Friday, November 20, 2009

Prose Hack

The US is in a depression. It is rather a mild depression, as depressions go, but if I may use the terms “recession” and “depression” in accordance with their verbal roots, although US economic activity is no longer receding, it is still depressed. (It is depressed by any standard, I think, but particularly, my own criterion would be, in comparison with what we know the US economy is capable of producing.) And it will remain so, even in the best case, “for a considerable period of time.” You don’t go from a doubling of the unemployment rate, back to normal business activity, without experiencing a great deal of melancholia along the way.

Most observers blame the economic collapse on the humungous housing and credit boom, which went bust in a particularly unpleasant manner. But what would have happened if the boom had never taken place? That very boom, even with war spending as an additional stimulus, and with households that were willing to consume their entire income, was, it seems to me, barely enough to forestall depression. Despite having such considerable help, the financial boom did not produce an economic boom. It barely created enough demand to bring US economic activity up to its potential for a year or so.

The bigger they come, the harder they fall, and this one was huge – but not huge enough, not strong enough, even in its days of glory, to fully hoist the boulder by which we are now being crushed. Blame this decade’s financial excess for the acuteness of the recession, but don’t blame it for the existence of a depression. It’s not clear exactly what it is, but we are dealing with some sort of “long wavelength” economic phenomenon whose underpinnings were a pre-existing condition. Today, one or two powerful shots of temporary fiscal stimulus may help chase away the worst of the blue devils, but they won’t be sufficient to restore health.

As I see it, there are only two ways the US can end this depression. One is by deliberately, intentionally, publicly, and resolutely engineering a moderately high inflation rate (in the future) by promising to use whatever monetary policy is necessary to achieve a mercilessly escalating series of price level targets once that policy finally acquires traction. That approach would force people (and businesses) to abandon “safe” investments and start building something that will allow them to take advantage of the inflation by selling the products at higher prices than they cost to create.

The other way is to risk (but probably not create) a very high inflation rate (again, in the future, not in the present) by means of massive deficit spending sustained to the point of recklessness. This deficit spending could take the form either of increased government purchases, which stimulate economic activity directly, or of “helicopter drop” tax cuts financed by creating money, which, if done on a sufficiently large scale, will eventually make people (and/or businesses) feel wealthy enough to start spending more.

Neither of these things is going to happen. Not in the current political climate, and not in any political climate that I can imagine over the next decade. I conclude that, when this depression ends, it will not be the US that ends it. This depression will end when the rest of the world (considered collectively) decides that it wants more than it is able or willing to produce, and when it approaches the US, bearing its accumulated IOU’s, offering to retire them at a substantial discount (a discount enforced by the foreign exchange market, not by renegotiating the instruments themselves), and asking the US to produce the remainder of what it wants.

Or else this depression will just continue. Eventually, some day, America’s capital stock will have deteriorated to the point where it cannot even supply the depressed level of demand that it will still be experiencing. (I mean demand “depressed” relative to what the US would have been capable of producing if growth had somehow proceeded normally, making efficient use of available resources. I’m optimistic that the US will experience growth over the next decade, just not enough growth. In my lexicon, if, for example, growth of demand were just sufficient to absorb labor force and productivity growth while leaving 10.2 percent of the labor force unemployed and 17.5 percent of the broadly defined labor force either unemployed or under-employed, as they are today, that would definitely still qualify as a continuing depression, though, by the way, it wouldn’t necessarily leave investors feeling depressed.) And once our capital stock does deteriorate sufficiently – in the future, but not in the foreseeable future – we will have to start building something again.




DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management.

56 comments:

David Pearson said...

The rest of the world could very well decide to cash in its dollars for goods. This points to one of the fundamental problems with the economy the Fed has created.

Ordinarily, the adjustment in trade imbalances would lead to an adjustment out of the "depression" as our exports surge. This economy is not ordinary. It is predicated on ultra-low interest rates -- the effect of a decade of Fed "experimentation" with deflation-fighting.

What happens to an economy based on low rates when foreigners trade IOU's for goods? The negative force of higher interest rates swamps the positive force of higher exports. Of course, that could lead to a situation where further dollar devaluation merely leads to higher interest rates.

Andy Harless said...

David: "The negative force of higher interest rates swamps the positive force of higher exports."

