Wednesday, August 4, 2010

Nominal GDP Targeting: the 24-7 Solution

Though I’m skeptical of some of his specific proposals, Scott Sumner has convinced me that nominal GDP targeting is the way to go. I’d like to propose the following law:

The Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System shall conduct monetary policy in such a way as to increase the nominal gross domestic product to approximately $24 trillion in the year 2017.

I choose 2017 because it’s 10 years after the end of the last growth cycle, and I choose $24 trillion based on an approximate extrapolation of the growth rate from 1997 to 2007. (You get why I like the numbers 7 and 24, right?) This is essentially a retroactive 10-year plan for monetary policy, but it leaves all the details up to the Fed.

I’m proposing this as a law to be passed by Congress, because it’s a little bit easier for me to imagine Congress passing such a law than the Fed making such a radical change on its own. Moreover, it would have more credibility if it were written into law rather than merely an announced policy of the Fed. It does take away a little bit of the Fed’s independence, but, as Dr. Phil might say, “How’s that independent central bank thing workin’ out for ya?” It fully retains the Fed’s operational independence, and it mandates an objective based on what the Fed was already achieving over the 10 years up to 2007 (and very roughly for the prior 10 years as well).

The law would need some sort of enforcement provisions, too, but these need not constrain any specific Fed actions. The Chairman would simply have to explain to Congress, on a regular basis, how the Fed plans to get from here to there. If the plan misses in the early years, it obviously has to become more aggressive in the later years – which is the whole point: the worse things get, the more dangerous it should become for banks, businesses, and individuals to keep sitting on cash instead of investing it. (If you want to give the Fed governors a bonus based on how close they come to the target, I’m down with that, too.)

After 2017, the Fed would be free to go back to its discretion in setting long-range policy goals. But it will have an incentive to continue nominal GDP targeting. It may even ask Congress to pass another law. What incentive? To make up for the abysmal performance of 2008-2010, the 2017 goal will almost certainly require the Fed to allow an inflation rate greater than 2% – possibly much greater than 2% – as 2017 approaches. The Fed will then need a credible way to bring the inflation rate back down. What could be more credible than a promise to continue the nominal GDP pattern of the past 20 years? (Remember, the $24 trillion goal for 2017 was based on an extrapolation of the 1997-2007 trend..)

I would hope that the Fed would then elect to continue with nominal GDP targeting. In the longer run, it’s a policy that solves the problem I discussed when I wrote about inflation targets and financial crises. A financial crisis will (if history is any guide) reduce expectations of real growth. If the Fed is targeting nominal GDP, then inflation expectations should automatically increase when real growth expectations decline. This automatically gives the Fed more room to cut the real interest rate so as to clean up the economic fallout from the financial crisis. And nominal GDP targets should also help prevent such crises by reining in real growth that is driven by speculation rather than actual improvements in productivity. In such cases, inflation may not accelerate, but nominal GDP will, and this will automatically lead to an expectation of Fed tightening. Aside from the arbitrary connection with the numbers 24 and 7, nominal GDP targeting is a 24-7 solution in the sense that it reliably provides help in a variety of circumstances.

I’m hoping my law will receive bipartisan – or even tetrapartisan – support. Progressives can see it as a way to make up for the inadequacy of fiscal policy initiatives. Mainstream Democrats can see it as way to consolidate the gains of fiscal policy. Republicans can see it as an acknowledgment that Democratic fiscal policy initiatives were the wrong solution in the first place. And Tea Partiers can see it as a way to get the Fed out of the business of micromanaging the economy. I don’t really care how you sell it; it’s just a good idea. And since all but about 535 of the members of Congress read my blog...

Yes, I’m hoping that Congress will pick up ideas like this from people like Scott Sumner and me, but I’m not expecting it. I’m still long the bond market in my personal accounts. For the sake of the country, though, I’m begging Congress and the Fed. Take my capital gains. Please.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

180 comments:

Tschäff said...

You give monetary policy too much power. Japan has provided ample evidence that monetary policy is a weak tool at best for generating strong GDP growth. The US is also adding to that body of evidence.

The Fed's current mandates for price stability and full employment are the right prescription for economic growth but with the Fed funds rate at zero, it is nearly out of options, and can be for the indefinite future. The reason QE and low interest rates don't work as advertised are explained here: http://www.newdeal20.org/2010/08/04/the-real-reason-banks-arent-lending-16510/

Even with near zero interest rates, deflation and persistent mass unemployment can exist. The solution is to provide people with enough financial income to meet their savings desires and consume enough to bring the economy to full employment. This can only be achieved with a trade surplus or government deficit. This isn't a theory, but an accounting identity. So if you were to make a law mandating GDP growth, make the tool to use fiscal policy. Let them adjust taxes and/or spending to regulate aggregate demand. It will bring an abrupt end to unemployment unlike monetary policy.

Since we're in a radical mood, I would add there are more goals for an economy than GDP growth. Maybe we should consider other wants like job security, national security, environmental sustainability and others over GDP growth as priority #1.

Tschäff
www.moslereconomics.com
Counter Insurgency, Deficit Terrorist Unit

Andy Harless said...

The Fed has plenty of options, if it's willing to use them. Long-term Treasury bonds are yielding about 4%. The Fed could buy them all, thereby effectively reducing the yield to 0% by replacing them with cash. Don't you think it would have a significant effect on nominal GDP if the Fed bought up the entire national debt? And the Fed is not limited to public debt. It can buy mortgage securities. It can buy commercial paper. It can buy all kinds of high-grade bonds. It can buy foreign currency. It can buy gold. It's just implausible that the Fed could exhaust its options without at least hitting the target.

