Friday, December 13, 2013

Stochastic Dynamic Inefficiency, Secular Stagnation, and the Natural Discounted Growth Rate


(I could have put a "wonkish" warning at the top, but come on, just look at the title!)

Let's start with the concept of the natural real interest rate, which is already ubiquitous. The real interest-rate is the interest rate corrected for expected inflation, and the natural real interest rate is the real interest rate consistent with price stability.  (I leave the definition of price stability ambiguous because it depends on your theory of the price level and inflation, which is a whole 'nother blog post.)

Now market monetarists like Scott Sumner and Nick Rowe point to a deficiency in the natural real interest rate concept: the natural real interest rate depends on the expected real growth rate. And monetary policy affects the expected real growth rate, so if policymakers try to set the actual interest rate equal to the natural rate, they are chasing a moving target. To me, this criticism suggests that the appropriate approach is to adjust the nominal interest rate not for expected inflation but for expected nominal growth. (While we're at it, we can also replace "price stability" with "nominal growth stability" and be done with our futile attempts to measure the aggregate price level.)

Most economists think that the natural real interest rate is normally positive. I have my doubts, but never mind, because I'm ditching the whole concept. Once we start correcting for expected normal growth rather than expected inflation, we are clearly not dealing with a natural rate concept that can be presumed to be normally positive.  If we are talking about a risk-free interest rate, then the need for physical capital returns to compensate for risk would make it very hard to achieve a long-run growth rate [an equilibrium with the interest rate] as high as the [growth] interest rate, let alone higher. To come up with a number that's usually positive, I suggest that we reverse the sign. Instead of talking about a "natural growth-adjusted interest rate," let's talk about a "natural discounted growth rate."

We can also talk about an "actual discounted expected growth rate."  (The discount is "actual," determined by the observable interest rate, but the associated growth rate is only "expected" because it is not known with any confidence when the interest rate is set.) If the actual rate equals the natural rate, you get a normal employment level and nominal income growth stability (or price stability, if you insist). If the actual rate is higher, you get accelerating inflation. If the natural rate is higher, you get depressed economic conditions, with excess unemployment and deflationary pressure, if not actual deflation. (Wicksellians, please recall that I have reversed the signs compared to the usual natural rate theory.)

Now that I've defined the natural discounted growth rate, I can define "secular stagnation" in the context of an NGDP target. Secular stagnation means that the natural discounted growth rate exceeds the growth rate of the NGDP target path.  In other words, the target path would require a negative nominal interest rate.  Under a level targeting regime, an attempt to pursue such a path will result in either monetary instrument instability or a "zigzag" growth pattern in which recessions alternate with inflationary catch-up periods. Under a growth rate targeting regime, you'll just keep missing the target from below, much like most of the developed world's central banks today. 

But if you play with the numbers, you can probably convince yourself that secular stagnation, by my definition, seems unlikely. A reasonable NGDP target path growth rate is maybe 5%.  Do we really think that the potential growth rate exceeds the natural interest rate by more than five percentage points? It's remotely conceivable, but my guess would be that our problem today is not secular stagnation (in this sense) but a flawed monetary policy regime.

Now if the target nominal growth rate (and the associated possibility of secular stagnation) is one of our bookends for the natural discounted growth rate, the other bookend is pretty clear: it's zero. Some readers will immediately recognize zero as the criterion for dynamic efficiency. Ignoring the issue of risk for a moment, an economy with a strictly positive natural discounted growth rate would be dynamically inefficient. Overall welfare could be improved by instituting a stable Ponzi scheme that transfers consumption backward across generations.

Does my assertion that the natural discounted growth rate is almost certainly strictly positive imply that we actually live in a dynamically inefficient economy? In an important sense, I think it does.  The thorny issue here is risk, and some will argue that the relevant interest rate for dynamic inefficiency is not the risk-free rate.  But I disagree.  The US government can produce assets that are considered virtually risk free, and a stable Ponzi scheme operated by the US government could presumably produce such assets yielding any amount up to the growth rate.  At today’s Treasury interest rates, which are clearly less than expected growth rates, marginal investors are (we can presume, since the assets are freely traded) indifferent between these low-yielding Treasury securities and investments that represent newly created capital.  So, given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, the government could, by operating a stable Ponzi scheme, be producing assets that have a higher risk-adjusted return than newly created capital.  Given the risk preferences of the marginal investor, it’s inefficient for the government not to be producing such assets.

It’s important to recognize that, under a typical scenario, the marginal investor will end up worse off, in a material sense, from earning the growth rate, compared to earning the actual return on capital.  In a material sense, the economy is dynamically efficient.  But the concept of risk preferences models a subjective good – call it “security” – and we’re not producing enough of this good.  The history of interest rates and growth rates suggests that we have seldom produced enough security, but the deficiency today is clearly worse than usual.  



DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product. 

854 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   801 – 854 of 854
Faizan ali said...

visit this website and get the latest business news in Pakistan. Business News Pakistan

Faizan ali said...