That depends on how the Fed and the Treasury react. The Fed will likely keep short-term interest rates low (unless the inflationary impact of the dollar's decline is unexpectedly large). In that case, the effect on interest rates depends on the supply and demand for longer-term Treasury securities (unless you think it will also affect risk spreads, but it's not clear which direction that effect would be). So the question is: what does the Treasury's supply curve look like? Right now, the Treasury is (misguidedly, in my opinion) trying to take advantage of low rates by doing a significant fraction of its financing long term. If rates start to rise, that incentive will start to disappear, and the Treasury might well start doing more short-term financing, thus limiting the yield curve impact.

But it's also not clear to me why rates would rise in the first place. The time for US creditors abroad to worry about a weak dollar is before the dollar collapses, not after. The cheaper the dollar gets, the less subsequent depreciation risk there is, and the more chance there is of subsequent appreciation. When foreign investors become unwilling to accept low yields on US bonds, the result would be a drop in the dollar, which should be sufficiently large to allow them to anticipate subsequent appreciation. There's no need for US interest rates to change unless domestic investors lose confidence in US bonds. But that would be a good thing, because they would have to shift their wealth into more productive assets.

Richard H. Serlin said...

"It’s not clear exactly what it is, but we are dealing with some sort of “long wavelength” economic phenomenon whose underpinnings were a pre-existing condition."

What do you mean by this? Can you cite some theory, papers, or other readings that explain this?

Andy Harless said...

Richard, I just mean that, whatever is going on, it is something that started long before the recent recession and is likely to continue long after. I use the phrase "long wavelength" to mean something that takes place over a longer period of time than the usual business cycle.

Richard H. Serlin said...

Thank you Andy,

With regard to your pessimism, "Neither of these things is going to happen. Not in the current political climate, and not in any political climate that I can imagine over the next decade." Here is an idea for achieving strong action even in spite of the political mess: The use of reconciliation for a stimulus. How is this possible?

A stimulus can be done through reconciliation, and therefore need only 50 votes and the VP to break the tie, if it's deficit neutral. But how can it be deficit neutral and still be a stimulus?

The answer is that it must be deficit neutral over a period of 5 years. So, put in the spending now, and the tax increases, on the very wealthy, on pollution, to pay for it 3 or more years later. If the recession is not over by then, roll it over, that is do another one of these stimuli at that time.

It's not that unlikely that you can find 50 Democrats in their caucus of 60 that will support a very large stimulus, especially one that is deficit negative over 5 years. And I love the idea of making the stimulus as much as possible high return investments like infrastructure, alternative energy, education, which grow GDP long term and therefore decrease the government debt as a percentage of GDP.

Archie M. Ross said...

US ALL day cash upgrades among Il offers several land loan selections for staying wise payday loan newport_news in conjunction with, day cash upgrades, Salaryday and Size Usecured bank loans, in conjunction with Automobile arrange Usecured bank loans. selection of us target serving to you choose for the proper land loan product to boot to product and services to help you to satisfy your low cost needs.

devon broad said...

Picked the money you will be needing. several weeks throughout a tho', ton this specific equity credit line back. It really is effortlessly! fluctuated with connectedness is that the upper really starting day payday loan huntsville development having u. s. of America day money enhancements is plainly thought NO COST!!! that is adequate.

Milla Jkmn said...

Interest charges will very add up and if you're late on your payment(s) you may be charged a considerable late fee payday loans corona further. day loans area unit meant to be utilised for short and temporary monetary times, paying them off after you get your next cheque.

Anonymous said...

To solve all our economic problems, it is very necessary to increase creating jobs and employment rates. This can now be achieved by creating awareness about the importance of education and its relation with employment and careers. It can also be done by making people register for online courses and getting online degrees to increase their chances of getting employed.

Arthur Andrew said...

What I believe is that the involvement of US in war against terrorism and over spending on military might have created this chaos in economic dilemma.

bestessaysforsale.net said...

Wow! This article is incredible! There are some ideas that can be used in practice. Thank you for such a job!

Jeanne Foster said...

professional essay editing service is at your service any time you need it.

Franklin Gloria said...

t is really a nice and useful piece of information. I am glad that you shared this helpful information with us. Please stay us up to date like this. Thank you for sharing.
Bens Automotive |

Finan Automotive |

Automotive Energy |

PP Automotive Center |

NT Medi-Care |

Care Giving Reviews |

Best Care Solution |

Health Care Professional |

Hospitality Cushion |

Sugar Loaf Hospital |

Jonny Thomas said...

