Friday, December 13, 2013

Stochastic Dynamic Inefficiency, Secular Stagnation, and the Natural Discounted Growth Rate


(I could have put a "wonkish" warning at the top, but come on, just look at the title!)

Let's start with the concept of the natural real interest rate, which is already ubiquitous. The real interest-rate is the interest rate corrected for expected inflation, and the natural real interest rate is the real interest rate consistent with price stability.  (I leave the definition of price stability ambiguous because it depends on your theory of the price level and inflation, which is a whole 'nother blog post.)

Now market monetarists like Scott Sumner and Nick Rowe point to a deficiency in the natural real interest rate concept: the natural real interest rate depends on the expected real growth rate. And monetary policy affects the expected real growth rate, so if policymakers try to set the actual interest rate equal to the natural rate, they are chasing a moving target. To me, this criticism suggests that the appropriate approach is to adjust the nominal interest rate not for expected inflation but for expected nominal growth. (While we're at it, we can also replace "price stability" with "nominal growth stability" and be done with our futile attempts to measure the aggregate price level.)

Most economists think that the natural real interest rate is normally positive. I have my doubts, but never mind, because I'm ditching the whole concept. Once we start correcting for expected normal growth rather than expected inflation, we are clearly not dealing with a natural rate concept that can be presumed to be normally positive.  If we are talking about a risk-free interest rate, then the need for physical capital returns to compensate for risk would make it very hard to achieve a long-run growth rate [an equilibrium with the interest rate] as high as the [growth] interest rate, let alone higher. To come up with a number that's usually positive, I suggest that we reverse the sign. Instead of talking about a "natural growth-adjusted interest rate," let's talk about a "natural discounted growth rate."

We can also talk about an "actual discounted expected growth rate."  (The discount is "actual," determined by the observable interest rate, but the associated growth rate is only "expected" because it is not known with any confidence when the interest rate is set.) If the actual rate equals the natural rate, you get a normal employment level and nominal income growth stability (or price stability, if you insist). If the actual rate is higher, you get accelerating inflation. If the natural rate is higher, you get depressed economic conditions, with excess unemployment and deflationary pressure, if not actual deflation. (Wicksellians, please recall that I have reversed the signs compared to the usual natural rate theory.)

Now that I've defined the natural discounted growth rate, I can define "secular stagnation" in the context of an NGDP target. Secular stagnation means that the natural discounted growth rate exceeds the growth rate of the NGDP target path.  In other words, the target path would require a negative nominal interest rate.  Under a level targeting regime, an attempt to pursue such a path will result in either monetary instrument instability or a "zigzag" growth pattern in which recessions alternate with inflationary catch-up periods. Under a growth rate targeting regime, you'll just keep missing the target from below, much like most of the developed world's central banks today. 

But if you play with the numbers, you can probably convince yourself that secular stagnation, by my definition, seems unlikely. A reasonable NGDP target path growth rate is maybe 5%.  Do we really think that the potential growth rate exceeds the natural interest rate by more than five percentage points? It's remotely conceivable, but my guess would be that our problem today is not secular stagnation (in this sense) but a flawed monetary policy regime.

Now if the target nominal growth rate (and the associated possibility of secular stagnation) is one of our bookends for the natural discounted growth rate, the other bookend is pretty clear: it's zero. Some readers will immediately recognize zero as the criterion for dynamic efficiency. Ignoring the issue of risk for a moment, an economy with a strictly positive natural discounted growth rate would be dynamically inefficient. Overall welfare could be improved by instituting a stable Ponzi scheme that transfers consumption backward across generations.

Does my assertion that the natural discounted growth rate is almost certainly strictly positive imply that we actually live in a dynamically inefficient economy? In an important sense, I think it does.  The thorny issue here is risk, and some will argue that the relevant interest rate for dynamic inefficiency is not the risk-free rate.  But I disagree.  The US government can produce assets that are considered virtually risk free, and a stable Ponzi scheme operated by the US government could presumably produce such assets yielding any amount up to the growth rate.  At today’s Treasury interest rates, which are clearly less than expected growth rates, marginal investors are (we can presume, since the assets are freely traded) indifferent between these low-yielding Treasury securities and investments that represent newly created capital.  So, given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, the government could, by operating a stable Ponzi scheme, be producing assets that have a higher risk-adjusted return than newly created capital.  Given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, it’s inefficient for the government not to be producing such assets.