Checkout for the latest business, economic and financial news from Pakistan and around the world. Pakistan Stock Market News

Cara Mengobati Penyakit Kuning Pada Bayi Umur 2 Bulan said...

obat penyakit kuning pada bayi

obat iritasi kulit bayi said...

obat iritasi kulit bayi

Harga Dan Khasiat QnC Jelly Gamat said...

harga dan khasiat qnc jelly gamat

reda gamal said...

اليكم اليوم عزيزى العميل افضل شركات التنظيف فى المملكة العربية السعودية وهى شركة ركن الشروق التى تمتاز بالعمالة الفنية ذو الخبرة الكبيرة فى مجال التنظيف ومكافحة الحشرات ونقل العفش الى جميع انحاء المملكة كما ان الشركة لديها خبرة كبيرة من كثرة العمل فى مجال التنظيف فىى المملكة . شركة تنظيف بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة نقل عفش بالرياض
شركة تنظيف خزانات بابها
شركة نقل عفش بابها
شركة مكافحة حشرات بابها
شركة تنظيف بالطائف
شركة نقل عفش بالطائف
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض


juegos fofy said...

Di nuovo, ringrazio il Parlamento perché condivide la prospettiva di una Fofy Games Friv Jogos Fofy nuova politica per i consumatori basata sul mercato Juegos Friv Twizl Friv Per anni vi siete affidati ad Ethernet per la condivisione di informazioni Jogos Twizl Twizl Friv Twizy Games ous Grazie per condividere con noi Twizl Yoob i tuoi piani e mostrare paso dopo passo il progetto.

cara mengatasi radang usus pada anak said...

cara mengatasi radang usus pada anak

juegos kiz i2017 said...


Herr Cashman, ich danke Ihnen für diese Information. Juegos Yepi Juegos Twizl Wir danken aber auch Ihnen Juegos Friv Friv 2 Friv 2.0 liebe Leserinnen und Leser, fur Ihr Interesse und Ihre Mitwirkung Juegos Friv 2.0 Juegos Friv 20 Juegos Friv 4 Friv 3 die Informationsgesellschaft in der Schweiz voranzubringen.

KarlDeville said...

Thank you for taking the time and sharing this information with us. It was indeed very helpful and insightful while being straight forward and to the point.
http://www.mcdonaldsgutscheine.net/ | http://www.startlr.com/ | http://www.saludlimpia.com/

evelyndana09@gmail.com said...

New experience for each of your emotions. Thrilling, vibrations of love, adventure adventurous or want to destroy all ... are transformed into this
24 hour check cashing

Cara Menghilangkan Jerawat Batu Di Dahi Secara Alami said...

cara menghilangkan jerawat batu di dahi secara alami

acep saepul milah said...

Thank you article, Also read this article
Walatra Sehat Mata Softgel

عبده العمراوى said...

شركة نقل اثاث بالدمام
شركة تنظيف مسابح بالدمام

AVI Homeopathy said...

Great post,Thanks for providing us this great knowledge,Keep it up. Best Homeopathy Doctor in Jaipur

reda gamal said...

ليس من السهل الحصول على شركة متميزة ومتخصصه لعملية التنظيف ومكافحة الحشرات ونقل العفش وغيرها من الخدمات فشركتنا رائده في هذا المجاال وجعل منزلك راقي وجميل حيث يتوفر لدى شركتنا عمال فلبيين وغيرهم متميزون وعلى درجه كبيره من الكفاءه والخبره كما ان شركة ركن الشروق يتوفر لديها افضل المعدات واحداثها التي تجعل الشركة متقدمه عن غيرها وجعل امور المنزل من تنظيف او مكافحة او نقل امر سهل وراقي في العمل عزيزي العميل نتمني منك الاسراع الينا وطلب الخدمة التي تريدها وسوف يصل اليك فريق على درجه كبيره من التميز والخبره والسرعه في العمل اتصل بنا ولا تتردد نصلك اينما كنت شركة تسليك مجاري بابها
شركة مكافحة حشرات بابها
شركة نقل عفش بابها

شركة تنظيف خزانات بابها
شركة تنظيف بالطائف

شركة نقل عفش بالطائف




Nikshit Narula said...

Awesome Post!
Check out Diwali Greetings 2017
Also download latest movie LOGAN 2017 DUAL AUDIO 720P BLURAY HINDI
Also Read trending Story Expectations vs reality
Also Check out Latest Government Job of Karnataka Recruitment 2017

valentine day said...

Merry Christmas & Happy New Year Traditions

OBAT KANKER PAYUDARA said...

Very useful, thank you very much for the information ... !! Visit also our
OBAT ASAM URAT
OBAT STROKE
OBAT JANTUNG KORONER
OBAT KOLESTEROL
OBAT KANKER PAYUDARA
G-SEA JELLY GAMAT EMAS
OBAT GLAUKOMA
OBAT KELENJAR GETAH BENING
WALATRA GAMAT EMAS KAPSUL

ails said...

Best Eco Friendly Diwali 2017 Slogans

http://www.cooldiwaliquotes.com/2017/08/happy-deepavali-images-free-download-HD.html

More

See more

happy Diwali 2017 Wishes in Sanskrit

http://www.cooldiwaliquotes.com/2017/08/best-rangoli-designs-for-diwali.html

obat asam urat untuk ibu hamil said...

obat asam urat untuk ibu hamil

promo qnc jelly gamat said...

