Monday, March 16, 2009

Absolute Confidence?

Not just the Chinese government, but every investor can have absolute confidence in the soundness of investments in the U.S.
– President Barack Obama, March 14, 2009, as reported in Bloomberg.

Statements like this one are causing me to lose confidence in the Obama administration’s economic policies. The particular investments about which the Chinese have been concerned are US Treasury securities. Absolute confidence in US Treasury securities is exactly what we don’t need. Absolute confidence in these securities is precisely the problem. The problem – for the US, anyhow – is that everyone wants to hold US Treasury securities instead of investing their money in productive activities (or spending it on the output of productive activities).

This is not just true of Americans; it is true of the world, including the Chinese. China has four choices:
  1. It can buy US Treasury securities.

  2. It can buy other US securities that represent productive uses of money.

  3. It can buy non-US securities, in which case the value of the dollar will fall and make US products more attractive, thereby encouraging Americans to invest in productive activities.

  4. Or it can buy no securities at all, in which case the value of the Yuan will rise, making non-Chinese products more attractive, thereby encouraging non-Chinese (including Americans) to invest in productive activities to replace the Chinese products that have become more expensive.
China has been choosing the first of these four options, and if it has “absolute confidence in the soundness of investments in the US,” then it will continue to choose that option, and Americans will continue not to invest in productive activities.

There is a common but misguided belief – to which President Obama, as one may surmise from his statement above, apparently subscribes – that a loss of confidence in US assets would have disastrous consequences for the US economy. In a boom time, or an inflationary time, that would be the case, but in a deflationary environment like the present, the consequences are more likely to be good. The Wall Street Journal, as an example, gives a typical statement: of the “loss of confidence would be a disaster” point of view:
In the worst-case scenario, a significant new aversion to U.S. investments could drive down the dollar and drive up interest rates, worsening the U.S. recession.
First of all, driving down the dollar would not worsen the recession; the direct effect would be to mitigate the recession by making US products more attractive. As for rising interest rates during a recession, that would indeed be a worst-case scenario, but it would not be the result of the aversion to US assets. It would be a result of a bad US policy response to that aversion.

My logic should be fairly clear:
  1. The Treasury has a choice whether to finance long-term or short-term

  2. The Fed has a policy – until further notice – of holding the federal funds rate below 0.25%, which policy requires it to purchase enough T-bills to keep short-term US Treasury rates near zero.

  3. Therefore, there is no limit on the Treasury’s choice of financing. It can issue as many or as few long-term securities as it chooses. What it does not finance long term, it will be able to finance short term at a near-zero interest rate, since the Fed will purchase enough T-bills to assure this.

  4. Therefore, the Treasury controls the supply of long-term Treasury securities.

  5. Therefore (assuming that the demand curve for such securities has the usual downward slope in the relevant range), the Treasury controls the price of long-term Treasury securities.

  6. Therefore (since bond yields – i.e., interest rates – depend inversely on prices), the Treasury controls the interest rates on its long-term securities.

  7. During a time of potentially deflationary recession, it will not be in the nation’s interest for the Treasury to allow interest rates on its long-term securities to rise, nor will it be in the nation’s interest for the Fed to allow short-term rates to rise.

  8. If they do so – whether or not they do so in response to a drop in demand for those securities – it is simply bad policy. Bad policy is not the result of declining confidence in US securities; it is the result of bad choices by policymakers.
So which interest rates are we talking about? Short-term Treasury interest rates? Those are controlled by the Fed and will not rise unless the Fed allows them to rise. Long-term Treasury interest rates? Those are controlled by the Treasury and will not rise unless the Treasury allows them to rise.

Or are we talking about private sector interest rates? Corporate bonds, as an example, are priced according to risk spreads over Treasury bonds. Those risk spreads depend on the amount of additional risk involved in owning corporate bonds and the amount of compensation that investors require for accepting that additional risk. The key word here is “additional.” A loss of confidence in US assets would most likely make US assets in general more risky. But how would it increase the additional risk of corporate bonds relative to government bonds? If anything it would do the opposite: the loss of confidence would weaken the dollar, making it easier for US corporations to sell their products, thereby increasing their profitability and their creditworthiness and reducing the additional risk from owning their bonds.