Theoretically, the Fed might not be able to hit the target without far exceeding it, because the natural interest rate might be lower than the negative of the inflation rate required to hit the target. I find that case implausible, too, though, because it implies a ridiculously low natural interest rate.

Tschäff said...

Good that you recognize that the Fed could buy longer term debt, it's something Greenspan recently expressed skepticism about here: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/38487969/ns/meet_the_press-transcripts

Why does the treasury even need to issue debt and other than to satisfy a law that prevents them from running an overdraft at the fed? Why does the treasury issue long term bonds? A very wonkish paper (http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=10404) says it is to satisfy private demand for a safe interest bearing assets. By the fed selling longer term tsy secs they keep the investment rate higher than it would be otherwise. If that rate came down would there be that stimulatory effect?

Should the Fed buy the entire national debt, it would be exchanging interest bearing tsy secs with lower interest bearing reserves. That would reduce inflationary pressure in the economy as that interest represents income for market participants.

Mike Norman has suggested that the Fed buy the stock market, your second point (high grade bonds, gold, commercial paper) makes me think of that. You're right in thinking it will stimulate the economy, because it would be an appreciation of value for those asset holders who presumably will presumably then increase their demand from the economy. But why is that preferable to a payroll tax holiday, or a job guarantee/employer of last resort program that would stimulate the economy from the bottom up?

Andy Harless said...

If the Fed bought up the national debt, it would be a huge capital gain for the current owners of the debt, which would far outweigh the income loss to subsequent would-be owners (unless the process created sufficiently large expectations of inflation, in which case current owners would have losses, but in that case the incentive to buy productive assets, and the stimulus induced thereby, would be even stronger).

Personally, I support fiscal policy initiatives too. If I were the King of America, I would do some of both. But fiscal policy has become very unpopular lately.

Tschäff said...

Please read this is highly illuminating: http://neweconomicperspectives.blogspot.com/2009/11/what-if-government-just-prints-money.html

It clearly debunks the notion that treasuries are less stimulatory than bank account balances. Thanks!

David Beckworth said...

Andy:

Good luck with the NGDP Target proposal! I really hope this idea gets more traction.

Now some questions. First,what is your long-run preferred growth rate of nominal GDP? Second, a NGDP target allows for productivity-driven disinflation or even deflation. Are you cool with that? (I am, but was curious to hear your thoughts).

Just to be clear as to what I mean on the second question, consider a permanent productivity shock that increases the productivity growth rate. In order to maintain a NGDP target in such a situation, the inflation rate has to drop as the real output growth increases.

Andy Harless said...

Presumably higher productivity growth would result in rising real wages, so sticky nominal wages wouldn't be a problem, so I would be OK with a lower inflation rate. Of course that conclusion depends on the target NGDP growth rate being high enough in the first place. If I had my choice, I'd probably want a target around 7%, combined with changes in tax laws so that businesses can deduct inflation from their taxable profits. Given the hostility toward inflation in the real world, I would settle for 5%, which I think is suboptimal but high enough to avoid any major problems. The proposal here implies about 5.5%, starting from 2007, just because the growth rate from 1997 to 2007 happens to be about 5.4%, and I rounded up the final target to $24 trillion.

Tschäff said...

The natural rate of interest is zero.
http://bilbo.economicoutlook.net/blog/?p=4656
I hope this helps.

Scott Sumner said...

Andy, Thanks for suggesting the NGDP target. Your discussion of using monetary incentives reminded me of some work I did way back in 1989 proposing the use of NGDP futures markets to set policy. A more recent paper (using the CPI instead) was published in Contributions to Macroeconomics in 2006, and actually started out by discussing compensating each Fed official by the accuracy of their policy votes. Here is a blog post where I discuss using market incentives to make policy more accurate:

http://www.themoneyillusion.com/?p=1184

Adam P said...

I don't know Andy, I think the basic idea is sensible in principle but not sure this sort of law actually accomplishes much. I like the idea of level targeting and legal mandate is not a bad idea but...

The first thing is that the enforcement mechanism is weak. Mervyn King has to write letters whenever CPI inflation exceeds 3% YoY. He's been doing it regularly, each time saying inflation will soon come down. He's correct not to tighten but this shows how these sort of targets, without strict enforcement, can be get kind of pushed aside.

Furthermore, if you asked the Fed right now if they thought they were doing enough to meet such a long term target they would probably say they are, yet we still have 9.5% unemployment. Your target really needs to be for shorter horizons. Having a target horizon that is the length of a full cycle needn't stabilize anything, you could hit it with a huge boom followed by a huge bust.

Andy Harless said...

Adam, you have to appreciate the difference between a growth target and a level target. With a growth target, Mervyn King goes to confession and gets absolution, and leaves intending to lead a new life, but he is tempted into sin again. (I'll admit I'm also on the side of the devil in that particular case.) With a level target, there is no absolution. Every time you undershoot, you fall deeper into sin, and eventually we decide that you were predestined to damnation and need to be replaced with a new central banker. (Mind you, I'm not advocating -- nor even claiming to understand -- Calvinist theology as a religious matter, but when it comes to central banking, I think it's preferable.)

I doubt the Fed thinks it's doing enough to meet my target. We've had almost 3 years of below-target core inflation and below-target real growth, for which the Fed would have to compensate. Surely (taking an average of the governors) the Fed believes that there is a significant permanent component to fluctuations in real growth, and nothing the Fed has said suggests that they plan to engineer more inflation to make up for the past 2 years' undershoots. (Indeed, looking at their forecasts, quite the opposite seems to be the case: they plan a few more years of below-target inflation, for which there is no indication that they plan to compensate later.)

