru
Desain Interior Kantor Klasik Terbaru
Desain Kamar Tidur 2017 Anak Perempuan
Kursi Goyang Minimalis
Lemari Hias Klasik Warna Putih Emas
Meja Makan Minimalis
Kursi Tiffany Murah
Tips Membeli Kamar Set Online Jepara
Interior Rumah Minimalis Terbaik

Yaro Gabriel said...

www0530

michael kors outlet
mulberry outlet
prada handbags
cheap mlb jerseys
polo outlet
ferragamo outlet
hawks jerseys
mulberry outlet
pandora charms
polo ralph lauren

Linda Cochran said...

To find a greater exposure for your facebook account, Persons expend bucks to Buy Facebook Followers to very easily obtain exposure online. buy 1000 facebook followers

Crew Fauzi said...

I and my family are very helpful with the info from you. May we all succeed the Hereafter.

Cara Cepat Mengecilkan Perut Buncit

Obat Benjolab Di Vagina

Obat Oles Tahan Lama

Sehat Itu Barokah

Joseph Share said...

Would you be interested in exchanging links?

Click Here
Chowhound.com

Soham Kapoor said...

Thanks for the amazing article. Click for more, Click here, Visit this site, visit this site, Visit this site, Click for more, visit this article, Read this article, Great article

Soham Kapoor said...

Click here, Visit here, more article, Names list, Visit more, Visit more, Visit more

Hualala said...

Air Jordan Retro 9
Air Max 270
Pandora Jewelry
Red Bottom Shoes For Women
Pandora Official Site
Retro Jordan 11
Pandora Outlet
Red Bottom for Women
Jordan 11
Paul20181013

Jessica Wil said...

Now you can win free stuff online, free giveaways, enter every day to win latest iphones, smartphones, macbooks, laptops, accessories, technology and much more at https://ifreegiveaways.com/

joint supplements for dogs said...

Joint Supplements For Dogs. Our select triple action Glucosamine, Chondroitin and Turmeric formula works to not only relieve pain, ease limb heaviness and joint aches but also lubricates joints and strengthens cartilage to increase your pet s mobility and greatly improve their quality of life Relieves stiffness and inflammation in pets sufferin.

JOY JULIO said...

Sickbits
Sickbits is a library of unlimited hacks for android, ios smartphones. Get unlimited amount of hacks and modes for mac & pc. DAEMON TOOLS LITE FREE DOWNLOAD

Naincy Kumari said...

I'm shakshi.I am working in India top most Escort serviceMumbai escorts.If u want to join the all facility of escortsPuri escorts
pls call me & whatssapCuttack escorts
visit the sites.Bhubaneswar escorts

Archana The best Call Girl said...

Hi friends ! I'm Archana Kumari. I like to have bed relationship with different persons rather than with a single man for the whole of life. I do it for enjoyment. If you are interested in me then,
Please follow me on the links given bellow.
Thanks.

Escorts Services in Kolkata
Escorts service in Mumbai
Mumbai Escorts

Mumbai Call girl
Jaipur Escorts
Escorts Services in Jaipur
=============================

kodiapkdl said...

दर्द भरी शायरी, पेनफुल शायरी
Let's see some of the pyar dard shayari in hindi or प्यार दर्द शायरी . Dard (Pain), The most hurtful pinch that aches the soul and body.

Rijschool den hag said...

Rijschool den haag Hofstad rijopleiding is écht gevestigd in Den Haag Wij helpen je met het behalen van je autorijbewijs na je rijexamen leer je pas echt autorijden Wij helpen je een heel eind op weg om het verkeer in Den Haag én in Nederland de baas te zijn Wij gaan voor kwalitatief rijden!

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 305 of 305   Newer› Newest»