So – subject to exogenous changes in risk and in the price of risk – private sector interest rates will not rise either, unless policymakers allow them to rise. The only good reason to allow rates to rise would be if excess demand begins to lift the US out of its deflationary recession and to threaten it with excessive inflation – a scenario inconsistent with “worsening the US recession.” Loss of confidence in US assets is not the worst-case scenario; bad policy is. Under current circumstances, encouraging excessive confidence in US Treasury securities is itself an example of bad policy. It’s not the worst case, but it’s far from the best.



DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management.

34 comments:

gg said...

Two comments
For what reason the fed to keep the fed funds
Rate at 0, 25 it must purchase enough T-bills to keep short-term US Treasury rates near zero?
Also if there are serious default or more likely inflation fears for the US there may be no or weak demand for short term T-bills at zero or low interest rates so the Fed has to absorb all the supply by printing money that can be highly inflationary
So although it is technically correct that it will be able to finance short term at a near-zero interest rate, since the Fed will purchase enough T-bills that carries with it a challenging trade-off.

Anonymous said...

what possible reason would they have any confidence in private equities or other securities? let see. equities are down what %50 in a year? and bonds are being discounted how much? the reason the flight to US treasuries occurred is simple. the trust between the investor and those pushing the securities has been trashed. and this isn't hampering the consumer as they are already trying to live on their diminished wages since credit dried up.

Anonymous said...

Hmmm, very interesting.

But if the Fed increased its holdings of treasuries (in order to offset lost Chinese demand) wouldn't that in turn increase the money supply? If so, wouldn't that create side effects? (Granted, in a deflationary context those might be good side effects, but...)

So if China lost all confidence and unloaded $1T worth of treasuries, in order to keep interest rates the same the Fed would be buying it, increasing M0 by $1T (highly non-trivial, right?).

Granted, let me know if my logic is wrong :) (Maybe the Fed itself wouldn't need to offset everything since there could be other buyers at the right price.)

Michael J. Bernard said...

Hyperinflation and the crash of the Keynesian model could be in the offing soon if the Chinese drastically draw down.

http://tinyurl.com/da295v

mB

Nazmul Aoto said...

Contingent upon length, a full circumstances and end results relationship may not be
essay writing services

conceivable inside your article. On the off chance that your rules oblige you to just utilize 500 words, for example, it will probably be so short there is no option let you cover the subject in total. Thusly, choosing whether to put the highlight on reason or impact will give you a chance to keep the work in more reasonable terms.

best essay writing services said...

To get the best works furthermore the best scores and grades submit your task to these arrangement suppliers and do you're different undertakings till your task is prepared to be submitted.

Samuel Moreland said...

. At the earliest reference point; you have to hit upon the right credit organization that arrangements with less time intensive credits and work out an application. www.aaa1autotitleloans.com/chicago

Erin cody said...

Hello,I love reading through your blog, I wanted to leave a little comment to support you and wish you a good continuation. Wishing you the best of luck for all your blogging efforts. 
Cmdent Travel |

Girl Travel |

Travel Kyouto |

Travel Toward |

Time Travel Today |

Yonse Travel |

Jomari Travel |

Home Gard Funding |

Big Home |

Rapid Homes |

marly aaran said...

his is my first time visit here. From the tons of comments on your articles,I guess I am not only one having all the enjoyment right here!
Business Builders |

Business Analyst |

Falcon Profits |

E-Business |

Business Book |

Pro Bonus Business |

Business Law |

Business Marketing |

My Business for Home |

Small Business Hub |

Robin Son said...

Hey what a brilliant post I have come across and believe me I have been searching out for this similar kind of post for past a week and hardly came across this. Thank you very much and will look for more postings from you.
Away Health Club |

On Care Cream |

AZ Health Care |

My Fitness Tree |

Fourth Sector Health |

Sandiego Fitness Club |

Live it Health For Life |

Green Up County Health |

Vision Care |

Loving Care |

amine lahragui said...

Your work is very good and I appreciate you and hopping for some more informative posts. happy new year 2016 new year 2016
bonne année 2016 imagenes de año nuevo 2016 imagenes de navidad 2016 feliz año nuevo 2016 Journée internationale des droits des femmes 2016

Rahul Dhalgade said...

