Monday, October 24, 2011

Can Knut Wicksell Beat Up Chuck Norris?

Nick Rowe argues that NGDP targeting is a way of dealing with coordination failure. Businesses don’t want to hire if nobody’s buying, and households don’t want to buy if nobody’s hiring. So they’re all hoarding money instead. The way to fix it is that you have Chuck Norris threaten to beat up anyone who hoards money. Then businesses start hiring and households start buying (or else they both buy riskier assets, and the people who sold those assets do the hiring and buying, because they also don’t want to be beat up for hoarding the proceeds).

In the simplest version of the argument, beating people up is a metaphor for inflation. But if you don’t believe the Fed can produce more inflation (as many economists believe that the Bank of Japan has tried and failed to produce a positive inflation rate over the past 20 years), you can take beating people up as a metaphor for reducing asset returns. Even if the Fed can’t produce inflation, it can bid down the returns on a lot of assets until people get fed up and start buying riskier assets that can finance new expenditures. Some people don’t even think the Fed can do that, because maybe people have such a strong need for safety that they will only hoard more cash if other safe asset returns go down. I’m not 100% sure myself, but, for the sake of argument, I’m going to assume that the Fed can, if it is aggressive enough in buying safe assets, convince people to buy enough risky assets to get the economy going again.

Nick’s point, though, is that the Fed can do this without actually reducing the return on safe asests (and presumably without producing a lot of inflation either). Chuck Norris can clear a room without actually beating anyone up. The threat is enough. Similarly, in Nick’s view, the Fed can fix a coordination failure by threatening to reduce the return on safe assets, but it won’t have to carry out that threat if it’s credible. In fact, asset returns will go up, because the improved economy will make businesses more profitable, thus raising the return on risky assets and inducing people to abandon safe assets even if the yields go up. Paradoxically, by credibly threatening to push asset returns down, the Fed succeeds in pushing them up.

OK, fine. I’ll note that Ben Bernanke is no Chuck Norris, but perhaps President Romney will replace him with Chuck Norris, or with the antimatter counterpart of Paul Volcker (who was the Chuck Norris of inflation fighting). I’ll also note that Chairman Norris will enter with a considerable handicap, given that many are uncertain about the Fed’s ability to succeed in convincing people to abandon safe assets. If the threat were credible and everyone knew it to be credible, then everyone would know that stock prices are going up and they really ought to sell their bonds as quickly as they can, and we’d immediately be on the path to the good equilibrium. But even with Chuck Norris as Fed Chairman, a lot of people are going to think, “What if the Fed fails? At least cash is safe.” The threat alone quite possibly won’t be enough: Chuck Norris may well have to beat up a bunch of people – QE, Walker style – before the room clears.

But OK, I’m not opposed to violence, when it’s the only way to get something done. Only here’s my concern: how do we know that coordination failure is the real problem?

Flash back to 2006. There was no coordination failure then. Firms were hiring. Households were buying. Commerce was functioning smoothly. Very smoothly, too, in the sense that the economy was neither overheating (no rising inflation, no labor shortage) nor driving interest rates abnormally high. (The 10-year TIPS yield ranged from 1.95% to 2.68% in 2006, consistently below the perceived long-run real growth rate of the US economy.)

Yet that smoothness was based on being completely out of touch with reality – or at least out of touch with what most people today regard the reality to have been. By most accounts, housing prices were inflated, making people feel wealthier than they really were, and lots of seemingly safe assets were available, which, as it turned out, were not at all safe. Even with interest rates relatively low, this deception was apparently necessary in order to get households to buy and firms to hire in sufficient quantities to achieve full employment. Since the deception is no longer feasible, interest rates will presumably have to be a lot lower – even if we rule out coordination failure – in order to induce enough buying and enough hiring today to achieve full employment.

But how much lower? We can’t say exactly. Today 10-year TIPS are yielding close to zero. Is that low enough, if it weren’t for coordination failure? Maybe. Maybe not. Your guess is as good as mine. I can certainly imagine that could we fix the coordination failure (if there is one) and still end up producing well below our capacity.

