Thursday, June 3, 2010

US Monetary Policy in the 2010’s: The Mankiw Rule Today

To make a short story even shorter, the Mankiw Rule suggests that the Zero Interest Rate Policy will continue for quite some time, barring dramatic changes in the inflation and/or unemployment rates.

“The Mankiw Rule” is what I call Greg Mankiw’s version of the Taylor Rule. “Taylor Rule” is now the general term for a rule that sets a monetary policy interest rate (usually the federal funds rate in the US case) as a linear function of an inflation rate and a measure of economic slack. Such rules provide a simple way of either describing or prescribing monetary policy. Unfortunately, there are now many different versions of the Taylor Rule, which all lead to different conclusions. Not only are there many different measures of both slack and inflation; there are also an infinite number of possible coefficients that could be used to relate them to the policy interest rate. In fact, if you ask John Taylor today, he will advocate a very different set of coefficients than the ones he proposed in his original 1993 paper (pdf).

Parsimony suggests that a good Taylor rule should have 3 characteristics: it should be as simple as possible; it should use robust, easily defined, and well-known measures of slack and inflation; and it should fit reasonably well to past monetary policy. Also, to have credibility, such a rule should have “stood the test of time” to some extent: it should fit reasonably well to some subsequent monetary policy experience after it was first proposed. The Mankiw Rule has all these characteristics. It uses the unemployment rate and the core CPI inflation rate as its measures, and it applies the same coefficient to both. This setup leaves it with only two free parameters, which Greg set in a 2001 paper (pdf) so as to fit the results to actual 1990’s monetary policy. As you can see from the chart below, the rule fits subsequent monetary policy rather well, although policy has tended to be slightly more easy (until 2008) than the rule would imply.



You will notice a substantial divergence, however, after 2008, between the Mankiw Rule and the actual federal funds rate. If the reason for this divergence isn’t immediately clear, you need to take a closer look at the vertical axis. Extrapolating from pre-Lehman experience, this chart suggests that the Fed is still doing the best it can to approximate the Mankiw Rule. When banks lend money to one another in the federal funds market, lenders stubbornly refuse to pay for the privilege of lending, and this perversity does limit the Fed’s options.

If we wanted to make a guess as to when the Fed will (or should) raise its target for the federal funds rate, a reasonable guess would be “when the Mankiw Rule rate rises above zero.” When will that happen? (Will it ever happen?) Nobody knows, of course, but the algebra is straightforward as to what will need to happen to inflation and unemployment. If the core inflation rate remains near 1%, the unemployment rate will have to fall to 7%. If the core inflation rate rises to 2%, the unemployment rate will still have to fall to 8%. Do you expect either of these things to happen soon? I don’t.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management.

637 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   601 – 637 of 637
Laurensia Chia said...

sbobet88

Web Development Company said...

Thanks to share this best information with us. Please visit here for latest techniques and more about web development company in all over the world. Web Development Company

Unknown said...

Thank you very much for sharing this very useful information, I am very happy to have found this information that I have been looking for my business development assignment help

anika kennedy said...

Excellent information you have shared! Stop worrying about your assignment. we are here to provide python assignment help at affordable prices with the help of a team of top programming experts. They can help you to understand the basics of academic writing and learn python programming for your better understanding.

Unknown said...

Nice post.Marketing Sweet

John Snyder said...

The website provide hot product with best price . Visit my site if you want to buy product: http://bestcouponaz.com/

freya maya said...

TCNBA es la mejor tienda online si estás pensando en adquirir una flamante y novedosa camiseta NBA. En www.tuscamisetasNBA.com encontrarás la mejor calidad de camisetas por el precio más reducido. La atención al cliente de TUSCAMISETASNBA es impecable y siempre contarás con ayuda y amabilidad por parte del equipo de atención al cliente. Si no encuentras alguna camiseta, puedes preguntarnos y quizá la tengamos. Confía en la calidad, confía en tcnba.

MATLAB solutions said...

This is something very important to understand, I really appreciate your efforts to share such information. Here I am also sharing some information that might be useful for students looking for Assignment Help , in various subjects like, MATLAB Assignment Help , or Matlab Assignment Help Online

Joy Brick said...

No more worries about your chemistry homework when you have Chemistry Assignment Help services. If you are unable to write your projects or having doubt over any topic, ask academic writers for more information.

Chemistry Homework Help

Chemistry Homework Help

Laurensia Chia said...

scr888

freya maya said...

Best buy Thai Buddhist Amulets, for Wealth, Health Luck Gambling money business , Love sex , and Happiness. Thai Amulets, Buddha amulet Magic Charms, Tiger Talismans.

Laurensia Chia said...

idn poker online

MIC Support LLC said...

A right decision and direction are very necessary grow an IT business to the top level. We, MIC Support LLC offering complete IT solutions including web design, development and digital marketing services. If you are a beginner in the field of IT business then you can contact our experts to get the right service related to website design, development and other IT services.

R Tech Pro said...

Latiesha (Evangelist Royal Free) Brown is a passionate life and Self Development Coach empowering viewers all over the world to break free from UNHEALTHY RELATIONSHIPS - Latiesha Brown faith UNHOLY SPIRITUALITY - CHURCH RED FLAGS - VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN and everything in between.