It’s important to recognize that, under a typical scenario, the marginal investor will end up worse off, in a material sense, from earning the growth rate, compared to earning the actual return on capital.  In a material sense, the economy is dynamically efficient.  But the concept of risk preferences models a subjective good – call it “security” – and we’re not producing enough of this good.  The history of interest rates and growth rates suggests that we have seldom produced enough security, but the deficiency today is clearly worse than usual.  



DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product. 

1,034 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   1001 – 1034 of 1034
obat herbal qnc jelly gamat said...

thnk u
https://slides.com/gamat
https://www.edocr.com/user/bayugual
https://css-tricks.com/forums/users/gamat/
https://www.freelancersunion.org/members/account/gamat-t/
https://fontlibrary.org/en/member/gamat/
http://www.ohmstudio.com/users/gamat

https://sway.office.com/GQXc2138n5KYv7py
https://hub.docker.com/r/gamat/gamat

Rank Math said...

SSC Result 2019
SSC Result 2019 by SMS
SSC Result 2019 by app
SSC Result 2019 Marksheet

Anonymous said...

Essen Katilayu Asli Untuk Semua Ikan

Essen Umpan Pengumpul Semua Ikan

Unknown said...

In India now a days their is the atmosphere of elections. Political parties are approaching towards public with new campaigns . And all parties are focusing towards people's common problem they are facing daily. Well I am the supporter of BJP .
Choose your favourite party
here .

Lara Gargett said...

Students while completing their assignments might be required to avail nursing care plan help, SWOT Analysis Help, Market Conditions Homework help, and comment on or Design New Product Assignment help. Alternately, students might not just only want assignment expert but might also want nursing teaching help so as to better understand the subject. while seeking nursing reflection assignment help online might be necessary to keep up with the course load, developing personal expertise and knowledge in project management assignments is also vital.

for ict 99 said...

Great Article
Final Year Project Domains for CSE
IEEE Project Centers in Chennai





JavaScript Training in Chennai
JavaScript Training in Chennai

Lutfi Kurniawan said...

My love never looked at who you never wanted you to be more than you are

Obat Penyumbatan Pembuluh Darah Otak
Obat Tangan Kesemutan
Obat Flu Singapura
Obat Luka Diabetes Bernanah
Cara Mengobati Pembekuan Darah Di Otak

gneral said...

يصعب أحيانا علي ربة المنزل أن تقوم بأعمال النظافة وحدها وخاصة في وجود أطفال أوانشغالها بعملها، وتحتاج إلى من يساعدها في انهاء مهام التنظيف، وأحيانا تمر عليه اوقات مناسبات أو عزومات وتحتار فيمن تقدم لها يد المساعدة، لذلك “شركة التقوي” تقدم لها كافة الخدمات المتميزة من أعمال التنظيف والترتيب والتلميع وتنسيق المنزل، ونقدم خدماتنا بكل أمان ودون قلق من استقدام الخادمات للعمل والقلق وعدم استئمانهم علي الممتلكات، فنحن شركة متميزة لنا باع طويل واسم وخبرة رائدة في مجال النظافة والتنظيف، نضمن لك خدمة متميزة، وأسعار خاصة، وأمان تام من أكثر شركة تنظيف المنازل.
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف سجاد بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حمام بالرياض
شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

gneral said...

تقدم شركة التقوي خدمة مكافحة حشرات بكافة أنواعها الطائرة والزاحفة، وكذلك مكافحة القوارض، للمنازل والشركات والمصانعو لا ننسي خدمة مكافحة الثعابين والزواحف ضمن خدماتن
ا
خدمتنا مميزة في هذا المجال وبرنامجنا في المكافحة مطور بإستخدام أجود أنواع المبيدات الحشرية الآمنة وننفذه بطريقة علمية علي
أيدي خبراء مدربين علي أعلي مستوي وبعد المكافحة نقدم برنامج الوقاية اللازم لضمان جودة الخدمة المقدمة ولضمان عدم وجود أي
حشرات مخبأة أو في أماكن التوالد غير المرئية
مع خدماتنا المتميزة لن تقلق علي مصنعك وأجهزتك ومعداتك ولن يخاف أبناؤك من الحشرات أو القوارض بعد اليوم
. اتصل بنا وتعرف علي عروضنا المتميزة المقدمة من شركة التقوي للخدمات المتكاملة

شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
شركة جلي بلاط بالرياض
شركة التقوي للخدمات المنزلية بالرياض

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
شركة بيع وشراء اثاث بالرياض
شركة صيانة مكيفات بالرياض
شركة صيانة مسابح بالرياض
شركة تركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياض

Meela Jasmine said...

You should take part in a contest for one of the best blogs on the web. I will recommend this site!