I specifically avoided targets for shorter horizons, because I think they are impossible to hit. The Fed needs to get some traction before it can start hitting targets. The way it gets the traction, in my plan, is to say, "Dudes, we may not be able to damage your cash portfolio right now, but once we get the chance, you just watch the hell out! You'd better start moving out of cash pretty soon, or it's going to be too late." Once it gets the traction, which takes a couple of years, it can make good on the threat. And the longer it takes, the stronger the threat becomes.

Henry Bee said...

Andy, good to see you blogging more frequently. Just a quick thought.

How is targeting the NGDP different from targeting the NRU? If we overestimate the NGDP levels that the economy can truly produce, the central bank could lose control of the money supply.

Henry Bee said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Andy Harless said...

NGDP is a nominal quantity; unemployment is a real quantity. If the Fed tries to keep the unemployment rate permanently below the true natural rate, you get hyperinflation. If it tries to keep NGDP growing at a rate much faster than real GDP can grow, all you get is a high but constant rate of inflation. I think it actually makes sense to allow for extra inflation to make up for shortfalls in growth of productivity and population. You can think of NGDP as being a "velocity-adjusted money stock" measure, in which case controlling NGDP is basically an extension of the old idea of controlling the money supply.

Henry Bee said...

Andy, thanks, that makes sense. So it's pretty much just a variation of the McCallum Rule.

Adam P said...

Andy,

I appreciate well the difference between a level target and rate target.

My allusion to King was not about what the target is or isn't, it's that if it is never hit and there is no real penalty then the "law" would have no bite.

The fact that you're level targeting won't help if people conclude the levels will never be made.

Anonymous said...

Would the Chinese allow it?

Tschäff said...

what could the Chinese do to stop it?

Richard H. Serlin said...

Very late to this, but if you targeted nominal GDP for 7 years in the future, and then productivity gains were a lot lower than expected, wouldn't you end up with inflation much too high? with all the attendant problems? Or the converse with deflation.

So isn't it more precise and less risky to just target inflation?

jerry lopiz said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
jerry lopiz said...

Then again its on the purpose of be, whether or not or not or not or not or not or not or not you happen to structure your psyche versed, likelihood is that simply will stop by our work the dominant a district of contiguous somebody and you may fabricate your current register money. Month-to-month some individual could just cash advance loans in fresno like the system entirely wants that's observe having been ready.

India Flower said...

This is also a very good post which I really enjoyed reading. It is not everyday that I have the possibility to see something like this.

Send Flowers To Panchkula

raju kr said...

Emtv helps us to provide updated Papua new guinea( PNG ) news, PNG Videos, PNG Article, PNG business, PNG technology, PNG weather, PNG Real Estate, PNG Fashion News, PNG Hollywood movies and other PNG News as well.

PNG Sports News

shubham sapkal said...


Happy Friendship Day 2015 messages
Raksha Bandhan 2015 wishes messages
happy raksha bandhan 2015 date calendar
friendship day essay information history for students kids

Supergirl Tv Show 2015
Season 1 episode 1 of super girl

Anonymous said...

Search Engine Optimization is the phrase used to describe optimizing your website for keyword and search engine recognition. The processes and areas involved with SEO eventually enable you to rank higher for the keywords you are targeting in popular search engines such as Google, Bing and Yahoo.SEO packages prices

Amit Kumar said...

Happy Friendship Day 2015
Happy Friendship Day Greetings Cards
Friendship Day 2015 Messages
Happy Friendship Day Images
Friendship Day 2015 Images
Friendship Day Greeting Cards
Happy Friendship Day Quotes
Friendship Day 2015 Quotes
Happy Friendship Day SMS in Hindi
Friendship Day SMS 2015
Friendship Day Wallpapers
Friendship Day SMS For Girlfriend

seo said...

E-Juice is a California based e-juice company. We create mouth watering e-juices that maximize the vaping experience. We take pride in our e-juice and use only the finest of ingredients. All our ingredients are USA made. Try one of our delicious flavors and make Ruthless E-Juice your all day vape.london lifestyle

seo said...

grass and various disasters (Romance, erotic, skin-deep, thriller, thriller and yellow, gray, books): Close to the heart Romance Erotic humor ... http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B00Q7VZOPM?*Version*=1&*entries*=0

seo said...

grass and various disasters (Romance, erotic, skin-deep, thriller, thriller and yellow, gray, books): Close to the heart Romance Erotic humor ... http://www.amazon.it/gp/product/B00Q7VZOPM?*Version*=1&*entries*=0

seo said...

Secrets Of The Irresistible Lover: Nadine Piat Reveals A Weirdly Effective, Science-Backed "Sensual Lover Technique" For Making A Man Physically And Emotionally Intoxicated By You...https://www.rebelmouse.com/secretsoftheirresistiblelover/

seo said...

Secrets Of The Irresistible Lover: Nadine Piat Reveals A Weirdly Effective, Science-Backed "Sensual Lover Technique" For Making A Man Physically And Emotionally Intoxicated By You...https://www.rebelmouse.com/secretsoftheirresistiblelover/

seo said...

love and desire for you literally at the push of a button. Even if your ex boyfriend won't answer your calls, emails or texts now, you'll be amazed at how quickly his attitude towards you changes once you learn these simple secrets.www.textyourexbackforum.com

seo said...

Are you looking for a SEO expert for your website link development..?Blog Commenting

seo said...