Thanks you for this post… great information.
Star Cricket Live Streaming HD Channel 1 2 3 4
Where can i Watch Live Cricket Online On starsports.com

Deepak Negi said...

Hey Guys Must Check these :-

I can do that live show
I can do that live telecast
I can do that Show live streaming

Dhanteras 2015 Puja
Dhanteras 2015 Gold Sale Offers
Dhanteras 2015 Puja Samagri
Dhanteras 2015 Puja Vidhi
Kuber 2015 puja vidhi

Happy Childrens Day 2015 Images
Childrens Day 2015
Happy Childrens Day 2015
Childrens Day 2015 Speech
Happy Childrens Day 2015 Quotes

Mastizaade Box Office Collection
Mastizaade Funny Scenes
Mastizaade hd Videos
Mastizaade hd Torrent Download
Mastizaade free Torrent download
Mastizaade kickass torrent
Mastizaade Hot Scenes
Mastizaade Movie Review
Mastizaade Romantic Scenes
Mastizaade Songs
Mastizaade trailer film
Mastizaade 1st Day Collection Prediction
Sunny Leone Mastizaade Movie

World Aids Day 2015 Quotes
World Aids Day 2015 Posters
World Aids Day 2015 Themes
World Aids Day 2015 Slogans
Happy New Year 2016
New Year 2016
New Year 2016 Quotes
Happy New Year 2016 Images
New Year 2016 Wishes

Sagar Balyan said...

rose day whatsapp dp
rose day whatsapp dp images
rose day romantic sms for girlfriend
happy rose day sms wallpaper
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in English
Happy New Year 2016 FB Messages in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Shayari in Hindi
Happy New Year 2016 FB Status in Urdu
happy new year 2016 animated videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp videos
happy new year 2016 whatsapp short videos
happy new year 2016 fb animated images
happy new year 2016 fb GIF images
happy new year shayari
happy new year 2016 shayari sms
happy new year shayari images
happy new year 2016 sms images
happy new year 2016 sms wallpaper
valentines day 2016 romantic quotes
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for her
romantic valentines day 2016 quotes for girlfriend
happy valentines day 2016 romantic SMS
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Wishes for Boyfriend
Valentines Day 2016 Romantic Sayings for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic messages for gf
happy valentines day 2016 romantic images
romantic Valentines Day 2016 E Cards
valentines day romantic 2016 FB Covers
happy valentines day 2016 Romantic FB Status
valentines day 2016 romantic sayings for Boyfriend
valentines day love sms messages
royal rumble 2016 live stream
watch royal rumble live streaming online
royal rumble 2016 results highlights
who won royal rumble 2016 winner
watch royal rumble 2016 HD video free ppv
royal rumble 2016 live online

Sagar Balyan said...

valentine day sms wallpaper
valentine day single line status
valentine day shayari one line
valentine day latest shayari
valentine day love shayari in hindi
valentine day shayari for boyfriend
valentine day shayari for girlfriend
valentine day love sms messages
valentine day shayari facebook
valentine's day shayari for wife
valentine kiss day shayari
valentine's day sher o shayari
valentine day sher o shayari hindi
valentine romantic status for whatsapp
whatsapp status valentine day special
valentine special whatsapp videos
valentine day special whatsapp short video
valentines day funny whatsapp status
valentines day romantic whatsapp status
valentines day one line whatsapp status
hug day love quotes
hug day long quotes
hug day latest quotes
hug day sad quotes
hug day love sms messages
hug day short quotes
hug day sad quotes 2 lines
hug day sad quotes one line status
hug day quotes messages for girlfriend
hug day quotes for gf
hug day quotes for best friend
hug day emotional quotes
hug day romantic quotes
romantic hug quotes for her
romantic hug day sms in hindi
hug day 2016 sms wallpaper
rose day 2016 shayari sms
rose day shayari sms in hindi
7th feb rose day sms
rose day love sms messages
rose day 2016 romantic sms
happy rose day romantic shayari
valentine day special whatsapp short video
rose day whatsapp short video

Anonymous said...

This is such a abundant ability that you are accouterments and you accord it abroad for free. I adulation seeing websites that accept the http://www.essaymania.net/ amount of accouterments a affection ability for free.