Pengobatan alternatif stroke ringan yang ampuh

promo qnc jelly gamat said...

Pengobatan alternatif stroke ringan yang ampuh

obat batuk bronkitis pada anak said...

obat batuk bronkitis pada anak

Riju Aggarwal said...

SBI Clerk Admit Card 2017 download
AFCAT Admit Card 2017 Download

Download Roblox APK
IERT Result 2017 Download

Playstore Issue on Freedom Apk
Freedom APK 2.0.9 Latest Download

Freedom Latest APK Download
Freedom APK Download

mac customer support said...

i really glad too see your post always you post very interesting .if you have any issue in mac or apple product .and you want any Mac Customer Support

mcafee support said...

if you have any problem related to dell product than contact with our team.
dell support number

sarkar said...

FCI Recruitment
FCI Recruitment 2017
Food Corporation of India Recruitment

NIT Jamshedpur Recruitment
Nit Recruitment 2017

UKSSSC Recruitment 2017
UKSSSC Recruitment

Anonymous said...

Ms Excel 2010
Amazing.

tanaman obat gondok beracun said...

obat gondok beracun

gujratlion said...


bigg boss 11
Bigg boss whatsapp status
whatsapp status
Happy diwali
good morning wishes
gujrat lion
Gujrati Singer

obat denature said...

nice........
I like for what you inform the public ...... thank you and success always .......
read also my websaite ..... please ......

Obat Untuk Penderita Penyakit Ambeien
Obat Ambeien Ampuh
Obat Ambeien Ampuh
Obat Ambeien Ampuh

Lenovo Customer Support Number said...

Amazing post and please keep posting like this...

mcafee customer support number said...

nice post.

Obat abses gigi pada anak said...

Terimakasih artikelnya sangat bermanfaat sekali

hermawan fauzi said...

obat gondok beracun

cara menyembuhkan gendang telinga pecah said...

Cara menyembuhkan gendang telinga pecah

mohan said...

Microsoft Office Support Number
Amazing.

Obat Cedera Lutut said...


Obat Cedera Lutut

gujratlion said...

bigg boss 11
Bigg boss whatsapp status
whatsapp status
Happy diwali
good morning wishes
gujrat lion
Gujrati Singer
Mahesh Babu Dialouge
Click here
good morning wallpaper
diwali 2017 good morning
Diwali Wishes
Christmas wishes

Aavuj Reshe Gujrati Movie
Upcoming gujrati Movie
Jigli And khajur
Khajur & Jigli
Gujrati Comedy Video
Kabutri and Popat
Popat & kabutri
Gujrati Comedy Videos
Aavuj Reshe Movie Box Office Collection

Cleaning services said...


تقدم افضل شركات تنظيف بالرياض خدمات التنظيف وكشف التسربات بالرياض حيث ان الشركة لها باع طويل فى تقديم الحلول فى مجال النظافه
وهناك بعض الخدمات منها كماتقدم الشركة كفاه خدمات التنظيف وكشف التسربات والغزل عميلانا العزيز تفضل بزياره
شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض

شركة تسليك مجارى شرق الرياض
شركة تسليك مجارى غرب الرياض
شركة تسليك مجارى جنوب الرياض
شركة تسليك مجارى شمال الرياض

شركة نقل اثاث شرق الرياض
شركة نقل اثاث جنوب الرياض
شركة نقل اثاث شمال الرياض
شركة نقل اثاث غرب الرياض


acep saepul milah said...

Thank you article, Also read this article
Obat Herpes
Obat Herpes Terbaik

netgear router customer service said...

amazing blog

Aline Santos said...

This is a great article. It gave me a lot of useful information. thank you very much.
FIT RED

Anonymous said...

cara-pemesanan-walatra-zedorill-7

Indra Dhawa said...


Good post I am glad to see your post
outlook support number keep posting

Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu Terbaik said...

It is totally unique information; I really love reading this again and again. Thanks Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu Terbaik You will find a lot of approaches after visiting your post. Great work read this Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu Terbaik

Cara Mengobati Tbc Kulit Secara Alami said...

Cara Mengobati Tbc Kulit Secara Alami

Indra Dhawa said...


Amazing post.Lovely content work I am glad to see your post
outlook support keep posting.

BEST DATING APPS said...

great post and thanks for this.

Indra Dhawa said...

Wonderful post.now a days hookup apps are very popular you can check best
hookup apps keep posting.

Cara Mengobati Penglihatan Kurang Jelas said...

Thank you for the information, and healthy greetings.

Cara Mengobati Penglihatan Kurang Jelas

Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu said...

Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu
Obat Herbal Infeksi Saluran Empedu

Holly Peppers said...

We honestly want to serve you the simplest matters with 100 percentage satisfactions. It is extraordinarily exhausting to say as soon as exactly must be forced to money your test. Usually it http://www.unitedcheckcashing.com ought to terribly tough to cash if it is now not official hours.check cashing near me

«Oldest ‹Older   801 – 854 of 854   Newer› Newest»