For latest information you have to go to see world-wide-web and on world-wide-web I found this web site as a best website for hottest updates.
Solar Panel House |

1890 Caroline House |

Home Sale |

The Perfect House |

SD Home Improvement |

Muschi House |

NH Homeless |

Peru Southern Tours |

Khaan Tours |

Auckland Jet Boat Tour |

nimi parker said...

Excellent and decent post. I found this much informative, as to what I was exactly searching for.The Article is quite impressive and thoughts been put up has clearly got something to state.
Just Class Cars |

Just Popular Cars |

Show Car Supply Automotive |

Greers Automotive |

VSP Automotive |

Canarias Automotive |

Used Toyota Cars |

Automotive Law Now |

Noma Automotive |

Automotive Transport |

Jane Doe said...

Thanks, the piece of writing is definitely wholesome!
topsampletermpaper.net

amine lahragui said...

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. happy new year 2016 new year 2016
bonne année 2016 imagenes de año nuevo 2016 imagenes de navidad 2016 feliz año nuevo 2016 Journée internationale des droits des femmes 2016

Anonymous said...

nice post....
ISL 2015 Live Streaming

Watch ISL 2015 Live Streaming On Star Sports

Rahul Dhalgade said...

Your blog was too good. i really appreciate with your blog.Thanks for sharing.
2015 ISL Schedule time table find here
Indian super league live stream watch on starsports
ISL Prediction 2015 matchs

grissha hamearth said...

If some one must be updated with hottest technologies then he should be pay a fast visit this online page and be up thus far everyday.
Sbobet Indonesia
Taruhan Bola Online

Deepak Negi said...

Hey Guys Must Check these :-

I can do that live show
I can do that live telecast
I can do that Show live streaming

Dhanteras 2015 Puja
Dhanteras 2015 Gold Sale Offers
Dhanteras 2015 Puja Samagri
Dhanteras 2015 Puja Vidhi
Kuber 2015 puja vidhi

Happy Childrens Day 2015 Images
Childrens Day 2015
Happy Childrens Day 2015
Childrens Day 2015 Speech
Happy Childrens Day 2015 Quotes

Mastizaade Box Office Collection
Mastizaade Funny Scenes
Mastizaade hd Videos
Mastizaade hd Torrent Download
Mastizaade free Torrent download
Mastizaade kickass torrent
Mastizaade Hot Scenes
Mastizaade Movie Review
Mastizaade Romantic Scenes
Mastizaade Songs
Mastizaade trailer film
Mastizaade 1st Day Collection Prediction
Sunny Leone Mastizaade Movie

World Aids Day 2015 Quotes
World Aids Day 2015 Posters
World Aids Day 2015 Themes
World Aids Day 2015 Slogans
Happy New Year 2016
New Year 2016
New Year 2016 Quotes
Happy New Year 2016 Images
New Year 2016 Wishes

Sagar Balyan said...

rose day whatsapp dp
rose day whatsapp dp images
rose day romantic sms for girlfriend
happy rose day sms wallpaper
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in English
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Shayari in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Status in Urdu
happy new year 2016 animated videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp short videos
happy new year 2016 fb animated images
happy new year 2016 fb GIF images
happy new year shayari
happy new year 2016 shayari sms
happy new year shayari images
happy new year 2016 sms images
happy new year 2016 sms wallpaper
valentines day 2016 romantic quotes
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for her
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for girlfriend
happy valentines day 2016 romantic SMS
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Wishes for Boyfriend
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Sayings for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic messages for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic images
romantic Valentines Day 2016 E Cards
valentines day romantic 2016 FB Covers
happy valentines day 2016 Romantic FB Status
valentines day 2016 romantic sayings for Boyfriend
valentines day love sms messages
royal rumble 2016 live stream
watch royal rumble live streaming online
royal rumble 2016 results highlights
who won royal rumble 2016 winner
watch royal rumble 2016 HD video free ppv
royal rumble 2016 live online

Sagar Balyan said...

