Monday, August 9, 2010

Inflation Targeting When the Natural Interest Rate is Negative

Over a century ago, in a theory that is still influential today, Swedish economist Knut Wicksell argued that, at any particular time, there is a certain “natural rate of interest” that is consistent with price stability. If the actual rate of interest falls below the natural rate, there is an incentive for entrepreneurs to borrow aggressively and demand more goods and more labor, driving prices up. If the actual rate rises above the natural rate, the incentive to borrow disappears, leading entrepreneurs to demand less goods and labor, driving prices down. Since the opportunities available to entrepreneurs are always changing, the natural rate is always changing, sometimes rising dramatically and at other times falling dramatically. Thus Wicksell argued that, relative to the natural rate, “the interest on money is, in reality, very often low when it seems to be high, and high when it seems to be low.”

As applied to the world we live in today, Wicksell’s original theory has several shortcomings, all widely recognized now. First, it doesn’t account for stickiness in wages and prices: as we observe, the short-run effect of a drop in demand is not so much a fall in wages and prices as a fall in employment. Second, it doesn’t account for the role of expectations in determining the price level and thus, the possibility of “inertial” inflation: it is now generally understood that (under a fiat money regime) a steadily rising price level, rather than a necessarily constant price level, is consistent with the equilibrium “natural” interest rate that Wicksell hypothesized. Third, it doesn’t fully account for the role of inflation expectations in defining the “real” interest rate: for example, a 2% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to be constant is equivalent to a 4% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to rise at a 2% rate. Finally, as I discuss below, it doesn’t account for the role of risk aversion in determining the behavior of entrepreneurs and those who finance them.

Wicksell argued that the natural interest rate was determined by the rate of return on capital. But in practice, the rate of return on capital is never known exactly in advance. Entrepreneurs require a compensation for the risk involved, and lenders (and buyers of stock and other forms of financing) require a compensation for the risk involved in financing them. As a result, particularly in times which are uncertain and when people are particularly risk-averse, there can be a very large wedge between the natural “risk-free” rate of interest and the rate of return on capital. One consequence of having such a large wedge is that, even if the return on capital is necessarily expected to be positive, the natural interest rate can be negative.

When the natural interest rate is negative, since it’s impossible to cut nominal interest rates much below zero, the only way to get back to normal is to create an expectation of inflation. If the nominal interest rate is zero and the inflation rate is positive, then the real interest rate is negative; thus it is possible, with a sufficient amount of expected inflation, to set the real interest rate down to the negative natural rate. But how can that inflation be achieved? Wicksell argues that prices rise when the actual interest rate falls below the natural rate, but in order for that to happen, prices must already be expected to rise. Can a central bank pull itself up by its own bootstraps?

The answer is almost certainly yes, since nearly everyone agrees that a sufficiently reckless central bank will always be able to produce a high inflation rate. (Imagine the Fed buying up the entire national debt, along with all the private sector’s offerings of commercial paper, mortgages, corporate bonds, and so on. Eventually, there will be inflation.) The problem is that it is hard to estimate in advance how aggressive monetary policy needs to be in order to produce the needed expectation of inflation. Not only doesn’t the central bank know what actions would produce a given “happy medium” target between too-low and too-high inflation expectations; it never really even knows what the natural interest rate is, so it doesn’t know how much inflation would be enough to get the real rate down to the natural rate.

If the central bank estimates wrong and overshoots, it risks a period of very high, and unnecessarily high, inflation. If (as seems infinitely more likely to me) it estimates wrong and undershoots, it risks reducing its credibility, so that it becomes more difficult, subsequently, to achieve the necessary inflation rate. (Note BTW that if you take the Mankiw Rule as an estimate of the natural interest rate, then the Fed’s current 2% inflation target is not high enough: the Fed is on a course to fail and thereby reduce its subsequent credibility.)

The solution is to aim not for an inflation rate but for a price level (or, as I suggested in my previous post, a level of nominal GDP). A series of price level targets that rises over time, but that does not get revised when the central bank undershoots or overshoots, allows for policy that automatically becomes more aggressive (or less aggressive) as necessary. If the central bank undershoots the first price level target, the second target is still in place, and this means it must aim for a higher inflation rate. If it undershoots the second target, the third is still in place, and it must aim for yet a higher inflation rate. And so on. Eventually, it will (automatically) find the inflation rate that works.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

31 comments:

Mark Biernat said...

I am a big fan of Knut Wicksell's theory of interest, prices and the cumulative process and have often felt his understanding of the rise and fall of prices has been over looked.
I agree with what you write that the marginal product of capital or the natural rate of interest can get stuck at such a low-level that monetary policy becomes ineffective, at least in the intermediate term. The effect will be seen on changes in the price level (but also growth).
If r<i then how can entrepreneurs rescue the economy?

-NGDP targeting

If the Fed over estimates or underestimate the natural rate of interest, which is does, then this will cause disequilibrium.
Your endorsement of NGDP targeting is interesting. It is something that I will seriously consider. I have to read more about it and consider this from various perspectives. Until then I am skeptical, but open. As a libertarian leaning person I think you will find some resistance on all sides until it is explain clearer for the man on the street.
I understand what you are saying but it might be a little more abstract for none economists. What might be easy for you to see might be harder to understand for a representative of the people, with no understanding of economics.
An idea might be is to continue to blog about this in a clear, non theoretical way. Nice and simple. If I am sold on the idea I will.

salman khan said...

But that’s actually aspect of the same tale that I’m telling: not only won’t developing a lot of money generate rising costs in the US; it also won’t generate rising costs in Chinese suppliers. direct flights to florida

salman khan said...

