Monday, August 9, 2010

Inflation Targeting When the Natural Interest Rate is Negative

Over a century ago, in a theory that is still influential today, Swedish economist Knut Wicksell argued that, at any particular time, there is a certain “natural rate of interest” that is consistent with price stability. If the actual rate of interest falls below the natural rate, there is an incentive for entrepreneurs to borrow aggressively and demand more goods and more labor, driving prices up. If the actual rate rises above the natural rate, the incentive to borrow disappears, leading entrepreneurs to demand less goods and labor, driving prices down. Since the opportunities available to entrepreneurs are always changing, the natural rate is always changing, sometimes rising dramatically and at other times falling dramatically. Thus Wicksell argued that, relative to the natural rate, “the interest on money is, in reality, very often low when it seems to be high, and high when it seems to be low.”

As applied to the world we live in today, Wicksell’s original theory has several shortcomings, all widely recognized now. First, it doesn’t account for stickiness in wages and prices: as we observe, the short-run effect of a drop in demand is not so much a fall in wages and prices as a fall in employment. Second, it doesn’t account for the role of expectations in determining the price level and thus, the possibility of “inertial” inflation: it is now generally understood that (under a fiat money regime) a steadily rising price level, rather than a necessarily constant price level, is consistent with the equilibrium “natural” interest rate that Wicksell hypothesized. Third, it doesn’t fully account for the role of inflation expectations in defining the “real” interest rate: for example, a 2% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to be constant is equivalent to a 4% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to rise at a 2% rate. Finally, as I discuss below, it doesn’t account for the role of risk aversion in determining the behavior of entrepreneurs and those who finance them.

Wicksell argued that the natural interest rate was determined by the rate of return on capital. But in practice, the rate of return on capital is never known exactly in advance. Entrepreneurs require a compensation for the risk involved, and lenders (and buyers of stock and other forms of financing) require a compensation for the risk involved in financing them. As a result, particularly in times which are uncertain and when people are particularly risk-averse, there can be a very large wedge between the natural “risk-free” rate of interest and the rate of return on capital. One consequence of having such a large wedge is that, even if the return on capital is necessarily expected to be positive, the natural interest rate can be negative.

When the natural interest rate is negative, since it’s impossible to cut nominal interest rates much below zero, the only way to get back to normal is to create an expectation of inflation. If the nominal interest rate is zero and the inflation rate is positive, then the real interest rate is negative; thus it is possible, with a sufficient amount of expected inflation, to set the real interest rate down to the negative natural rate. But how can that inflation be achieved? Wicksell argues that prices rise when the actual interest rate falls below the natural rate, but in order for that to happen, prices must already be expected to rise. Can a central bank pull itself up by its own bootstraps?

The answer is almost certainly yes, since nearly everyone agrees that a sufficiently reckless central bank will always be able to produce a high inflation rate. (Imagine the Fed buying up the entire national debt, along with all the private sector’s offerings of commercial paper, mortgages, corporate bonds, and so on. Eventually, there will be inflation.) The problem is that it is hard to estimate in advance how aggressive monetary policy needs to be in order to produce the needed expectation of inflation. Not only doesn’t the central bank know what actions would produce a given “happy medium” target between too-low and too-high inflation expectations; it never really even knows what the natural interest rate is, so it doesn’t know how much inflation would be enough to get the real rate down to the natural rate.

If the central bank estimates wrong and overshoots, it risks a period of very high, and unnecessarily high, inflation. If (as seems infinitely more likely to me) it estimates wrong and undershoots, it risks reducing its credibility, so that it becomes more difficult, subsequently, to achieve the necessary inflation rate. (Note BTW that if you take the Mankiw Rule as an estimate of the natural interest rate, then the Fed’s current 2% inflation target is not high enough: the Fed is on a course to fail and thereby reduce its subsequent credibility.)

The solution is to aim not for an inflation rate but for a price level (or, as I suggested in my previous post, a level of nominal GDP). A series of price level targets that rises over time, but that does not get revised when the central bank undershoots or overshoots, allows for policy that automatically becomes more aggressive (or less aggressive) as necessary. If the central bank undershoots the first price level target, the second target is still in place, and this means it must aim for a higher inflation rate. If it undershoots the second target, the third is still in place, and it must aim for yet a higher inflation rate. And so on. Eventually, it will (automatically) find the inflation rate that works.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

251 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   201 – 251 of 251
AGEN RESMI PRODUK S3 INDONESIA S3 CARBO MGANIK said...