That’s where Knut Wicksell comes in. Wicksell was the early 20th century economist who argued that prices would tend to go up or down depending on whether the interest rate was below or above its “natural” level (which varied over time). Modern interpretations allow for sticky prices and wages, so instead of falling prices, you get unemployment when the interest rate is too high. As I suggested in a post last year, and in the paragraph above, the “natural interest rate” could be negative, in which case a higher inflation rate is the only way to achieve full employment.

For practical purposes I advocate the same policy that Nick does – nominal GDP targeting – but I’m a bit less optimistic about how quickly and smoothly we could approach the target. And, given a choice, I’d probably favor a more aggressive target than Nick would. One of the implications of the Wicksellian analysis (which is not so clear if you think coordination failure is the only problem) is that more aggressive targets are easier to hit, because they imply higher inflation rates and therefore a lower floor on the real interest rate.

The important thing is to set a target path and stick to it even if you keep missing the first few targets by larger and larger margins. If the natural interest rate is negative, the early targets may be impossible to hit, but if you continue trying to hit the subsequent targets, those targets will imply higher inflation rates. Suppose your target path rises by 5% per year. A 10% increase in NGDP over two years may not imply enough inflation to get the real interest rate down to its natural level, but if NGDP doesn’t rise at all in those two years, the target path will now imply 20% NGDP growth over the subsequent two year period. That would require a lot of inflation – certainly enough to be consistent with a very negative natural real interest rate. Chuck Norris may take his hits in the first few years, but Knut is eventually going down.




DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

438 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 438 of 438
Future Generali said...

Future Generali Car Insurance
Future Generali Hospital Cash Plan
Future Generali Health Total
Future Generali Travel Insurance
Things are very open and intensely clear explanation of issues. was truly information. Your website is very beneficial.

Easyday Benefits said...

Easyday Blog
Easyday About Us
Easyday Terms Conditions
Easyday Club Locator
Thank you; I enjoyed reading this post and it helped me gain some insight on this topic.

David Dhavan said...

You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this topic to be really something which I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and very broad for me. I am looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

akinfo said...

emmc course in dhaka

holloway vs poirier live stream said...


Watch UFC 236 live Stream
Watch UFC 236 live Stream
Watch UFC 236 live Stream
Watch UFC 236 live Stream

Unknown said...

Private Label Organic Cosmetics in India

Best Private Label Cosmetics in India

Cosmetic products manufacturers in India

Best Private Label cosmetics manufacturers in India

Private Label Cosmetic Packaging in India

Private Label Cosmetics Wholesale in India


Escorts Services in Pakistan said...

Escorts Services in Pakistan

Escorts in Karachi
Karachi Escorts

Escorts in Karachi
Karachi Lahore

Escorts in Lahore

UFC Live said...

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

Canelo vs Jacob

Canelo vs Jacob Live

Canelo vs Jacob Live Stream

Canelo vs Jacob Live Streaming

Canelo vs Jacob Live Stream Free

Canelo vs Jacob Live Stream Free Online



https://disqus.com/home/channel/nfl/discussion/channel-nfl/live_canelo_vs_jacobs_live_stream_free_online/

https://disqus.com/home/channel/nfl/discussion/channel-nfl/live_canelo_vs_jacobs_live_stream_free_online/

https://disqus.com/home/channel/nfl/discussion/channel-nfl/live_canelo_vs_jacobs_live_stream_free_online/

https://disqus.com/home/channel/nfl/discussion/channel-nfl/live_canelo_vs_jacobs_live_stream_free_online/

https://disqus.com/home/channel/nfl/discussion/channel-nfl/live_canelo_vs_jacobs_live_stream_free_online/

Anonymous said...