Cheapest And Reliable Link Building Great experience of backlinks, Increase your site rank within few daysBoost Your Website

seo said...

top desee videos hot pix is here and you can enjoy watching all the best desee video pages here.desee One

seo said...

love and desire for you literally at the push of a button. Even if your ex boyfriend won't answer your calls, emails or texts now, you'll be amazed at how quickly his attitude towards you changes once you learn these simple secrets.how to make your ex love you again fast

seo said...

top desee videos hot pix is here and you can enjoy watching all the best desee video pages here.desee One

seo said...

Cheapest And Reliable Link Building Great experience of backlinks, Increase your site rank within few daysBoost Your Website

seo said...

Are you looking for a SEO expert for your website link development..?Blog Commenting

seo said...

love and desire for you literally at the push of a button. Even if your ex boyfriend won't answer your calls, emails or texts now, you'll be amazed at how quickly his attitude towards you changes once you learn these simple secrets.i want my ex boyfriend to come back to me

dip said...

Here you can Watch UEFA Champions League 2016 Live Streaming
Champions League live stream

rafique habib said...

Many people here simply buy Youtube views for cheap price whenever they have a new awesome video but no visitor is watchingwww.youtubeviewsbuy.com/

rafique habib said...

If you find yourself going through a breakup and aren't ready to call it quits, then Text Your Ex Back can help you.https://rebelmouse.com/textyourexback2review/

rafique habib said...

Whether it is your lover’s birthday, Valentine’s Day, the holidays, or you just want to surprise your partner with a romantic gesture, …http://www.antoniapearceromance.com/

seo said...

What’s even more fascinating is that this shape is based on your height, is obtainable by almost all women and is based on solid anthropometric, health, and psychology research.rebelmouse.com/venusfactorsystemreview

seo said...

What’s even more fascinating is that this shape is based on your height, is obtainable by almost all women and is based on solid anthropometric, health, and psychology research.find other sites like this

rafique habib said...

No matter who initiates it, breaking up is extremely tough. The period shortly after is often filled with hurt, confusion and a feeling of emptiness.http://copyfight.org/

rafique habib said...

No matter who initiates it, breaking up is extremely tough. The period shortly after is often filled with hurt, confusion and a feeling of emptiness.girlfriend system v2 method

amine lahragui said...

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. happy new year 2016 new year 2016
bonne année 2016 imagenes de año nuevo 2016 imagenes de navidad 2016 feliz año nuevo 2016 Journée internationale des droits des femmes 2016

rafique habib said...

Yoga has gone from a quietly researched practice perfected by saints in the Indian subcontinent, to a wildly successful international movement that has bound together diverse groups of people all looking to attain inner peace and enhanced bodily fortitude. Yoga for Health

rafique habib said...

Yoga has gone from a quietly researched practice perfected by saints in the Indian subcontinent, to a wildly successful international movement that has bound together diverse groups of people all looking to attain inner peace and enhanced bodily fortitude. lots of fun

rafique habib said...

Yoga has gone from a quietly researched practice perfected by saints in the Indian subcontinent, to a wildly successful international movement that has bound together diverse groups of people all looking to attain inner peace and enhanced bodily fortitude. storeboard

rafique habib said...

Yoga has gone from a quietly researched practice perfected by saints in the Indian subcontinent, to a wildly successful international movement that has bound together diverse groups of people all looking to attain inner peace and enhanced bodily fortitude. lots of fun

rafique habib said...

You guys demanded this one like crazy. With the critical success of Christopher Nolan's Batman, it's easy to forget what killed the franchise in the first place, Trevor McManus

rafique habib said...

great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks. www.mp3loudspeakdr.com

rafique habib said...

great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks.
www.mp3loudspeakdr.com

rafique habib said...

great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks.
www.mp3loudspeakdr.com

rafique habib said...

great blog .I will be interested in more similar topics. i see you got really very useful topics , i will be always checking your blog thanks.
www.mp3loudspeakdr.com

rafique habib said...

Plus, learn incredible eye exercises to improve vision, the "Dr. Bates 2.0" shortcut developed by Duke Peterson, Rebel Mouse com

rafique habib said...

Plus, learn incredible eye exercises to improve vision, the "Dr. Bates 2.0" shortcut developed by Duke Peterson, rebelmouse

rafique habib said...

Plus, learn incredible eye exercises to improve vision, the "Dr. Bates 2.0" shortcut developed by Duke Peterson, pop over to this website

rafique habib said...

I want you to thank for your time of this wonderful read!!! I definately enjoy every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff of your blog a must read blog!!!! Trevor McManus

grissha hamearth said...

To create a such reasonably article is actually superb,I daily scan your blogs and provides my announcement for that here this text is simply too nice and then amusive.
Agen Sbobet Online
Agen Sbobet Casino

seo said...

Exciting to read this article as I am a volunteer at the Southampton Animal Shelter where the playgroups are currently used and were pionneered! Great tool to help improve the lives of dogs as they wait for forever homes in shelters/rescue groups! SG Dating Web

seo said...

Exciting to read this article as I am a volunteer at the Southampton Animal Shelter where the playgroups are currently used and were pionneered! Great tool to help improve the lives of dogs as they wait for forever homes in shelters/rescue groups! www.sgdatingweb.com/gfas-review-how-the-girlfriend-activation-system-attracts-women

seo said...

Exciting to read this article as I am a volunteer at the Southampton Animal Shelter where the playgroups are currently used and were pionneered! Great tool to help improve the lives of dogs as they wait for forever homes in shelters/rescue groups! the social man - the girlfriend activation system.rar

seo said...

I am happy to find this post very useful for me, as it contains lot of
information. I always prefer to read the quality content and this thing I
found in you post. Thanks for sharing.www.ebookreviews.ning.com/pdf/

seo said...

