(I could have put a "wonkish" warning at the top, but come on, just look at the title!)

Let's start with the concept of the natural real interest rate, which is already ubiquitous. The real interest-rate is the interest rate corrected for expected inflation, and the natural real interest rate is the real interest rate consistent with price stability. (I leave the definition of price stability ambiguous because it depends on your theory of the price level and inflation, which is a whole 'nother blog post.)

Now market monetarists like Scott Sumner and Nick Rowe point to a deficiency in the natural real interest rate concept: the natural real interest rate depends on the expected real growth rate. And monetary policy affects the expected real growth rate, so if policymakers try to set the actual interest rate equal to the natural rate, they are chasing a moving target. To me, this criticism suggests that the appropriate approach is to adjust the nominal interest rate not for expected inflation but for expected nominal growth. (While we're at it, we can also replace "price stability" with "nominal growth stability" and be done with our futile attempts to measure the aggregate price level.)

Most economists think that the natural real interest rate is normally positive. I have my doubts, but never mind, because I'm ditching the whole concept. Once we start correcting for expected normal growth rather than expected inflation, we are clearly not dealing with a natural rate concept that can be presumed to be normally positive. If we are talking about a risk-free interest rate, then the need for physical capital returns to compensate for risk would make it very hard to achieve ~~a long-run growth rate~~ [an equilibrium with the interest rate] as high as the [growth] ~~interest~~ rate, let alone higher. To come up with a number that's usually positive, I suggest that we reverse the sign. Instead of talking about a "natural growth-adjusted interest rate," let's talk about a "natural discounted growth rate."

We can also talk about an "actual discounted expected growth rate." (The discount is "actual," determined by the observable interest rate, but the associated growth rate is only "expected" because it is not known with any confidence when the interest rate is set.) If the actual rate equals the natural rate, you get a normal employment level and nominal income growth stability (or price stability, if you insist). If the actual rate is higher, you get accelerating inflation. If the natural rate is higher, you get depressed economic conditions, with excess unemployment and deflationary pressure, if not actual deflation. (Wicksellians, please recall that I have reversed the signs compared to the usual natural rate theory.)

Now that I've defined the natural discounted growth rate, I can define "secular stagnation" in the context of an NGDP target. Secular stagnation means that the natural discounted growth rate exceeds the growth rate of the NGDP target path. In other words, the target path would require a negative nominal interest rate. Under a level targeting regime, an attempt to pursue such a path will result in either monetary instrument instability or a "zigzag" growth pattern in which recessions alternate with inflationary catch-up periods. Under a growth rate targeting regime, you'll just keep missing the target from below, much like most of the developed world's central banks today.

But if you play with the numbers, you can probably convince yourself that secular stagnation, by my definition, seems unlikely. A reasonable NGDP target path growth rate is maybe 5%. Do we really think that the potential growth rate exceeds the natural interest rate by more than five percentage points? It's remotely conceivable, but my guess would be that our problem today is not secular stagnation (in this sense) but a flawed monetary policy regime.

Now if the target nominal growth rate (and the associated possibility of secular stagnation) is one of our bookends for the natural discounted growth rate, the other bookend is pretty clear: it's zero. Some readers will immediately recognize zero as the criterion for dynamic efficiency. Ignoring the issue of risk for a moment, an economy with a strictly positive natural discounted growth rate would be dynamically inefficient. Overall welfare could be improved by instituting a stable Ponzi scheme that transfers consumption backward across generations.

Does my assertion that the natural discounted growth rate is almost certainly strictly positive imply that we actually live in a dynamically inefficient economy? In an important sense, I think it does. The thorny issue here is risk, and some will argue that the relevant interest rate for dynamic inefficiency is not the risk-free rate. But I disagree. The US government can produce assets that are considered virtually risk free, and a stable Ponzi scheme operated by the US government could presumably produce such assets yielding any amount up to the growth rate. At today’s Treasury interest rates, which are clearly less than expected growth rates, marginal investors are (we can presume, since the assets are freely traded) indifferent between these low-yielding Treasury securities and investments that represent newly created capital. So, given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, the government could, by operating a stable Ponzi scheme, be producing assets that have a higher risk-adjusted return than newly created capital. Given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, it’s inefficient for the government not to be producing such assets.