CHLOROFORM DI JAKARTA
CHLOROPHYLL DI JAKARTA
LIQUID DI JAKARTA
TRIVAM DI JAKARTA
SLEELPING BEAUTY DI JAKARTA
CHLOROFORM DI MALUKU
CHLOROPHYLL DI MALUKU
LIQUID SEX DI MALUKU
TRIVAM DI MALUKU
SLEEPING BEAUTY DI MALUKU

SEO-SURAT said...

Very well written post. It will be useful to anybody who uses it, as well as myself. Keep doing what you are doing – looking forward to more posts.
Web Design Surat
Surat IT Company
SEO Company in Surat
Software Development Company in Surat
Seo services company in surat

Smart Bazar said...

Your work is superb. The best <online shopping in Pakistan is now available on Smart Bazar.

Shree said...

thank you very much gan , the article is very interesting that we can refer to. Shree

designer saree

android training surat said...

Really Nice Post. Thank you Admin for this Great Article.

seoclassesonline said...

Thanks for posting and discussion of the topic, employment, interest, and money, it’s a beautiful blog, and provide an important topic so I really enjoyed this topic. Welcome to our company and provide the best services in SEO.
Seo company in Delhi
Best Seo company in Delhi
Seo company in Patna

getkeralatourpackages said...

tour packages in Kerala Thank you so much for so sharing the blog of the employment, interest, and money, and provides great thought well said Kerala is one of the most beautiful places for honeymooners.Kerala tour packages It will help customers to plan their holiday in Kerala.honeymoon packages in Kerala Keep Posting.holiday packages in Kerala
keralapackages

SGintellect.com said...

Our Mission is offer affordable digital marketing agency in phoenix
seo company in arizona offer competitive pricing to all our customers and we do our best to retain our clientele.
Phoenix Digital Marketing Company is an award-winning marketing agency in Phoenix offering marketing strategy, lead gen, creative, web design, SEO, email.....

SGintellect.com said...

search engine optimization company focuses on providing clients with measurable results, no matter their industry.
There are best digital marketing agencies phoenix robust contenders across the country United Nations agency will facilitate your improve visibility, fine-tune SEO, and rector nice content.
Our search engine optimization phoenix provide a detailed report of your website SEO performance evaluation, as well as data about your traffic.
local seo phoenix provide effective Local SEO strategies to service providers across the globe.

divyangbhuva said...

This arrange is synchronous s informative impolites festivity to pity.Thanks for a very interesting blog.
good job....

Anonymous said...

Great info. I love all the posts. I really enjoyed. I would like more information about this, because it is very nice. Thanks for sharing.

places to visit in nepal

places to visit in mysore

Simba__Institute said...

hello,
If user user will increases then advertisers will automatically increase so as written in article focus on your website architecture
digital marketing

Flats in Kochi said...

Your article is nice.Informative and helpful.

Unknown said...

Blog.......
Electronic Goods Showrooms in Delhi
AC Dealers in Delhi
LED TV Dealers

Flats in Thrissur said...

Informative article, keep sharing.

seoclassesonline said...

Thanks for posting and sharing of the topic Employment, interest, and money, and provide an important information.Seo company in Patna

zhului said...

On the facts, the Plaintiff’s affidavits do not disclose a strong enough case to justify an order for the Defendant to https://www.fiverr.com/shahzadaalvi/do-for-your-complete-seo breach their undertaking to their customers and the regulators.

Gamebug said...

I've been alone with you inside my mind
And in my dreams I've kissed your lips a thousand times
I sometimes see you pass outside my door
Hello, is it me you're looking for?

Gamebug said...

Good! I have found interesting things here

Gamebug
run-3
Cool math-chess
sudoku
primary-math

Bilal ch said...

Nice one, awesome article one of mine favorite.
786shop (Online Clothing Brand)
https://www.786shop.com/blog/detail/wear-fancy-party-dresses-this-summer

Gabriella Jackson said...

Oh my goodness! an amazing article dude. Thank you However I am experiencing issue with ur rss. Don’t know why Unable to subscribe to it. Is there anyone getting identical rss problem? Anyone who knows kindly respond. Thnkx

Click Here
Visit Web
Nalab.stanford.edu

Manila said...