Mobile Storebox said...

Happy Lohri Wallpaper
Lohri Pics
Happy Lohri Images
Happy Lohri Wishes
Happy Lohri Quotes
Hindu Festival 2015
Sundance Film Festival
Things to do in Edinburgh
Holy Ship
Thaipusam
BPM Festival
Carnevale Di Venezia
Things to do in Banff
Ati-Atihan
Lohri Wishes
WWE in India
Sundance Film Festival 2016
Up Helly Aa
Lohri Festival
Harbin Ice Festival
Jam Cruise
Quebec Winter Carnival
Ice Sculpture
Hogmanay 2016
Junkanoo Parade
Sundance Film festival Winners
Rainbow Serpent Festival
Holy Ship 2016
Cowboy Poetry
Dinagyang

Mobile Storebox said...

Republic Day Image
Republic Day Wallpaper
Republic Day Messages
Republic Day Speech
Republic Day Status
Republic Day Speech in Hindi
Speech on Republic Day
Republic Day India
Speech on Republic Day in Hindi
Essay on Republic Day
Republic Day 2016
Republic Day Pictures
Republic Day Information
Republic Day in Hindi
Republic Day Photos
Republic Day Pics
Images of Republic Day
Lohri
Happy Lohri
Lohri Wallpapers
Lohri Festival
Lohri Wishes
Lohri Sms
Lohri Songs
Lohri Images
Lohri Greetings

Mobile Storebox said...

Republic Day Wallpaper
Republic Day Messages
Republic Day Speech
Republic Day Status
Republic Day Speech in Hindi
Speech on Republic Day
Republic Day India
Speech on Republic Day in Hindi
Essay on Republic Day
Republic Day 2016
Republic Day Pictures
Republic Day Information
Republic Day in Hindi
Republic Day Photos
Republic Day Pics
Images of Republic Day
Republic Day
Republic Day Quotes
Happy Republic Day
Speech for Republic Day
Republic Day Wishes
Republic Day Images
India Republic Day
Republic Day Sms
Republic Day Songs
What is Republic Day

Mobile Storebox said...

Lohri
Happy Lohri
Lohri Wallpapers
Lohri Festival
Lohri Wishes
Lohri Sms
Lohri Songs
Lohri Images
Lohri Greetings
Happy Lohri Wallpaper
Lohri Pics
Happy Lohri Images
Happy Lohri Wishes
Happy Lohri Quotes
Hindu Festival 2015
Republic Day
Republic Day Quotes
Happy Republic Day
Speech for Republic Day
Republic Day Wishes
Republic Day Images
India Republic Day
Republic Day Sms
Republic Day Songs
What is Republic Day
Republic Day Image

asds said...

Inspirational Love Quotes
Love Quotes
Inspirational Quotes

Inspirational Quotes
Love Quotes
Photoshop Tutorials

Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mother's Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016
Happy Mother's Day 2016
Mothers Day 2016
Mother's Day 2016

happy mothers day quotes
happy mothers day messages
happy mothers day poems

mothers day quotes from daughter
mothers day quotes from son
mothers day quotes from husband to wife

mothers day quotes from family
mothers day quotes
mothers day messages

mothers day poems
mothers day poems from daughter
funny mothers day quotes

funny mothers day messages
funny mothers day sayings
mothers day sayings

mothers day love quotes
inspirational mothers day quotes

asds said...

Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mother's Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016

Happy Mother's Day 2016
Mothers Day 2016
Mother's Day 2016
Happy Mothers Day
Happy Mother's Day
Happy Mothers Day 2016

Happy Mother's Day 2016
Mothers Day 2016
Mother's Day 2016

asds said...

Happy fathers Day
Happy father's Day
Happy fathers Day 2016

Happy father's Day 2016
fathers Day 2016
father's Day 2016

father's day
fathers day

fathers day quotes
fathers day messages
fathers day poems
Happy fathers Day
Happy father's Day
Happy fathers Day 2016

Happy father's Day 2016
fathers Day 2016
father's Day 2016

Happy Father’S Day 2016 Quotes

asds said...