Good exclusive company exhibitions are okay for discussing details, but they will never substitute face-to-face conferences. sources tell me

salman khan said...

It is our intention to drive the first Electric Van for approximately 90 days and discover all of the nuances that might come with an EV or if there are any design changes we would like to have included with future vans,” said Robichaud. TUBE

Yasir Khalid said...

I like "lowness," the more proper nouns would be "low" or "lowliness" but "lowness" certainly drives it home. I might have used "lowsomeness" because it's more of a mouthful, more fun to pronounce. But I'll probably find myself using lowness from now on. Going Here

Yasir Khalid said...

I happen to think that organization exhibitions still hold value, whether you are there to program, see market buddies, rim and deal or to walk the shelves to explore a certain item or technological innovation. click reference link

Yasir Khalid said...

I'm liking the room setup of that hotel. The simple elegance reminds me so much of the hotels in paddington I've stayed in during my business trips. best site

Yasir Khalid said...

127There is also the point that much around the globe has come to rely on US transfer requirement and therefore will often assistance the cash. venus factor weight loss

salman khan said...

Carter Brown, CEO of Boulder Electric Vehicle and a Precision customer, invented the electric service truck, and convinced Robichaud to test-drive the truck that he felt would be a perfect fit for the service industry because of the short routes service technicians drive daily. one of the best in his field

Yasir Khalid said...

ome excellent insights into the book. Since then, I enjoyed many discussions at Imperial about how we can develop and use this approach. http://ir.wetsealinc.com/releasedetail.cfm?releaseid=543218

salman khan said...

The Technological Town Hall” at AHR Jan 28 at 1:00 p.m.Indicate has a success of experience with preparing company activities and he has hand to make AHR the effective display that it is today.I lately taken up with Indicate Halligan, CEO of H+A Globally, Chicago, illinois, il, about the very subject of company activities. Jason Halpern

Yasir Khalid said...

Google, what happened with Address Book-gate, why so many of Facebook’s early employees have left, what he learned from Steve Jobs and whether he could confirm stories about Path’s fundraising. (On that last one, he pled the fifth). Necklaces

Yasir Khalid said...

For far too long, our country has been under a regime that caters solely for the political elite at the expense of the people. We have some of the best educated and hardworking citizens in Southern Africa, and yet our unemployment rate remains at over 85 percent. This cannot be allowed to continue. Sam Tabar

Yasir Khalid said...

Many company activities, like contractors’ businesses, knowledgeable considerably during the excellent economic economic downturn of the last few years. Stansberry & Associates

salman khan said...

Carter Brownish, CEO of Boulder Power Automobile and a Perfection client, developed the electrical assistance vehicle, and assured Robichaud to test-drive the vehicle that he knowledgeable would be an ideal fit for the assistance market because of the brief tracks assistance specialists generate everyday. Laurene Powell Jobs

salman khan said...

It is then our objective to begin the conversion at two monthly. Logistically it needs a chance to exchange out an experienced to a new van and we do not want to overcome ourselves, although the earlier we change the earlier we begin preserving. which is something he adores

Yasir Khalid said...

Æs Hop Trip will be available October 1st, in 22-ounce bottles and on draft as part of the popular Bond Street Series.

Yasir Khalid said...

Æs Hop Trip will be available October 1st, in 22-ounce bottles and on draft as part of the popular Bond Street Series. Marc Sparks

Yasir Khalid said...

If the technology works, and in this case it seems that it does, it’s a win for everyone. One neat thing about being the first company to purchase the trucks is that Robichaud is pretty much involved in any design changes that may be made to the vehicle. including this foreward

salman khan said...

We are existing because we are not dead; though our daily way of life is packed with the emotional jumble of concepts, feelings, and applications, at another stage we have a low-level careful system that is always looking out for existential threats. steve holman

salman khan said...

Aside from just letting him chew on the links, I also used a chain of them to hook up toys to the stroller bars, so he could freely play with them but they won't drop to the floor. Just remember to buy spare filters, light bulbs and the powercable. old school new body steve holman

Anonymous said...

Nixon was a Republican average who led the nation at time that the community feeling was highly to the Remaining. my link

Tanveer Ali said...

AHR Expo, Xylem and FieldAware are among a few of our clients in the HVACR marketplace. click here

Tanveer Ali said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tanveer Ali said...

Choosing the right screen alternative organization and the perfect ms windows and gates for your house is a little more involved than just going into a shop and finding something that looks great. click here

Tanveer Ali said...

As discussed above, what represents submit content is a method of generating traffic. This technique is in accordance with the demonstration of content on places known as Content Directories. venus factor system

salman khan said...

What other contractor can say they were involved in the design process of an all-electric service vehicle? Not many! Robichaud is a great example of a contractor on the cutting-edge of technology. He serves as an example to others to take a risk and test new technologies. If the technology works, and in this case it seems that it does, it’s a win for everyone. One neat thing about being the first company to purchase the trucks is that Robichaud is pretty much involved in any design changes that may be made to the vehicle. BIOGOLD on Amazon

Tanveer Ali said...

Like billy-the-kid, I'd like to follow your blog - but that means I need an actual blog to follow! So how about something new somewhat more frequently please, so we can have more food-for-thought - as I'm withering on this sparse diet you've got us on so far! Quick Sale House

Tanveer Ali said...

TD Waterhouse is successfully known in the marketplaces as a distribute online dealing company based on the extended confirmed and successfully reliable dealing system of Town Catalog. Agen IBCBET

salman khan said...

He serves as an example to others to take a risk and test new technologies. If the technology works, and in this case it seems that it does, it’s a win for everyone. Quick House Sales

Tanveer Ali said...

This is mainly because HGH is between probably the most critical, metabolic testosterone during the whole human body. check this site out