Monday, August 9, 2010

Inflation Targeting When the Natural Interest Rate is Negative

Over a century ago, in a theory that is still influential today, Swedish economist Knut Wicksell argued that, at any particular time, there is a certain “natural rate of interest” that is consistent with price stability. If the actual rate of interest falls below the natural rate, there is an incentive for entrepreneurs to borrow aggressively and demand more goods and more labor, driving prices up. If the actual rate rises above the natural rate, the incentive to borrow disappears, leading entrepreneurs to demand less goods and labor, driving prices down. Since the opportunities available to entrepreneurs are always changing, the natural rate is always changing, sometimes rising dramatically and at other times falling dramatically. Thus Wicksell argued that, relative to the natural rate, “the interest on money is, in reality, very often low when it seems to be high, and high when it seems to be low.”

As applied to the world we live in today, Wicksell’s original theory has several shortcomings, all widely recognized now. First, it doesn’t account for stickiness in wages and prices: as we observe, the short-run effect of a drop in demand is not so much a fall in wages and prices as a fall in employment. Second, it doesn’t account for the role of expectations in determining the price level and thus, the possibility of “inertial” inflation: it is now generally understood that (under a fiat money regime) a steadily rising price level, rather than a necessarily constant price level, is consistent with the equilibrium “natural” interest rate that Wicksell hypothesized. Third, it doesn’t fully account for the role of inflation expectations in defining the “real” interest rate: for example, a 2% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to be constant is equivalent to a 4% nominal interest rate when prices are expected to rise at a 2% rate. Finally, as I discuss below, it doesn’t account for the role of risk aversion in determining the behavior of entrepreneurs and those who finance them.

Wicksell argued that the natural interest rate was determined by the rate of return on capital. But in practice, the rate of return on capital is never known exactly in advance. Entrepreneurs require a compensation for the risk involved, and lenders (and buyers of stock and other forms of financing) require a compensation for the risk involved in financing them. As a result, particularly in times which are uncertain and when people are particularly risk-averse, there can be a very large wedge between the natural “risk-free” rate of interest and the rate of return on capital. One consequence of having such a large wedge is that, even if the return on capital is necessarily expected to be positive, the natural interest rate can be negative.

When the natural interest rate is negative, since it’s impossible to cut nominal interest rates much below zero, the only way to get back to normal is to create an expectation of inflation. If the nominal interest rate is zero and the inflation rate is positive, then the real interest rate is negative; thus it is possible, with a sufficient amount of expected inflation, to set the real interest rate down to the negative natural rate. But how can that inflation be achieved? Wicksell argues that prices rise when the actual interest rate falls below the natural rate, but in order for that to happen, prices must already be expected to rise. Can a central bank pull itself up by its own bootstraps?

The answer is almost certainly yes, since nearly everyone agrees that a sufficiently reckless central bank will always be able to produce a high inflation rate. (Imagine the Fed buying up the entire national debt, along with all the private sector’s offerings of commercial paper, mortgages, corporate bonds, and so on. Eventually, there will be inflation.) The problem is that it is hard to estimate in advance how aggressive monetary policy needs to be in order to produce the needed expectation of inflation. Not only doesn’t the central bank know what actions would produce a given “happy medium” target between too-low and too-high inflation expectations; it never really even knows what the natural interest rate is, so it doesn’t know how much inflation would be enough to get the real rate down to the natural rate.

If the central bank estimates wrong and overshoots, it risks a period of very high, and unnecessarily high, inflation. If (as seems infinitely more likely to me) it estimates wrong and undershoots, it risks reducing its credibility, so that it becomes more difficult, subsequently, to achieve the necessary inflation rate. (Note BTW that if you take the Mankiw Rule as an estimate of the natural interest rate, then the Fed’s current 2% inflation target is not high enough: the Fed is on a course to fail and thereby reduce its subsequent credibility.)

The solution is to aim not for an inflation rate but for a price level (or, as I suggested in my previous post, a level of nominal GDP). A series of price level targets that rises over time, but that does not get revised when the central bank undershoots or overshoots, allows for policy that automatically becomes more aggressive (or less aggressive) as necessary. If the central bank undershoots the first price level target, the second target is still in place, and this means it must aim for a higher inflation rate. If it undershoots the second target, the third is still in place, and it must aim for yet a higher inflation rate. And so on. Eventually, it will (automatically) find the inflation rate that works.


DISCLOSURE: Through my investment and management role in a Treasury directional pooled investment vehicle and through my role as Chief Economist at Atlantic Asset Management, which generally manages fixed income portfolios for its clients, I have direct or indirect interests in various fixed income instruments, which may be impacted by the issues discussed herein. The views expressed herein are entirely my own opinions and may not represent the views of Atlantic Asset Management. This article should not be construed as investment advice, and is not an offer to participate in any investment strategy or product.

432 comments:

«Oldest   ‹Older   401 – 432 of 432
Games 2 Girls said...

Thank you for that information you article great article, I was very impressed about it, wish you would have stayed next share

raze3.co

Neeraj kumar said...

Thank you for sharing This knowledge.Excellently written article, if only all bloggers offered the same level of content as you, the internet would be a much better place. Please keep it up
UANEPFO

Slope Game Unblocked said...

Much informative article, and I really appreciate this info and willing for moreinteresting article like this.
slope

Madalin Stunt Cars 2 said...

Thanks for your post. There is a lot of information needed for me
happyroom.online

Madalin Stunt Cars 2 said...