Wishes Quotes
Wishes Quotes Greetings
Easter Sunday
Easter Sunday 2016
Recover Deleted Files on Android
Apple iPad Mini 4 Cases and Covers
Online Music Identification Services

Multiplayer Games for your iPhone
Free Stock Photo Websites
Design Resources

Free Android Apps
Improve the Performance of Android Tablet
Screen Recording Software
Screen Sharing Software for Remote Access

asds said...

Valentines day 2016
Happy Valentines day 2016
Happy Valentines day
Valentine's day 2016

Happy Valentine Day Quotes For Husband
kiss quotes for her
kiss quotes for girlfriend

happy valentines day 2016
valentines day 2016
valentine's day 2016

happy propose day
valentines day quotes
happy valentines day quotes
happy valentines day quotes

kiss quotes for boyfriend
anti valentines day quotes
anti valentines day quotes

propose day sms
short valentines day poems

asds said...

valentines day poems for her
valentines day poems for girlfriend
Happy Rose Day Quotes SMS And Sayings

Happy Propose Day SMS - Messages For Him And Her
Valentines Day Quotes
Happy Chocolate Day Love Quotes

Happy Chocolate Day Sms Messages
Valentines Day Gifts For Her
Cheap Valentines Day Cards

Cute Valentines Day Quotes
Valentines Day Poems For Him
Happy Valentines Day Whatsapp Messages

Valentines Day Ideas For Kids
Valentines Day Pick Up Lines
Happy Chocolate Day Quotes For Him And Her

happy valentines day quotes
valentines day quotes
Happy Valentine Day Quotes For Husband

asds said...

Valentines day 2016
Happy Valentines day 2016
Happy Valentines day
Valentine's day 2016

Funny Valentines Day Quotes
Valentine Week List 2016
Valentines Day Quotes
Happy Valentines Day Quotes
fathers day quotes
fathers day messages
fathers day poems

Easter Quotes From The Bible
Happy Easter Quotes
Easter Quotes

MEANING OF REPUBLIC OF INDIA HISTORY said...

republic day of india
republic day image
happy republic day images
images of republic day
republic day of india
india republic day
importance of republic day
republic day pics
photos of republic day
about republic day in hindi
happy republic day image
republic day speech
indian republic day
speech on republic day
26 january republic day
republic day 2016

Republic Day in Hindi Language | English Language said...

happy republic day
republic day
republic day images
indian republic day
happy republic day 2014
republic day quotes
happy republic day images
republic day image
republic day photos
republic day sms
republic day message
republic day wishes
republic day pictures
26 january republic day
republic day greetings
republic day photo
republic day in hindi
republic day images pictures
26 january republic day images
indian republic day quotes

Republic day message for students said...

republic day parade
speech on republic day in english
republic day message
speech for republic day
indian republic day 2014
january 26 republic day
republic day celebration
republic day greetings
speech of republic day
short speech on republic day
happy republic day quotes
republic day in hindi
republic day photos
republic day pic
republic day images
greetings of republic day
26 january republic day images
image of republic day
republic day photo

Jessica Jeon said...

This article has been all about Facebook Followers plus the way having whole lot more number of followers in today's time is simply wonderful. buy facebook followers

salman khan said...

Your Site Is Very Good and The Post is Well On Topic, Thanks for Sharing it with us.

New Movies Songs 2016
airlift akshay powerpack performance
los angeles is facing housing
Anne Hathaway Proudly Reveals
apple iphone 7 colors
Quetta Gladiators T20 Pakistan Super League 2016
love poetry in urdu 2016
New Video Songs 2016
royalty free electronic music 2016

Priyanka Sharma said...

Current News And updates |

Omkar kapoor |

Airtel 4g Girl |

Serial Ye hain Mohhabtein |

Funny Valentines day messages |

Chocolate day Messages |

Happy Valentines day 2016 Wallpapers |

Valentines day Messages |

Latest Bikes IN INdia |

Valentines day 2016 pictures |

Teddy Day pictures

Lucy Linda said...

Garcinina Cambogia extract was recently featured on Dr. Oz where he proclaimed it as the "Holy Grail of Weight Loss" supplements. Learn how Dr Oz Garcinia Extracts Works to Lose Weight, Burn fat and suppress appetite.