Website
Information
Click Here

Do My Computer Science Project said...

I Appreciate This Work Amazing Post For Us I Like It.

Arya said...


Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
norton.com/setup
www mcafee activate
AVG support number
kaspersky contact number
trendmicro com bestbuypc

Arya said...

Thank for Sharing Such Nice Things.
activate my norton product key
mcafee.com activate key
AVG Antivirus phone number
webroot phone number
kaspersky phone number
Outlook Phone number
webroot antivirus activation code



hằng vũ said...

It's great, wish you success in the next blog, this is a post that we all should read at least once. I would love to keep track of your posts, it is really a useful source of information, wish you success.
friv 4 school math games, jogos para crianças, friv 4 school math games 2019, cá koi mini

meldaresearch said...

Our Buy Custom Essay Service Online is normally written by professionals who have sufficient experience in writing academic papers in any discipline. Our customer service is available 24/7, which makes it easy for clients to place orders and receive their Online Custom Essay Writing Services on time.

meldaresearch said...

Our Cheap Nursing Term Papers are designed in such a way that there are standby writers all the time to work on the requested orders and complete them on time for timely delivery. Our Affordable Custom Term Papers are always available since we offer customized services to suit all your needs at an affordable fee.

Angel Claudia said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Rachel Pike said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
Avast Customer Service
McAfee Customer Service Phone Number
AVG Customer Service Number
kaspersky customer service Phone number
hp printer support number

Rachel Pike said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
AVG contact number

800tollfreenumber said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
How to Solve Norton Error Code 9999, 174?
How to Fix AVG Download and Installation Failure Issue?
How to Fix Antivirus Error 12152 or 7305

Jack said...

How The Antivirus Detects Virus?
How Does Antivirus Software Program Protect The Framework Of the Computer
Reliable Antivirus Software For The Safety of Your Computer
Why It Is necessary to Update Antivirus Software Regularly

BHBUJJWALSAINI said...

Thanks you sharing information.
You can also visit on

How to think positive

Cure For Cowardice

Mudras

SOCIAL ANXIETY AND LOW SELF-ESTEEM

PUBLIC MEETING AND PRESENTATION

HOME WORKOUT PLAN

Assignment help Australia said...

No one can write a blog like you, thank to write blog allassignmenthelp.com always help of university student to make an assignment before the deadline.
editing proofreading service

800tollfreenumber said...

Thanks you sharing information.
Learn How to Install & Activate McAfee Antivirus
Top Approaches with Norton Support to Guard Your New Gadgets

Jack said...

What is a Trojan Horse and How Can I Remove it from My Computer?
12 Tips for Online Safety and Security
How to Choose the Perfect Internet Security Suite for your Computer
What is Trojan horse virus and how can I remove it manually

Barbara Pantuso said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
Musical Education: Music Alive

Emma Ludwig said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
Quotes About Girls: Way to Learn Your Significance
How Else Could You Spend Your Birthday

Unknown said...

For the doors are made 4 holes in each wooden door and poured pesticides, as well as the work of openings under the door
شركة مكافحة حشرات بسكاكا
شركة رش مبيدات بسكاكا
المبيدات الحشرية الكيميائية
افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات

Unknown said...

For the doors are made 4 holes in each wooden door and poured pesticides, as well as the work of openings under the door
شركة مكافحة حشرات بسكاكا
شركة رش مبيدات بسكاكا
المبيدات الحشرية الكيميائية
افضل شركة مكافحة حشرات

Justicehorus said...

The method and software that I use now to compile the list has changed. I hope to build a better list as I learn how. Read all about it in my latest blog post. Have a great day everyone!

Travel Biz
Travelity

Rachel Pike said...

Thanks for sharing such a nice Blog.I like it.
Mcafee Customer Service

Wedding Venues in Delhi said...

Searching for wedding venues in Delhi? Visit Get Your Venue! With over 8 years of experience, you can count on Get Your Venue's attentive service to help make your special day one you’ll cherish forever. Call today!

Wedding Venues in Delhi said...

The Fusion Decor provides you with an elegant and classy selection of wedding decorations in Delhi to help you plan your wedding day. Find everything you need: outdoor wedding decorations, table wedding decorations, church wedding decorations, indian wedding decorations, winter wedding decorations. Visit us for more information.

Wedding Venues in Delhi said...

Get Your Menu provides high quality catering services, high standard cuisine for wedding or other party. Create some buzz at your wedding reception by using this amazing wedding caterers in Delhi.

«Oldest ‹Older   1001 – 1034 of 1034   Newer› Newest»