اس کے بہت پر مشتمل ہے کے طور پر میں، میرے لئے بہت مفید اس پوسٹ کو تلاش کرنے کے لئے خوش ہوں معلومات.
win your ex back with texts

rafique habib said...

With all the various kinds of senior living available today it’s hard to comprehend the differences between them but even more difficult to select the perfect one for a parent. assisted living

rafique habib said...

With all the various kinds of senior living available today it’s hard to comprehend the differences between them but even more difficult to select the perfect one for a parent. senior living

rafique habib said...

Get Professional Blogger Templates For your blog. Download High Quality Blogger Templates available in blogger template

rafique habib said...

Get Professional Blogger Templates For your blog. Download High Quality Blogger Templates available in blogger template

rafique habib said...

“friend zone” is because they lack a basic understanding of the laws that govern female attraction www.teaterdating.com/techniques-to-help-turn-that-girl-friend-into-a-girlfriend

rafique habib said...

“friend zone” is because they lack a basic understanding of the laws that govern female attraction http://teaterdating.com/techniques-to-help-turn-that-girl-friend-into-a-girlfriend

rafique habib said...

“friend zone” is because they lack a basic understanding of the laws that govern female attraction girlfriend activation system is it real

rafique habib said...

this is a 60 Second Panic Solution review and fan site.  If you are looking for the official website so you can purchase the system directly from Anna Gibson-Steel for the lowest price, RebelMouse

rafique habib said...

this is a 60 Second Panic Solution review and fan site.  If you are looking for the official website so you can purchase the system directly from Anna Gibson-Steel for the lowest price, https://www.rebelmouse.com/60secondpanicsolutionreviews/

rafique habib said...

this is a 60 Second Panic Solution review and fan site.  If you are looking for the official website so you can purchase the system directly from Anna Gibson-Steel for the lowest price, anna gibson-steel 60 second panic solution reviews

rafique habib said...

Let's talk about what the Girlfriend Activation System is and what it is not. After purchasing GFAS for myself,
http://ebookreviews.ning.com/pdf/girlfriend-activation-system-review

rafique habib said...

Let's talk about what the Girlfriend Activation System is and what it is not. After purchasing GFAS for myself,
http://ebookreviews.ning.com/pdf/girlfriend-activation-system-review

rafique habib said...

Awesome there, Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer. www.copyfight.org/girlfriend-activation-system-review-is-gfas-v2-the-most-effective-girlfriend-system-yet

rafique habib said...

Awesome there, Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
http://girlfriendactivationsystemreview.org/

rafique habib said...

Awesome there, Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
http://girlfriendactivationsystemreview.org/

rafique habib said...

Awesome there, Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
http://girlfriendactivationsystemreview.org/

rafique habib said...

Awesome there, Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
http://girlfriendactivationsystemreview.org/

rafique habib said...

Dr. Dinakar Golla  is a native Pittsburgher who is the founder of the Golla Center for Plastic Surgery & Spa.  He is a Board Certified Plastic Surgeon in Pittsburgh with extensive experience in cosmetic surgery.  He has authored numerous articles, Breast Reduction

rafique habib said...

so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing Rebel-Mouse

rafique habib said...

so many useful info here in the post, we need work out more techniques in this regard, thanks for sharing rebelmouse.com

rafique habib said...

this is a 60 Second Panic Solution review and fan site. If you are looking for the official website so you can purchase the system directly from Anna Gibson-Steel for the lowest priceold school new body eating plan

Obat Diabetes said...

I have learn all the posts and i found very unique info on this blog
Obat Wasir
Obat Kanker paru Paru
Obat Wasir Alami
Ace Maxs
Obat Ace Maxs
Obat Diabetes
Obat Asam Urat
Obat Darah Tinggi
Obat Kanker Tulang

rafique habib said...

Nice post! This is a very nice and innovative blog. I will definitively come back to more times.! Thanks for informative post. haveyouseenhim.com

Zam Zam said...

enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.
http://dating-journal.com/dating-and-attraction/a-review-of-my-dating-experiences-using-the-girlfriend-activation-system/

Zam Zam said...

enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.
http://dating-journal.com/dating-and-attraction/a-review-of-my-dating-experiences-using-the-girlfriend-activation-system/

Zam Zam said...

enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work.
http://dating-journal.com/dating-and-attraction/a-review-of-my-dating-experiences-using-the-girlfriend-activation-system/

Sagar Balyan said...

valentine day sms wallpaper
valentine day single line status
valentine day shayari one line
valentine day latest shayari
valentine day love shayari in hindi
valentine day shayari for boyfriend
valentine day shayari for girlfriend
valentine day love sms messages
valentine day shayari facebook
valentine's day shayari for wife
valentine kiss day shayari
valentine's day sher o shayari
valentine day sher o shayari hindi
valentine romantic status for whatsapp
whatsapp status valentine day special
valentine special whatsapp videos
valentine day special whatsapp short video
valentines day funny whatsapp status
valentines day romantic whatsapp status
valentines day one line whatsapp status
hug day love quotes
hug day long quotes
hug day latest quotes
hug day sad quotes
hug day love sms messages
hug day short quotes
hug day sad quotes 2 lines
hug day sad quotes one line status
hug day quotes messages for girlfriend
hug day quotes for gf
hug day quotes for best friend
hug day emotional quotes
hug day romantic quotes
romantic hug quotes for her
romantic hug day sms in hindi
hug day 2016 sms wallpaper
rose day 2016 shayari sms
rose day shayari sms in hindi
7th feb rose day sms
rose day love sms messages
rose day 2016 romantic sms
happy rose day romantic shayari
valentine day special whatsapp short video
rose day whatsapp short video