Very nice post, i certainly love this website, keep on it

Visit Web
Photigymarket.com
Information

Eileen Price said...

Would you be interested in exchanging links?

Seoinpractice.com
Information
Click Here

Anonymous said...

A Delhi call girl who will make you excited in your trousers
9810731982
Hello dudes, I am Lovely Rani, a 21-year-old independent Delhi Escorts, who is one of the most fascinating gals. You’ll surely be delighted in my companionship and feel excited in your trousers. I am a warranty to turn you on and leave you fulfilled. You may have a plenty of experiences when it comes to date but with me, the experience is entirely different. I am comfortable in any settings and you’ll surely have a great time in my companionship. What’s more, I have the fantastic local knowledge. If you’re coming to Delhi it could be the boring experience if there is no one to accompany you. But when you hire me, I’ll accompany you and make your stay a fantastic one. You can walk into the most famous pubs, dance clubs or even bars. You can also enjoy the authentic cuisine of the national capital in my companionship. I have spent so much of time out and about in Delhi that I am completely aware of the interesting places in the city. I very well know, where the hottest places of the town are. So, if you’re looking for the most fascinating Independent Delhi Escorts, there is no other alternative.

Lokhandwala Escorts | Vile Parle Escorts | Juhu Escorts | Andheri Escorts | Marine Escorts | Bandra Escorts | Thane Escorts | Churchgate Escorts | Elphinstone Escorts | Amritsar Escorts | Ludhiana Escorts | Jalandhar Escorts | Dharamshala Escorts | Mohali Escorts | Panchkula Escorts | Bathinda Escorts | Srinagar Escorts | kalka Escorts | Patiala Escorts | Zirakpur Escorts | Banjara Hills Escorts | Jubilee Hills Escorts | Secunderabad Escorts | Uppal Escorts | Kukatpally Escorts | Gachibowli Escorts |Manikonda Escorts | Miyapur Escorts | Red-Hills Escorts | Park-Street Escorts | Park-Circus Escorts | Sonarpur Escorts | Dumdum Escorts | Howrah Escorts | Sealdah Escorts | Newtown Escorts | Gariahat Escorts | Jadavpur Escorts | Greater-Noida Escorts | Noida Escorts | Faridabad Escorts | Ghaziabad Escorts | Connaught-Place Escorts | Gurgaon Escorts | Anand-Vihar Escorts | Mahipalpur Escorts | Noida-City-Center Escorts | Cyber-City Escorts | Kashmiri Escorts | New-Delhi Escorts | Kalka -Je Escorts| Vaishali Escorts | Chandni-Chowk Escorts | New-Friends-Colony Escorts | Dwarka Escorts | Vasant-Vihar Escorts | Laxmi-Nagar Escorts | Kirti-Nagar Escorts | Nehru-Place Escorts | Shahdara Escorts | Dilshad-Garden Escorts | Mayur-Vihar Escorts | Vaishali Escorts | Model-Town Escorts | Patel-Nagar Escorts | Rajouri-Garden Escorts | Paschim-Vihar Escorts | Meera-Bagh Escorts | Shalimar-Bagh Escorts | Indirapuram Escorts | Pahar-Ganj Escorts | Safdarjung Escorts | Green-Park Escorts | Chattarpur Escorts | R-K-Puram Escorts | Aerocity Escorts | Pitampura Escorts | Rohini Escorts | Uttam-Nagar Escorts | Chennai Escorts | Partners Link | Manali Escorts | Bhopal Escorts | Indore Escorts | House-Wife Escorts | Russian Escorts | College Call Girls | Model Escorts | Celebrity Escorts | Dehradun Escorts | Patna Escorts | Pune Escorts | Ahmedabad Escorts | Jaipur Escorts | Lucknow Escorts | Chandigarh Escorts | Kolkata Escorts

BillieMartinez said...

Very nice post, i certainly love this website, keep on it

Tiede.fi
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

AlbertLee said...

It’s hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you know what you’re talking about! Thanks

Advancedbusiness.co
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

MarkNelson said...

Your place is valueble for me. Thanks!…

Dailyjobglobal.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

Jackie Austin said...

Would you be interested in exchanging links?

Instabio.cc
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

Kiro Wadazo said...

You made some decent points there. I looked on the internet for the issue and found most individuals will go along with with your website.

Visit Web
Yeezylegitcheck.com
Information

JeanAdams said...