On this channel, I help you reflect, learn and breakthrough toxic relationships. If you're ready to create a new path for yourself, Latiesha Brown hit that subscribe button.

freya maya said...

InDesign's comprehensive course training teaches you how to master the features of this page layout software: create a template, add pages, blocks, text variables, format text using style sheets, and heal. graphics. Indesign Workshop

freya maya said...

InDesign's comprehensive course training teaches you how to master the features of this page layout software: Indesign Workshop create a template, add pages, blocks, text variables, format text using style sheets, and heal. graphics.

Amy Kriysten said...


"Hire an IT Department Starting at $99/month

Text or Call us at (888) 778-9532

Our Website: Rootpal.com

Build your business with a dedicated IT team to help manage, grow, and secure your company.

How Does Rootpal Work?

Rootpal gives you a dedicated IT team that helps you set up your business computers, servers, website, SEO and much more.

Every business small or large needs an IT team

Every business needs guidance on how to grow their IT infrastructure and we're your solution to making it all come together.

The Rootpal Services

Here are just a few of the services that we provide and assist with setting up for your business at Rootpal.

Unlimited Remote Support
Virus & Malware Protection
Backup & Disaster Recovery
remote support
Web & Hosting Solutions
Business Email
SEO & Backlink Building
Server Setup & Maintenance
Remote Monitoring

Increase your business revenue through IT

Rootpal increases your business growth by increasing your business's tech through our services.
"

Puremelda said...

Top Rated Nursing Writing Services allows students to navigate their work. The Firm avoids unoriginal writing. It takes time to craft the Nursing Research Paper Writing Services and gives adequate time to reflect and develop Best Nursing Writing Company.

Puremelda said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Sam Finnie said...

Helping out students to carry out their Marketing Assignments

KayleBates said...

Great goods from you, man. I've understand your stuff pruor too and you are just too magnificent. I realy like wha you hve acquired right here, certainly like what you are stating and the best way through which you say it.

You're making it enjoyable and you continue to take care of to keep it sensible. I cant wait to read much mkre from you. Thhis is actually a great web site.

Kerenisme
Cantika

Term Paper Writing Services said...

It is very convenient to use Admission Essay Writing Service of Research Papers Writing Services company which is available at any time of the day of the week, month and year as it can assist you any time you require Custom College Papers Writing Services.

Term Paper Writing Services said...

It is very convenient to use Admission Essay Writing Service of Research Papers Writing Services company which is available at any time of the day of the week, month and year as it can assist you any time you require Custom College Papers Writing Services.

Term Paper Writing Services said...

It is normal for students to be anxious about hiring an online professional Online Term Paper Writer because they can never be sure whether they can get high-quality affordable Nursing Assignment Services and the right Research Papers Writing Services or not.

Essay Writer Services said...

Acquiring Thesis Writing Services doesn’t have to drain your finances. Custom College Papers Services charges are modest to ensure clients receive Article Review Paper Writing Services which are original and well written.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

Are you looking for Unmatched Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services? You don’t need to fail your Custom Research Paper Writing Services when you can utilize the best Dissertation Help Services or Affordable Custom Research Paper Services from the help of the online paper writers.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

You should take some time and evaluate the Custom Essay Writing Services and Cheap Custom Essay Services as most students buy Affordable Online Essay For Sale and get ripped off.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

All of your Nursing Research Papers Services and Nursing Research Paper Writing Help hardships and problems can be solved easily by providing Custom Nursing Writing Services assistance.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

It is normal for students to be anxious about hiring an online professional Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services Provider because they can never be sure whether they can get high-quality affordable Custom Research Paper Services and the right Research Paper Assistance Services or not.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

The backbone of Term Paper Writing Services company is its writers and ours are the choicest in the industry to ensure that clients acquire the Best Term Paper Services and that will make you collect a high-quality Custom Term Paper Writing Help.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

Are you looking for Unmatched Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services? You don’t need to fail your Custom Research Paper Writing Services when you can utilize the best Dissertation Help Services or Affordable Custom Research Paper Services from the help of the online paper writers.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

You should take some time and evaluate the Custom Essay Writing Services and Cheap Custom Essay Services as most students buy Affordable Online Essay For Sale and get ripped off.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

All of your Nursing Research Papers Services and Nursing Research Paper Writing Help hardships and problems can be solved easily by providing Custom Nursing Writing Services assistance.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

It is normal for students to be anxious about hiring an online professional Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services Provider because they can never be sure whether they can get high-quality affordable Custom Research Paper Services and the right Research Paper Assistance Services or not.

Legitimate Custom Research Paper Services said...

The backbone of Term Paper Writing Services company is its writers and ours are the choicest in the industry to ensure that clients acquire the Best Term Paper Services and that will make you collect a high-quality Custom Term Paper Writing Help.

John Snyder said...

แทงบอลufabet เว็บพนันออนไลน์ ยูฟ่าเบท สมัครฟรี 2500 | UFA เดิมพันขั้นต่ำ 10 บาท ใช้ระบบ ฝาก-ถอน 30 เท่านั้น สมัครวันนี้รับโปรโมชั่น 100% สนใจ @ufa700

Total Assingment Help said...

We have an expertise in providing accounting assignment help. Our accounting writers are highly experienced and dedicated in their specific domain

«Oldest ‹Older   601 – 637 of 637   Newer› Newest»