Sagar Balyan said...

rose day whatsapp dp
rose day whatsapp dp images
rose day romantic sms for girlfriend
happy rose day sms wallpaper
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in English
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Shayari in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Status in Urdu
happy new year 2016 animated videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp short videos
happy new year 2016 fb animated images
happy new year 2016 fb GIF images
happy new year shayari
happy new year 2016 shayari sms
happy new year shayari images
happy new year 2016 sms images
happy new year 2016 sms wallpaper
valentines day 2016 romantic quotes
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for her
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for girlfriend
happy valentines day 2016 romantic SMS
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Wishes for Boyfriend
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Sayings for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic messages for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic images
romantic Valentines Day 2016 E Cards
valentines day romantic 2016 FB Covers
happy valentines day 2016 Romantic FB Status
valentines day 2016 romantic sayings for Boyfriend
valentines day love sms messages
royal rumble 2016 live stream
watch royal rumble live streaming online
royal rumble 2016 results highlights
who won royal rumble 2016 winner
watch royal rumble 2016 HD video free ppv
royal rumble 2016 live online

rafique habib said...

This is a very good post which I really enjoy reading. It is not every day that I have the possibility to see
something like this. απολυμανσεις

rafique habib said...

This is a very good post which I really enjoy reading. It is not every day that I have the possibility to see
something like this. απολυμανσεις

rafique habib said...

This is a very good post which I really enjoy reading. It is not every day that I have the possibility to see
something like this.apolimanseis

rafique habib said...

I wanted to thank you for this great post!!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.slsabyrd.com/gut-check-for-men-courtesy-of-the-girlfriend-activation-system-the-scrambler-and-the-slow-fade/

rafique habib said...

I wanted to thank you for this great post!!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.http://slsabyrd.com/

rafique habib said...

This type of
message always inspiring and I prefer to read quality content, so happy to
find good place to many here in the post, the writing is just great, thanks
for the post.is girlfriend activation system v2 worth it

rafique habib said...

Your blogs further more each else volume is so entertaining further serviceable It appoints me befall retreat encore. I will instantly grab your feed to stay informed of any updates.www.nagmauritius.org/how-to-treat-hair-loss-with-home-remedies

rafique habib said...

Your blogs further more each else volume is so entertaining further serviceable It appoints me befall retreat encore. I will instantly grab your feed to stay informed of any updateswww.nagmauritius.org

rafique habib said...

Great post, you have pointed out some excellent points, I as well believe this is a very superb website.hair loss home remedies that work

rafique habib said...

I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from
http://girlfriendactivationsystem.co/girlfriend-activation-system-review/

rafique habib said...

I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from
http://girlfriendactivationsystem.co/girlfriend-activation-system-review/

rafique habib said...

I feel very grateful that I read this. It is very helpful and very informative and I really learned a lot from
http://girlfriendactivationsystem.co/girlfriend-activation-system-review/

Zam Zam said...

Nice information, valuable and excellent design, as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts, lots of great information and inspiration, both of which I need, thanks to offer such a helpful information here.www.nagmauritius.org/how-to-treat-hair-loss-with-home-remedies

Zam Zam said...

Thank you for your post, I look for such article along time, today i find it finally. this post give me lots of advise it is very useful for me hair loss home remedies that work

Zam Zam said...

Because we screen our members, these criminal, fraudulent or inaccurate profiles were never posted.
online single dating

Zam Zam said...

Because we screen our members, these criminal, fraudulent or inaccurate profiles were never posted.
online single dating

Gennie said...

merry christmas messages
merry christmas messages
christmas greetings messages
wishes merry christmas
xmas wishes 2015
christmas msg 2015
greeting messages xmas
card messages merry christmas
xmas funny quotes
christmas funny quotes

Zam Zam said...

Good post. It is really help to us. Its give us lots of interest and pleasure. Its opportunity are so fantastic and working style so speedy. Its really a good article. It gives me lots of pleasure and interest..!! https://www.rebelmouse.com/

Nettie yaka said...

perumahan jakarta timur rumah disewa jakarta rumah btn di jakarta timur jual rumah murah di jakarta timur kredit rumah di jakarta timur rumah jual jakarta rumah kontrakan murah jakarta timur harga rumah di alam sutera serpong rumah di alam sutera rumah dijual alam sutera olivia rumah dijual di alam sutera serpong rumah alam sutera serpong di jual rumah alam sutera tangerang jual rumah alam sutera jual rumah alam sutera jual rumah di alam sutera 2012 jual rumah alam sutera 2010 perumahan alam sutera serpong jual rumah murah di alam sutera harga perumahan alam sutera tangerang

Zam Zam said...

Blue Sky Addiction Treatment is a dedicated network of providers that is passionate about placing each of our clients into the correct type of addiction treatment program for their individual needs.
We help identify and address a wide array of needs related to drug and alcohol addiction,
as well as mental health services.drug addiction rehabilitation programs

Murray butar said...

Rumah Dijual BSD Rumah Bsd JUal Rumah di BSD Harga Rumah Di Gadi Jual Rumah Di Alam Sutera Rumah Dijual Bsd Giri Loka gading serpong Gudang Tas Branded Tas Wanita Murah Butik Baju Murah Grosir Tas Jual Krim Pemutih Rumah DIjual Di Giri Loka Grosiran Baju Murah Toko Tas Grosir Dijual Rumah Bsd Ta Jual Rumah Di Griya Tas Import Grosir Tas Murah Import Fashion Grosir

Burl yuni said...