I agree with what you share. It will be very useful information for everyone. Hope your next posts are as well
madalinstuntcars2.net

Slope Game said...

Your sharing is great. I am they are a lot of things from your article. That is a very interesting experience
slopegame.co

Basketball Legends said...

I think you are right to say so. Your share is great, I found a lot of things in

your post.
basketballlegends.co

Jasmine Thompson said...

Your sharing is great. I am they are a lot of things from your article. That is a very interesting experience
slopegame.co

Kabir Creation said...

Great Blog !!!
Visit us: lanyards manufacturers

online hotel booking sites said...

nice article.
if you are looking for cheap and best hotel deals in india please visit www.zoyostays.com

buy viagra generic said...

nice information. Thanks a lot for sharing such wonderful information.

subhash moond said...

Memorial Day Messages
Memorial Day Pictures
Memorial Day 2018 Images

Syem Park said...

CHLOROFORM DI JAKARTA
CHLOROPHYLL DI JAKARTA
LIQUID DI JAKARTA
TRIVAM DI JAKARTA
SLEELPING BEAUTY DI JAKARTA
CHLOROFORM DI MALUKU
CHLOROPHYLL DI MALUKU
LIQUID SEX DI MALUKU
TRIVAM DI MALUKU
SLEEPING BEAUTY DI MALUKU

SEO-SURAT said...

Very well written post. It will be useful to anybody who uses it, as well as myself. Keep doing what you are doing – looking forward to more posts.
Web Design Surat
Surat IT Company
SEO Company in Surat
Software Development Company in Surat
Seo services company in surat

Bahria Town Advice said...

Nice work. Keep sharing. Have a look to the the beautiful and spectacular views in Bahria Enclave by visiting Advice.pk

Advice.pk said...

Nice work. Keep sharing. Have a look to the the beautiful and spectacular views in Bahria Enclave by visiting Advice.pk

Smart Bazar said...

Your work is superb. The best <online shopping in Pakistan is now available on Smart Bazar.

Smart Bazar said...

your content is unique. online shopping in Pakistan with free home deliveryare now completely available on Pakistan’s no one online selling shop Smart Bazar.

safegenericrx said...

Nice blog thanks for sharing this informative blog with us.
Etizolam online USA

洛噷 said...

2018728 leilei3915
adidas yeezy shoes
ferragamo shoes sale
pandora jewelry
nike outlet
canada goose
fred perry clothing
uggs outlet
coach outlet online
pandora charms
coach outlet

Obat Herbal Denature said...

Menghilangkan Kutil Pada KelaminJadi Apa Pilihan Pengobatan Yang Baik Untuk Kutil Kelamin Pria? Beberapa metode pengobatan yang dapat dicoba untuk menyembuhkan penyakit ini adalah melalui penggunaan krim dan salep. Selain itu bisa juga dengan resep dokter lain yang tujuanya untuk memusnahkan kutil tersebut. untuk cara pemesanana silahkan kunjungblog kami

obat herbal untuk wasir eksternalWasir tidak dapat menyebabkan kanker dubur. Dalam beberapa kasus yang jarang

Shree said...

thank you very much gan , the article is very interesting that we can refer to. Shree

designer saree

Juliana Kho said...

1
2 agen sabung ayam s128
3
4 honda black cbet
5 daftar kis918 indonesia
6 osg77 slot online
7
8 joker123 slot

android training surat said...

Really Nice Post. Thank you Admin for this Great Article.

seoclassesonline said...

Thanks for posting and discussion of the topic, employment, interest, and money, it’s a beautiful blog, and provide an important topic so I really enjoyed this topic. Welcome to our company and provide the best services in SEO.
Seo company in Delhi
Best Seo company in Delhi
Seo company in Patna

jasmin rope said...

aynaaworld brings to you an outstanding range of online Indian luxury ethnic wear inspired by Ace fashion designers of India Our tailor made designs includes a wide range of bridal sarees, designer lehengas, party dresses other Indian luxury clothing for women and men

getkeralatourpackages said...

tour packages in Kerala Thank you so much for so sharing the blog of the employment, interest, and money, and provides great thought well said Kerala is one of the most beautiful places for honeymooners.Kerala tour packages It will help customers to plan their holiday in Kerala.honeymoon packages in Kerala Keep Posting.holiday packages in Kerala
keralapackages

SGintellect.com said...

Our Mission is offer affordable digital marketing agency in phoenix
seo company in arizona offer competitive pricing to all our customers and we do our best to retain our clientele.
Phoenix Digital Marketing Company is an award-winning marketing agency in Phoenix offering marketing strategy, lead gen, creative, web design, SEO, email.....

SGintellect.com said...

search engine optimization company focuses on providing clients with measurable results, no matter their industry.
There are best digital marketing agencies phoenix robust contenders across the country United Nations agency will facilitate your improve visibility, fine-tune SEO, and rector nice content.
Our search engine optimization phoenix provide a detailed report of your website SEO performance evaluation, as well as data about your traffic.
local seo phoenix provide effective Local SEO strategies to service providers across the globe.

Golden Slot Game said...

golden slot
goldenslot
สล็อตออนไลน์
โกลเด้นสล็อต

Unknown said...

This arrange is synchronous s informative impolites festivity to pity.Thanks for a very interesting blog.
good job....

Anonymous said...

Great info. I love all the posts. I really enjoyed. I would like more information about this, because it is very nice. Thanks for sharing.

places to visit in nepal

places to visit in mysore

«Oldest ‹Older   401 – 432 of 432   Newer› Newest»