valentine day sms wallpaper
valentine day single line status
valentine day shayari one line
valentine day latest shayari
valentine day love shayari in hindi
valentine day shayari for boyfriend
valentine day shayari for girlfriend
valentine day love sms messages
valentine day shayari facebook
valentine's day shayari for wife
valentine kiss day shayari
valentine's day sher o shayari
valentine day sher o shayari hindi
valentine romantic status for whatsapp
whatsapp status valentine day special
valentine special whatsapp videos
valentine day special whatsapp short video
valentines day funny whatsapp status
valentines day romantic whatsapp status
valentines day one line whatsapp status
hug day love quotes
hug day long quotes
hug day latest quotes
hug day sad quotes
hug day love sms messages
hug day short quotes
hug day sad quotes 2 lines
hug day sad quotes one line status
hug day quotes messages for girlfriend
hug day quotes for gf
hug day quotes for best friend
hug day emotional quotes
hug day romantic quotes
romantic hug quotes for her
romantic hug day sms in hindi
hug day 2016 sms wallpaper
rose day 2016 shayari sms
rose day shayari sms in hindi
7th feb rose day sms
rose day love sms messages
rose day 2016 romantic sms
happy rose day romantic shayari
valentine day special whatsapp short video
rose day whatsapp short video

Roma Singh said...

Your work is excellent and i admire you and hopping for a few extra informative posts.
how to get rosy whiter skin

Toko Herbal Ace Maxs said...

It is a dynamic blog site to seek out and contains depth information with full coverage. Thank you very much has has been sharing this information
Obat Gagal Ginjal Alami

salman khan said...

Your Site Is Very Good and The Post is Well On Topic, Thanks for Sharing it with us.

New Songs 2016
Online Jobs In Pakistan 2016
Pakistan Super League 2016
First Time in Pakistan
apple iphone 7 video reviews
Quetta Gladiators Pakistan Super League 2016
very sad poetry in urdu 2016
New Romantic Songs 2016
where can i get copyright free music for youtube videos

Meiko Kaito said...

I love these!! I can't wait to try this on my own. essay writing serivce Such a fabulous idea!!!

Anonymous said...

icc t20 world cup
icc t20 world cup 2016
icc t20 world cup 2016 live
icc t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
icc t20 world cup live
t20 world cup 2016
t20 world cup
t20 world cup 2016 live
t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
t20 world cup live

icc t20 world cup
icc t20 world cup 2016
icc t20 world cup 2016 live
icc t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
icc t20 world cup live
t20 world cup 2016
t20 world cup
t20 world cup 2016 live
t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
t20 world cup live


IPL t20
IPL t20 2016
IPL t20 2016 live
IPL t20 2016 Streaming
IPL t20 2016 live Streaming
IPL t20 2016 Streaming
IPL t20 live Streaming
IPL live Streaming
IPL live
IPL t20 live
mobiles phone india
bolly hindi lyrics
indian rail Pnr Status

guru les privat kerumah said...


Guru les privat kerumah

Guru privat jakarta

Guru les Privat SD SMP SMA

calon gubernur terkuat DKi 2017 said...

Calon Gubernur DKI Terkuat 2017

Calon Gubernur DKI 2017

Calon Terkuat Gubernur DKI 2017

jual ramuan madura said...

Jual ramuan madura

jual tongkat madura

jual jamu tradisional

jhon said...

So a abstracted accommodation like the Abbey Aggressive Accommodation is the easiest and simplest way to go to abstain such abhorrent circumstances. Actuality an apart loan, it is provided at a actual low bulk of absorption that stands beneath eight percent. The absolute bulk that can be adopted through this accommodation comes to about 25,000 pounds that is absolutely a acceptable sum for a absolutely apart loan.
payday loans chicago

Anonymous said...

Thanks for giving me the useful information. I think I need it!

- Happy Wheels
- FNAF
- FNAF World

youncy said...

Jasaqq
Dominoqq
Bandarq

Eri Alaaspari said...

thank you very much gan , the article is very interesting that we can refer to.
cara mengobati ganglion tanpa operasi

Run 3 unblocked said...

Run 3 Unblocked
Run 4 Unblocked
Run Unblocked
Car Racing Games
Super Mario Unblocked.
Donkey Kong Unblocked.

Shan Jonson said...

Besides, you have to realize that payday advance is started to individuals in dire requirement for money and not for extravagance. The start of fax less payday advance makes it less demanding for borrowers to get quick money to settle critical budgetary needs.
Cash Advance

Shan Jonson said...


To start with, you should realize that payday advance is not for each body and you should work your self fit for the credit administration before you apply, on the off chance that you don't do that, your application will be decrease. So on the off chance that you require fax less payday credit, you have to ensure you have all it takes to apply and get endorsement before you wander into applying for fax less payday advance.

Cash Advance

Agen judi bola said...

Agen Judi Bola
Casino Online Terpercaya
Agen Bola Terpercaya

Bogdan Yanov said...