Distributor Tas Mur Dijual Rumah Cluster Pusat Grosir Tas Rumah Dijual Di The Jual Rumah Bsd Gree Dijual Rumah Di Bsd Tas Murah Batam pemutih wajah pria Baju Murah Bandung Rumah Dijual Di Serpong Rumah Murah di Alam Sutera Jual Rumah Bumi Ser Tas Cantik Produk Pemutih Wajah Ciri-Ciri Krim Pemutih Tas Tas Murah Nama Produk Pemutih Tas Cantik Harga Tanah Di Nusa Kosmetik Buat Wajah

Nettie yaka said...

jual apartemen gading serpong tangerang jual apartemen tangerang selatan jual apartemen jakarta barat jual apartemen jakarta pusat jual apartemen jakarta selatan jual apartemen jakarta timur jual apartemen jakarta utara jual rumah dki jakarta jual rumah jakarta barat jual rumah jakarta pusat jual rumah jakarta selatan jual rumah jakarta timur jual rumah jakarta utara jasa kontraktor waterproofing jual bahan bangunan jual baja ringan jual bata jual besi jual genteng jual hebel jual pasir jual paving konsultasi pajak startegi penjualan bagian keuangan sewa mobil pemikiran bisnis menghitung ekuitas jasa video editing trader tunggal meningkatkan etos kerja wedding website pelatihan manajemen Rental Mobil strateg bisnis jasa pelatihan jasa video editing pengaruh brand

Benny carrolina said...

Beli Rumah Di Alam Jual Rumah Di Bsd Sewa Rumah Gading S Grosiran Baju Murah Grosir Baju Tanah Abang jual rumah bsd gading Rumah Dijual Bsd Pu Grosir Tas Branded Grosir Jual Rumah BSD Nusa Loka Tas KW Grosir Rumah Dijual Rumah Dikontrakan Jual RUmah BSD City Dijual Rumah Murah Belanja Tas Rumah Dijual Baju Muslim Murah Grosir Online Baju Korea Online

Murray butar said...

Supplier Baju Kosmetik Untuk Wajah Rumah Dijual Di Griya Loka Rumah Dijual Di Del Jasa Kontraktor Rumah Pemutih Kulit Secara Alami Tas Kantor Jual Rumah Bsd Game Truk Gandeng Tas Tas Batam Baju Murah Bandung Dijual Rumah Bsd Branded Tas Batu Merah Hati Rumah Second Di Alam Sutra Tas Branded Murah Harga Tanah Nusa Loka Harga Pintu Besi Pasir Putih Depok Gambar Interior Rumah Minimali

Kieth daeng said...

Kanopi Rumah Jual Rumah Bsd Gading Baju Grosir Korea Toko Murah Online Besi Cor Genteng Mutiara Instalasi Listrik Rumah Sederh Branded Tas Harga Sewa Rumah Di Model Rumah Mewah

Lexie riezky said...

Harga Paving Blok Tas Tas Batam Harga Pasir 2013 Contoh Teralis Jendela Tas Grosir Branded Desain Minimalis Cara Pembuatan Genteng Gambar Pagar Besi Minimalis Harga Besi Cor Permainan Mobil Truk Genteng Mantili Biaya Bangun Rumah Minimalis Fashion Wanita Teralis Pintu Tas Tas Bermerk Tas Grosir Tas Murah Bandung Tas Original Berat Jenis Beton Jasa Desain Rumah.Com

Zam Zam said...

SEO & Web Design Services that Work, Our Search Engine Optimization & Web Design services work because we connect people with your objectives,and our web design works because it gives them want they want,
without making them think. seo san diego

Zam Zam said...

Amazing Moments, Most Amazing moment in the history of video,
Enjoy the most amazing real video from the Amazing Moments natural video, Amazing Moments

Zam Zam said...

Almond oil has been in used for centuries now; the oil became popular in the last century because of its numerous health, skin, and hair benefits. Because of numerous almond oil benefits, the oil has been extensively used in Mediterranean and South East Asia regions where almond tree was first domesticated.Almond Oil Benefits

Amit Kumar said...


www.starsports.com t20 world cup 2016 live streaming
ICC T20 World Cup 2016 live streaming on starsports.com
cricket world cup 2016 live streaming on www.starsports.com
starspots.com 2020 world cup 2016 live streaming
twenty20 world cup 2016 live streaming
t20 world cup live streaming 2016 on www.hotstar.com

Gajraj Sharma said...

valentine poem for boyfriend
valentine day poem for girlfriend
best valentine day poem
valentine day whatsapp status
valentine day message for facebook
valentine day date sheet
valentine day wallpaper
valentine songs
valentine gift
valentine ideas
valentine card for boyfriend
valentine card for wife
hug day messages and images for girlfriend and boyfriend
kiss day messages images
promise day msgs,wishes and images
teddy day wishes,msgs for girlfriend and boyfriend
chocolate day msgs ,images sms for girlfriend
propose day msgs images wishes
rose day msg,sms,wishes for girlfriend

Basri Abdullah said...

Hello ! I just wish to give an enormous thumbs up for the nice info you've got right here on this post. I will probably be coming back to your weblog for more soon.Informasi Hiburan, Dunia Pendidikan dan Kecantikan Terbaik di Jakarta

guru les privat kerumah said...

Guru les privat kerumah

Guru privat jakarta

Guru les Privat SD SMP SMA

jual ramuan madura said...

Jual ramuan madura

jual tongkat madura

jual jamu tradisional

calon gubernur terkuat DKi 2017 said...