If you Intereste The Live Boxing Match Betwin Canelo vs Jacobs You Can Click This Link or Copy & browse your secarch engin.
You Can Watch The Boxing Free in HD.
You Can Get All Some Boxing News By your Google Account That's free for you & only For You.
canelo vs jacobs live
canelo vs jacobs live stream
canelo vs jacobs live streaming
canelo vs jacobs live stream free
canelo vs jacobs live stream Free online
canelo vs jacobs live online
canelo vs jacobs live fight
jacobs vs canelo live
jacobs vs canelo live stream
jacobs vs canelo live streaming
jacobs vs canelo live stream free
jacobs vs canelo live stream Free online
jacobs vs canelo live online
jacobs vs canelo live fight
https://www.evensi.us/live-canelo-jacobs-stream-free-online/300596091

UFC Live said...


canelo vs jacobs live
canelo vs jacobs live stream
canelo vs jacobs live streaming
canelo vs jacobs live stream free
canelo vs jacobs live stream Free online
canelo vs jacobs live online
canelo vs jacobs live fight
jacobs vs canelo live
jacobs vs canelo live stream
jacobs vs canelo live streaming
jacobs vs canelo live stream free
jacobs vs canelo live stream Free online
jacobs vs canelo live online
jacobs vs canelo live fight

sxdfghg said...

Canelo vs Jacobs
Canelo vs Jacobs Live
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Live online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Facebook
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free on Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo

UFC Live said...

Canelo vs Jacobs
Canelo vs Jacobs Live
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Live online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Facebook
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free on Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo

UFC Live said...

Canelo vs Jacobs
Canelo vs Jacobs Live
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Live online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Stream
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live Streaming
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Stream Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Streaming Online
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Free Live On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Twitter
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream On Facebook
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free on Reddit
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Stream Free On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo

Anonymous said...


Jacobs vs Canelo
Jacobs vs Canelo Live
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Streaming
Jacobs vs Canelo Live online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Fight
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Fight Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Streaming Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live Stream
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live Streaming
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Stream Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Streaming Online

UFC Live said...


Jacobs vs Canelo Live
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Streaming
Jacobs vs Canelo Live online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Fight
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Fight Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Streaming Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live Stream
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live Streaming
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Stream Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Streaming Online
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live On Reddit
Jacobs vs Canelo Free Live On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream On Reddit
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream On Facebook
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free on Reddit
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free On Twitter
Jacobs vs Canelo Live Stream Free On Facebook
Canelo vs Jacobs Live Fight

Agarwal Packers and Movers Ltd said...

Very Nice Blog, Thanks for This Post..it's Been Good Reading This.
Best Movers Singapore
Agarwal Movers Singapore Pte. Ltd Blog

Unknown said...

In India the biggest festival has arrived . Can anyone guess . Yes it is IPL .( INDIA KA TYOHAR). I just wait whole year to watch the matches .
My favourite team is MUMBAI INDIANS . vote now. For your favourite team

Unknown said...

Private Label Skin care products in India

Private Label Organic shampoo in India




S. Harris said...

As Best SEO Company, I really love the layout of this website and how perfectly the information provided

Future Generali Rural Insurance said...

Terra Chips
Future Retail
Future Consumer
Pantaloons

Kellogs said...

Kelloggs
Kellogs

Special

Kellogs Chocos
Kellogs Oats

kazima perfumers said...

Private Label Organic Cosmetics in India

Best Private Label Cosmetics in India

Unknown said...

Top Makeup Manufacturers in India

Private Label Hair products in India

Unknown said...

Private Label Hair care products in India

Private Label Aromatherapy in India

Private Label Organic essential oils in India

gneral said...

يصعب أحيانا علي ربة المنزل أن تقوم بأعمال النظافة وحدها وخاصة في وجود أطفال أوانشغالها بعملها، وتحتاج إلى من يساعدها في انهاء مهام التنظيف، وأحيانا تمر عليه اوقات مناسبات أو عزومات وتحتار فيمن تقدم لها يد المساعدة، لذلك “شركة التقوي” تقدم لها كافة الخدمات المتميزة من أعمال التنظيف والترتيب والتلميع وتنسيق المنزل، ونقدم خدماتنا بكل أمان ودون قلق من استقدام الخادمات للعمل والقلق وعدم استئمانهم علي الممتلكات، فنحن شركة متميزة لنا باع طويل واسم وخبرة رائدة في مجال النظافة والتنظيف، نضمن لك خدمة متميزة، وأسعار خاصة، وأمان تام من أكثر شركة تنظيف المنازل.
شركة تنظيف منازل بالرياض

شركة نقل اثاث بالرياض

شركة تنظيف سجاد بالرياض
شركة مكافحة حشرات بالرياض
شركة تنظيف خزانات بالرياض

شركة مكافحة حمام بالرياض
شركة تخزين اثاث بالرياض

gneral said...