It’s important to recognize that, under a typical scenario, the marginal investor will end up worse off, in a material sense, from earning the growth rate, compared to earning the actual return on capital. In a material sense, the economy is dynamically efficient. But the concept of risk preferences models a subjective good – call it “security” – and we’re not producing enough of this good. The history of interest rates and growth rates suggests that we have seldom produced enough security, but the deficiency today is clearly worse than usual.

DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

## 1,022 comments:

«Oldest ‹Older 1001 – 1022 of 1022This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.

Uber Clone Script

Uber Clone App

Excellent and very exciting site. Love to watch. Keep Rocking.

jasaqq

Organic farming

Top organic farm

Best organic farm in Rajasthan

Top organic farm in India

Organic Pomegranate Farming

Organic thai ber farm

Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found the information I was looking for. Once again, thank you so much.

cara menghilangkan bekas luka bakar

cara mengobati ptosis

cara menghilangkan benjolan seperti bisul di ketiak

cara mengobati bronkitis

cara mengobati impetigo pada anak

cara menyembuhkan fistula ani

You are very good author because of this blog posting. there are you provide interesting news about chemicals. Generally i search lots of new blog for this information but i did not get conform information pikview

obat wasir setelah melahirkan

Gracias por compartir su pasión por el mejoramiento de Kizi Games Friv Games las vidas de los niños en el Estado de Friv Jeux De Fille Jogos Friv Gracias por vuestras reacciones a Jogos Friv Juegos Friv Juegos Kizi Gry Friv las transmisiones que os han hecho.

obat wasir setelah melahirkan

Tourist Places in Himachal Pradesh

Travel Destination Near Manali

Beautifull Hill Station Shimla for Couples

Tourist Place Near Kasauli

Weekend Destination near Chamba

Weekend Destination near Kufri

obat wasir setelah melahirkan

obat wasir setelah melahirkan

obat penyakit kawasaki

The post is written in very a good manner and it contains many useful information for me. Thank you very useful information admin, and pardon me permission to share articles here may help :

risa herbal

obat benjolan

toko obat herbal sapnudin

sehatdancantikalami

khasiat obat herbal

cara menghilangkan bekas jerawat

One of the ways to increase sales and profits is to constantly search for new markets.

20 inches weave hair

18 inches weave hair

manfaat gula aren untuk asam urat

Thank you for another fantastic posting. Where else could anyone get that kind of information in such a perfect way of writing? I have a speech next week, and I was looking for more info ;)

cara menyembuhkan mata katarak

cara mengobati sakit kepala cluster

cara mengobati liver

cara mengobati gusi bengkak

cara menurunkan leukosit tinggi

penyebab haid tidak lancar

cara mengobati diare

cara mengobati mata bengkak

Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found the information I was looking for. Once again, thank you so much.

cara menyembuhkan radang tenggorokan

obat tumor otak alami

obat infeksi jamur pada miss v

cara mengatasi rahang bengkak

pengobatan bidai tulang kering

cara mengobati glaukoma

Tourist Place Near Kumarakom

Weekend Destination near Kovalam

Tourist Places to Visit in Kollam

Most Famous Hotels & Honeymoon Resorts in Munnar

Places to Visit in Calicut (Kozhikode)

Places to visit in Varkala

Places to visit in Alleppey (Alappuzha)

You managed to hit the nail upon the top and also defined out the whole thing without having side effect , people could take a signal. Will likely be back to get more. Thanks

Tangki Panel

Tangki Fiberglass

Jual Septic Tank

Tangki Kimia

Jual Talang Fiber

Jual Rotameter

jual mesin ro

Jual Botol Plastik Agro

Jual Botol Plastik Murah

I was very pleased to find this web-site. I wanted to thanks for your time for this wonderful read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you blog post.

Website

Information

Hi there, I enjoy reading through your article.

I like to write a little comment to support you.

E aadhar card

Aadhar card download

Check Aadhar Card Status by name & moblie no.

e aadhar card update

Uidai help enquiry

Aadhar Card Correction

Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found the information I was looking for. Once again, thank you so much.

obat alami untuk menghilangkan kutil

cara mengobati hirschsprung

cara mengobati otitis eksterna

obat kaki bengkak akibat keseleo

obat tradisional abses payudara

obat luka koreng bernanah

Post a Comment