Calon Gubernur DKI Terkuat 2017

Calon Gubernur DKI 2017

Calon Terkuat Gubernur DKI 2017

guru les privat kerumah said...

Guru les privat kerumah

Guru privat jakarta

Guru les Privat SD SMP SMA

samvilale said...

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.
geometry dash| sniper games |happy wheels demo | happy wheels 2 |agario| five nights at freddy's

maderic said...

SALAM SEMANGAT

maderic obat asam urat said...

salam semangat

jamkho herbal kolesterol said...

salam semangat selamat pagi

jamsi obat penyakit gula said...

jamsi obat penyakit gula nice sahre

obat kolesterol jamkho said...

salam semangat

jamsi obat penyakit gula said...

salam semanta

jamkho herbal cepat said...

salam semangat

krim wajah aman said...

salam sehat

cream wajah yang aman said...

cream wajah yang aman

Pusat produk woo tekh said...

Pusat produk woo tekh

Cream Memutihkan Wajah said...

Cream Memutihkan Wajah

Obat Pelangsing Badan Alami said...

Obat Pelangsing Badan Alami

Obat pelangsing cepat aman said...

Obat pelangsing cepat aman

Obat Pelangsing Slimming Capsule Green World said...

Obat Pelangsing Slimming Capsule Green World

Pelangsing badan cepat dan aman said...

Pelangsing badan cepat dan aman

Jamu pelangsing tradisional cepat aman said...

Jamu pelangsing tradisional cepat aman

PELANGSING WSC BIOLO said...

PELANGSING WSC BIOLO

Obat Pelangsing Wsc Biolo said...

Obat Pelangsing Wsc Biolo

Pelangsing wsc biolo woo tekh said...

Pelangsing wsc biolo woo tekh

Wsc biolo obat pelangsing yang aman said...

Wsc biolo obat pelangsing yang aman

Obat pelangsing badan cepat dan ampuh wsc biolo said...

Obat pelangsing badan cepat dan ampuh wsc biolo

Obat diet cepat dan aman wsc biolo said...

Obat diet cepat dan aman wsc biolo

OBAT PELANGSING WSC BIOLO said...

OBAT PELANGSING WSC BIOLO

OBAT PELANGSING AMPUH said...

OBAT PELANGSING AMPUH

Kapsul Pelangsing Badan Alami said...

Kapsul Pelangsing Badan Alami

budan said...

Pratista skin care
Tf Organik
obat jerawat paling ampuh

Jasaqq
Dominoqq
Bandarq

Guru les privat kerumah

Guru privat jakarta

Guru les Privat SD SMP SMA

jasa seo murah bergaransi

budan said...

obat pembesar penis
obat pembesar alat vital pria

sewa dan Rental mobil surabaya
Rental Mobil Surabaya

Amit Kumar said...


this blog is really helpful. i found very interesting things here. i HAVE FOUND THE ANSWER OF MY SOLUTION HERE.

Fan Movie Review
www.bookmyshow.com Fan Movie Advance Ticket Booking
Fan Movie Rating
Fan Movie Public Response
Fan Movie Critics
Fan Movie Story
Book Online Fan Movie on www.bookmyshow.com
Fan Movie Budget
Fan Review
Fan Rating
Fan Advance Ticket Booking on bookmyshow.com


this blog is really helpful. i found very interesting things here. i HAVE FOUND THE ANSWER OF MY SOLUTION HERE.

First Day Collection Of Fan
Second Day Collection Fan
Third Day Collection Fan
Total Box Office Collection of fan
Opening Box Office Collection Of Fan
Weekend Collection Of Fan
1st Day Collection Of Fan
Shahrukh Khan's Top 10 facts about fan movie
2nd Day Collection Fan
3rd Day Collection Fan
Fan Friday Box Office Collection
Fan Saturday Box Office Collection Report
Fan Sunday Box Office Income

youncy said...

Jasaqq
Dominoqq
Bandarq

Eri Alaaspari said...

thank you very much gan , the article is very interesting that we can refer to.
cara mengobati ganglion tanpa operasi

Qnc Jelly Gamat Asli Original said...


Qnc Jelly Gamat Asli Original

PELANGSING badan biolo said...

amazing sahre in veru interesting

Obat Pelangsing Perut Buncit Alami said...

Obat Pelangsing Perut Buncit Alami

Biolo Wsc Obat Pelangsing said...

Biolo Wsc Obat Pelangsing

Pelangsing Badan Biolo Slimming said...

Pelangsing Badan Biolo Slimming

woo tekh indonesia said...

woo tekh indonesia

OBAT TRADISIONAL PELANGSING AMAN said...

OBAT TRADISIONAL PELANGSING AMAN

Pelangsing wsc biolo woo tekh said...

Pelangsing wsc biolo woo tekh

obat pelangsing yang aman said...

obat pelangsing yang aman

Obat pelangsing badan cepat dan ampuh wsc biolo said...

Obat pelangsing badan cepat dan ampuh wsc biolo

imc poker said...

imc poker

bandarq said...

bandarq

texas poker said...

texas poker

youncy said...

obat diabetes alami
obat kolesterol alami
obat asam urat alami

obat diabetes alami
obat kolesterol alami
obat asam urat alami

manfaat minyak lintah
minyak lintah asli
khasiat minyak lintah

Agen Domino
Agen Poker
Agen Domino QQ

batik dewandari said...

Perfect Blog. Nice way to relax and get some important information. Thanks
baju batik lebaran
baju batik muslim
seragam baju batik
baju seragam kerja

gta 5 said...

Very interesting blog. Alot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definately interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know.
gta 5 | www.google search | excel