Aw, this was a really nice post. In idea I would like to put in writing like this additionally – taking time and actual effort to make a very good article… but what can I say… I procrastinate alot and by no means seem to get something done.

Stylist-profi.ru
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

Grand Master said...

One of the leading names in the industry, Thaliyan Group has been instrumental in making available first-class lot of Grand Master Cattle Feed . With our experience of more than a decade, we are operating as a manufacturer and supplier in the domestic market.

VanesaBell said...

There are certainly a lot of details like that to take into consideration. That is a great point to bring up. I offer the thoughts above as general inspiration but clearly there are questions like the one you bring up where the most important thing will be working in honest good faith.

Click Here
Visit Web
Videodataanalysis.com

MariyamSimones said...

This is the right blog for anyone who wants to find out about this topic. You realize so much its almost hard to argue with you (not that I actually would want…HaHa). You definitely put a new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Great stuff, just great!

Net.au
Information
Click Here

Dora Shaw said...

Spot on with this write-up, I truly think this website needs much more consideration. I’ll probably be again to read much more, thanks for that info.

Amara.org
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

Laurens99 said...

I like your post and everything you share
https://americanpokerx.com
keep sharing such kind of articles here.

web6 said...

Really great post.
Thanks for sharing with us.
Website development company in surat

Filehippo said...

This is the right blog for anyone who wants to find out about this topic.
filehippo

pradeep perelly said...

Very informative post for me. thanks

KayleeCraig said...

The next time I read a blog, I hope that it doesnt disappoint me as much as this one. I mean, I know it was my choice to read, but I actually thought you have something interesting to say. All I hear is a bunch of whining about something that you could fix if you werent too busy looking for attention.

Walleyecentral.com
Information
Click Here
Visit Web

Mobile Mods Apk said...

Employment is major weapon for the development of a country

Fashion Stop said...

Great post, very helpful.
Will definitely try it.
Also for great Party Wear, Casual wear must visit Fashiongarh Retail .

vision infotech said...

this is great post.

SEO Frisbee said...

Inflation targeting is a monetary policy that sets an explicit inflation target for the central bank to achieve. When the natural interest rate is negative, which means that real interest rates are negative, inflation targeting can help the central bank to manage the economy by ensuring that inflation remains within its target range. SEO Frisbee .I was extremely pleased with the SEO Service provided by SEO Frisbee Company. They were knowledgeable and accommodating, and they were able to deliver excellent results.

lukaszfashion said...

Inflation targeting has become a common strategy for central banks to achieve and maintain price stability and to support economic growth. However, it can be a challenge when the natural interest rate is negative.

meravakeel said...

Employment: Job security is the foundation of a strong economy, and employers should prioritize investing in their employees to ensure job satisfaction and a safe working environment.

Reeta Fashion said...

Reeta Fashion offers a wide range of beautifully printed sarees for purchase online. With a focus on quality and style, customers can browse through a diverse collection of traditional and modern designs to find the perfect saree for any occasion. Whether it's for a wedding, festival, or everyday wear, Reeta Fashion has something for everyone. The user-friendly website allows for easy navigation and secure online transactions, ensuring a seamless shopping experience. With competitive pricing and fast shipping, Reeta Fashion is a go-to destination for those looking to buy printed sarees online.




Sherry said...

Fresh News Info is a great source of information that provides readers with up-to-date news and insights from various industries.
Google’s Dark Web Email Address Warning | New Security Feature
5 Easy Ways to Secure Your Smartphone from Hackers

Vivel said...

Discover the latest trends and shop for fashion-forward clothing, accessories, and more at Reeta Fashion. Download this app for a seamless online shopping journey and unlock exclusive deals. Browse a wide range of stylish collections, from casual wear to formal attire. Stay ahead of the fashion curve and enjoy the convenience of shopping from the comfort of your home. Shop with confidence and let Reeta Fashion redefine your wardrobe today!

sarthaksamwad said...

I like this blog post, it's really like this inflation targeting when natural youre articles. thank you for posting this blog.
BPSC IAS coaching in patna

car remapping in west midlands said...

amazing website really like it thanks for shring .

shreebalajinetralaya said...

I like this blog post, it's really like this inflation targeting when natural youre articles. thank you for posting this blog.
eye hospital in patna

«Oldest ‹Older   201 – 251 of 251   Newer› Newest»