Nonetheless I am here now proessaywriting.com
and would just like to say

obat kuat sex dan alat bantu sex said...

obat kuat tahan lama
pembesar panjang penis permanen
obat perangsang wanita
alat bantu sex pria
alat bantu sex wanita
aneka kondom silikon
aneka kosmetik

Seodistro said...

Many people have the same opinion like you. That's great jasaseoclub

nairy uness said...

يحتوي الموقع على اجمل العاب طبخ بنات حصرية ومتجددة باستمرار ويمكنك اللعب مباشرة في العاب طبخ التي تعتبر من اروع العاب بنات.

Giải Trí Tổng Hợp said...

Welcomes to google terminal from Austin Texas! google snake
Amazing insight you have on this, Happy wheels it's nice to find a website that details so much information about different artists... Age of war 2 This article always blew me... Earn to die For how many times I have read this.
slither io Hi! I’ve been reading your blog for a while slitherio it's nice to find a website that details so much big farm

lady queen said...


Cara Pengobatan Diabetes Alami herbal
Cara Pengobatan asam urat dan kolesterol
Cara Pengobatan Jerawat

Mushtaq ahmed said...

activate axis bank mobile banking
activate andhra bank mobile baking
activate canara bank mobile banking
activate corporation bank mobile banking
activate syndicate bank mobile banking
activate central bank mobile banking
activate dena bank mobile banking
activate union bank mobile banking
activate yes bank mobile banking
activate uco bank mobile banking
activate obc mobile banking
activate vijaya bank mobile banking
activate idbi mobile banking
activate citi bank mobile banking
activate kotak mobile banking
hdfc net banking
icici net banking
axis net banking
andhra net banking
canara net banking
corporation net banking
syndicate net banking
central bank net banking
dena bank net banking
union bank net banking
yes bank net banking
uco bank net banking
obc net banking
vijaya bank net banking
idbi bank net banking
citi bank net banking
bob net banking
kotak net banking

lady queen said...


Cara Pengobatan Diabetes Alami herbal
Cara Pengobatan asam urat dan kolesterol
Cara Pengobatan Jerawat

Mushtaq ahmed said...

hdfc loan against securities interest rates

Candy Sim said...

The blog or and best that is extremely useful to keep I can share the ideas
of the future as this is really what I was looking for, I am very comfortable and pleased to come here. Thank you very much.
strike force heroes| slitherio | earn to die 2
earn to die 5| goodgame empire |tank trouble 2

Candy Sim said...

this is one of the cult game now, a lot of people enjoy playing them . Also you can refer to the game :
age of war | earn to die 5 | Tank trouble | happy wheels | earn to die 6
The game controls are shown just under . Movement mechanisms primarily include acceleration and tilting controls.
tank trouble unblocked | wings io | strike force heroes

Mushtaq ahmed said...

bobibanking login

lady queen said...


Situs BandarQ Terpercaya
Situs Poker Uang Asli
Judi Domino 99

Gege Dai said...

ed hardy tshirts
nfl jersey wholesale
cheap canada goose jackets
adidas wings
michael kors outlet
christian louboutin online
true religion jeans
ugg outlet
michael kors outlet
coach outlet online
nike air max uk
michael kors outlet online
nba jerseys
louboutin pas cher
louis vuitton outlet store
asics
jordan 11
mont blanc pens
rolex watches for sale
fitflops sale
the north face jackets
oakley sunglasses wholesale
iphone case uk
longchamp outlet
swarovski crystal
christian louboutin uk
coach outlet clearance
louis vuitton bags
timberland boots
pandora jewelry
soccer jerseys
moncler outlet
hollister
abercrombie outlet
mulberry bags
czq20160816

Vinamilk Vinamilk said...

Gaming world where everyone entertained with games like Run 3 unblocked or Run 4 unblocked or Run unblocked . The adventure racing game as Car Racing Games or game that a lot of people like the Super Mario Unblocked or Donkey Kong Unblocked is also very attractive. Have fun!

postings.com said...

I laughed out loud, shed some tears … Scrambled Eggs is a theatrical feast for women of all ages and the men who love them!" and CBS’ Magee Hickey “I haven't laughed so hard in years. It's touching, poignant, funny and oh so very real."postings.com

Candy Sim said...

This is one of the cult game now, a lot of people enjoy playing them . Also you can refer to the game :
gold mine strike | pokemon go 2
The game controls are shown just under . Movement mechanisms primarily include acceleration and tilting controls.
stickman games | stick war 2 | animal jam 2