تقدم شركة التقوي خدمة مكافحة حشرات بكافة أنواعها الطائرة والزاحفة، وكذلك مكافحة القوارض، للمنازل والشركات والمصانعو لا ننسي خدمة مكافحة الثعابين والزواحف ضمن خدماتن
ا
خدمتنا مميزة في هذا المجال وبرنامجنا في المكافحة مطور بإستخدام أجود أنواع المبيدات الحشرية الآمنة وننفذه بطريقة علمية علي
أيدي خبراء مدربين علي أعلي مستوي وبعد المكافحة نقدم برنامج الوقاية اللازم لضمان جودة الخدمة المقدمة ولضمان عدم وجود أي
حشرات مخبأة أو في أماكن التوالد غير المرئية
مع خدماتنا المتميزة لن تقلق علي مصنعك وأجهزتك ومعداتك ولن يخاف أبناؤك من الحشرات أو القوارض بعد اليوم
. اتصل بنا وتعرف علي عروضنا المتميزة المقدمة من شركة التقوي للخدمات المتكاملة

شركة رش مبيدات بالرياض
شركة جلي بلاط بالرياض
شركة التقوي للخدمات المنزلية بالرياض

شركة كشف تسربات المياه بالرياض
شركة بيع وشراء اثاث بالرياض
شركة صيانة مكيفات بالرياض
شركة صيانة مسابح بالرياض
شركة تركيب اثاث ايكيا بالرياض

Angel Claudia said...

We are among the best online companies providing affordable custom research paper writing services. When you cheap essay writing service USA and buy nursing essays online you get the services of experts and specialists in your field.

meldaresearchusa said...

To ease services,we avail web portal for best nursing writing services where US students make “write my essay” write my research paper and “write my paper” requests.

meldaresearchusa said...

Our assignment help USA have gained substantial knowledge in the 17 years we have been providing custom research paper for sale online services to students worldwide.

HẰNG said...

I accidentally saw your post and it attracted me from the first few seconds, it was excellent, hope you have more successful posts. I like this post because it contains a lot of useful information to read, maybe everyone will like me.
friv 4 school math games 2019, io jogos jogar, cá koi mini, abcya for kids

meldaresearch said...

Our Legitimate Essay Writing Service are unique and written from scratch. To ensure you that each Research Paper Services completed are non-plagiarized, we provide free plagiarism reports for each document upon the client’s request.

ahmed599 said...

There is no house does not enter by flies flies household insect, which is disgusting insects, which cause discomfort to her voice annoying as it stands on the body and on food and here transport germs and microbes carried in her foot to your food and to your body It also lays eggs anywhere
شركة رش مبيدات
شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بحائل
شركة مكافحة حشرات بحائل\
شركة رش مبيدات بحائل

sojib said...

This post is really useful and helpful to know more about the things which you have shared. I appreciate you for such a great amount of information. I assure this would be beneficial for many people

yasminabdullah said...

شركة تنظيف بالرياض
In fact, Hendry writes, the insects’ tunneling activities play a key role in improving soil quality, and their annual swarming trips provide a steady source of food for many bird species. Seagulls, however, may want to refrain from snacking on the winged ants.شركة تنظيف بالرياض Hart tells the Guardian that the birds can appear drunk after eating just a few of the insects, perhaps as a result of the formic acid found in the ants’ bodies.


شركة تنظيف بالرياض

petlove.com said...

This is extraordinary! The message I will go over here is ref, that it is a pointer. I have never heard that. I just hear that it is utilized to make changeless alterable.


ducomm

cửa gỗ công nghiệp hdf said...

Please bring you more articles read more. I enjoyed your blog. I will recommend to my friends about your blog

Huy Blog said...

The content of your article is very good, thank you for sharing this content, cho thuê cục phát wifi đi hàn quốc

Roksy said...

We have more than 5 years of experience in the technical education industry and are known for offering the best laptop repairing course in Patna, Bihar.

laptop repairing courses in Patna
laptop repairing training institute in Patna
laptop repairing institute in patna

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 438 of 438   Newer› Newest»